TWLV-I: Analysis and Insights from Holistic Evaluation on Video Foundation Models
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents an in-depth analysis and holistic evaluation of video foundation models using the TWLV-I benchmark.
- It explores the capabilities, limitations, and potential of these models across a wide range of video understanding tasks.
- The evaluation framework provides a comprehensive assessment of video foundation models, offering insights to guide future research and development.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a detailed study of video foundation models, which are powerful artificial intelligence (AI) systems trained on large video datasets to perform a variety of video understanding tasks. The researchers used a benchmark called TWLV-I to thoroughly evaluate these models, examining how well they can perform tasks like video classification, video captioning, and video question answering.
The evaluation framework provided a comprehensive assessment of the video foundation models' capabilities, limitations, and potential. The researchers were able to identify areas where the models excel, as well as areas that need improvement. This information can be valuable for guiding future research and development efforts in the field of video understanding AI.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the TWLV-I (Thorough Whole-Learner Video Evaluation Initiative) benchmark, which is designed to provide a holistic assessment of video foundation models. The benchmark includes a diverse set of video understanding tasks, such as video classification, video captioning, and video question answering.
The researchers evaluated several state-of-the-art video foundation models using the TWLV-I benchmark. The models were assessed on a wide range of metrics, including task performance, sample efficiency, robustness, and computational efficiency. The results of the evaluation provided insights into the strengths, weaknesses, and potential of these models.
For example, the researchers found that the models performed well on tasks like video classification but struggled with more complex tasks like video captioning. They also discovered that the models were sensitive to certain types of video perturbations, indicating a need for improved robustness.
The TWLV-I benchmark and the insights from this study can inform the development of next-generation video foundation models and guide future research in the field of video understanding AI.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed evaluation of video foundation models, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research.
One limitation is that the evaluation was conducted on a limited set of video foundation models, and the researchers note that the performance of these models may not be representative of the entire field. Additionally, the benchmark tasks may not capture the full range of real-world video understanding challenges, and there may be other important metrics or evaluation criteria that were not considered.
The researchers also highlight the need for continued research on improving the robustness and sample efficiency of video foundation models, as well as their ability to handle complex video understanding tasks. They suggest that future work could explore techniques like few-shot learning, active learning, and multi-task learning to address these challenges.
Overall, the TWLV-I benchmark and the insights presented in this paper provide a valuable contribution to the field of video understanding AI, but there is still much work to be done to fully realize the potential of these powerful models.
Conclusion
The paper presents a comprehensive evaluation of video foundation models using the TWLV-I benchmark, offering valuable insights into the capabilities, limitations, and potential of these models. The evaluation framework and the findings from this study can inform the development of next-generation video understanding AI systems and guide future research in this rapidly evolving field.
The insights gained from this work can help researchers and developers design more robust, efficient, and capable video foundation models that can tackle a wider range of video understanding tasks. This, in turn, can lead to advancements in various applications, such as video analysis, video synthesis, and interactive video-based experiences.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
TWLV-I: Analysis and Insights from Holistic Evaluation on Video Foundation Models
Hyeongmin Lee, Jin-Young Kim, Kyungjune Baek, Jihwan Kim, Hyojun Go, Seongsu Ha, Seokjin Han, Jiho Jang, Raehyuk Jung, Daewoo Kim, GeunOh Kim, JongMok Kim, Jongseok Kim, Junwan Kim, Soonwoo Kwon, Jangwon Lee, Seungjoon Park, Minjoon Seo, Jay Suh, Jaehyuk Yi, Aiden Lee
In this work, we discuss evaluating video foundation models in a fair and robust manner. Unlike language or image foundation models, many video foundation models are evaluated with differing parameters (such as sampling rate, number of frames, pretraining steps, etc.), making fair and robust comparisons challenging. Therefore, we present a carefully designed evaluation framework for measuring two core capabilities of video comprehension: appearance and motion understanding. Our findings reveal that existing video foundation models, whether text-supervised like UMT or InternVideo2, or self-supervised like V-JEPA, exhibit limitations in at least one of these capabilities. As an alternative, we introduce TWLV-I, a new video foundation model that constructs robust visual representations for both motion- and appearance-based videos. Based on the average top-1 accuracy of linear probing on five action recognition benchmarks, pretrained only on publicly accessible datasets, our model shows a 4.6%p improvement compared to V-JEPA (ViT-L) and a 7.7%p improvement compared to UMT (ViT-L). Even when compared to much larger models, our model demonstrates a 7.2%p improvement compared to DFN (ViT-H), a 2.7%p improvement compared to V-JEPA (ViT-H) and a 2.8%p improvement compared to InternVideo2 (ViT-g). We provide embedding vectors obtained by TWLV-I from videos of several commonly used video benchmarks, along with evaluation source code that can directly utilize these embeddings. The code is available at https://github.com/twelvelabs-io/video-embeddings-evaluation-framework.
