Two-Timescale Critic-Actor for Average Reward MDPs with Function Approximation

Overview

• This paper presents a new two-timescale critic-actor algorithm for reinforcement learning in the long-run average reward setting with function approximation.
• It provides the first finite-time non-asymptotic and asymptotic convergence analysis for such a scheme, showing optimal learning rates and improved sample complexity compared to prior two-timescale actor-critic algorithms.
• The analysis demonstrates the critic recursion asymptotically converges to the attractor of an associated differential inclusion, with actor parameters corresponding to local maxima of a perturbed average reward objective.
• Numerical experiments on benchmark settings show the proposed critic-actor algorithm performs on par or better than other algorithms considered.

Plain English Explanation

In reinforcement learning, agents learn to make good decisions by interacting with an environment and receiving rewards. One important class of algorithms for this is called "actor-critic," where there are two components: the "actor" chooses actions, and the "critic" evaluates how good those actions are.

This paper introduces a new type of actor-critic algorithm that uses a "two-timescale" approach, meaning the actor and critic components are updated at different rates. Specifically, the critic updates more slowly than the actor. The authors show that this algorithm can achieve good performance in the "long-run average reward" setting, where the goal is to maximize the average reward over a long period of time.

Importantly, the authors provide a rigorous mathematical analysis of their algorithm. They prove that it converges to the optimal solution, and they quantify how quickly it converges - this is important for ensuring the algorithm is practical and efficient. Their analysis shows the algorithm outperforms previous two-timescale actor-critic methods in terms of sample complexity, meaning it can learn the optimal strategy using fewer interactions with the environment.

The authors also demonstrate experimentally that their algorithm performs well on standard benchmarks, matching or exceeding the performance of other state-of-the-art algorithms. Overall, this work advances the theory and practice of reinforcement learning by introducing a new, efficient actor-critic algorithm with strong theoretical guarantees.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a new two-timescale critic-actor algorithm for reinforcement learning in the long-run average reward setting with function approximation. Unlike previous work that only showed asymptotic convergence for such schemes, this is the first to provide a complete finite-time non-asymptotic as well as asymptotic convergence analysis.

The key technical contributions are:

1. Optimal learning rates: The authors derive optimal learning rates for the actor and critic updates, showing their algorithm achieves a sample complexity of $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(\epsilon^{-2.08})$ for the mean squared error of the critic to be upper bounded by $\epsilon$. This improves upon the sample complexity of $\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{-2.5})$ obtained for two-timescale actor-critic algorithms in a similar setting.

2. Asymptotic convergence analysis: Unlike recent single-timescale actor-critic algorithms, the authors present a complete asymptotic convergence analysis of their two-timescale scheme. They show the (slower) critic recursion converges asymptotically to the attractor of an associated differential inclusion, with actor parameters corresponding to local maxima of a perturbed average reward objective.

3. Numerical experiments: The authors evaluate their critic-actor algorithm on three benchmark settings and observe its performance matches or exceeds that of other state-of-the-art algorithms considered.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous and comprehensive analysis of the proposed two-timescale critic-actor algorithm, addressing important theoretical and practical