Read more8/26/2024
0
VideoEval: Comprehensive Benchmark Suite for Low-Cost Evaluation of Video Foundation Model
Xinhao Li, Zhenpeng Huang, Jing Wang, Kunchang Li, Limin Wang
With the growth of high-quality data and advancement in visual pre-training paradigms, Video Foundation Models (VFMs) have made significant progress recently, demonstrating their remarkable performance on traditional video understanding benchmarks. However, the existing benchmarks (e.g. Kinetics) and their evaluation protocols are often limited by relatively poor diversity, high evaluation costs, and saturated performance metrics. In this paper, we build a comprehensive benchmark suite to address these issues, namely VideoEval. Specifically, we establish the Video Task Adaption Benchmark (VidTAB) and the Video Embedding Benchmark (VidEB) from two perspectives: evaluating the task adaptability of VFMs under few-shot conditions and assessing their representation power by directly applying to downstream tasks. With VideoEval, we conduct a large-scale study on 20 popular open-source vision foundation models. Our study reveals some insightful findings on VFMs: 1) overall, current VFMs exhibit weak generalization across diverse tasks, 2) increasing video data, whether labeled or weakly-labeled video-text pairs, does not necessarily improve task performance, 3) the effectiveness of some pre-training paradigms may not be fully validated in previous benchmarks, and 4) combining different pre-training paradigms can help improve the generalization capabilities. We believe this study serves as an important complement to the current evaluation for VFMs and offers valuable insights for the future research.
Read more7/10/2024
0
InternVideo2: Scaling Foundation Models for Multimodal Video Understanding
Yi Wang, Kunchang Li, Xinhao Li, Jiashuo Yu, Yinan He, Chenting Wang, Guo Chen, Baoqi Pei, Ziang Yan, Rongkun Zheng, Jilan Xu, Zun Wang, Yansong Shi, Tianxiang Jiang, Songze Li, Hongjie Zhang, Yifei Huang, Yu Qiao, Yali Wang, Limin Wang
We introduce InternVideo2, a new family of video foundation models (ViFM) that achieve the state-of-the-art results in video recognition, video-text tasks, and video-centric dialogue. Our core design is a progressive training approach that unifies the masked video modeling, crossmodal contrastive learning, and next token prediction, scaling up the video encoder size to 6B parameters. At the data level, we prioritize spatiotemporal consistency by semantically segmenting videos and generating video-audio-speech captions. This improves the alignment between video and text. Through extensive experiments, we validate our designs and demonstrate superior performance on over 60 video and audio tasks. Notably, our model outperforms others on various video-related dialogue and long video understanding benchmarks, highlighting its ability to reason and comprehend longer contexts. Code and models are available at https://github.com/OpenGVLab/InternVideo/tree/main/InternVideo2/.
Read more8/15/2024
0
Foundation Models for Video Understanding: A Survey
Neelu Madan, Andreas Moegelmose, Rajat Modi, Yogesh S. Rawat, Thomas B. Moeslund
Video Foundation Models (ViFMs) aim to learn a general-purpose representation for various video understanding tasks. Leveraging large-scale datasets and powerful models, ViFMs achieve this by capturing robust and generic features from video data. This survey analyzes over 200 video foundational models, offering a comprehensive overview of benchmarks and evaluation metrics across 14 distinct video tasks categorized into 3 main categories. Additionally, we offer an in-depth performance analysis of these models for the 6 most common video tasks. We categorize ViFMs into three categories: 1) Image-based ViFMs, which adapt existing image models for video tasks, 2) Video-Based ViFMs, which utilize video-specific encoding methods, and 3) Universal Foundational Models (UFMs), which combine multiple modalities (image, video, audio, and text etc.) within a single framework. By comparing the performance of various ViFMs on different tasks, this survey offers valuable insights into their strengths and weaknesses, guiding future advancements in video understanding. Our analysis surprisingly reveals that image-based foundation models consistently outperform video-based models on most video understanding tasks. Additionally, UFMs, which leverage diverse modalities, demonstrate superior performance on video tasks. We share the comprehensive list of ViFMs studied in this work at: url{https://github.com/NeeluMadan/ViFM_Survey.git}
Read more5/8/2024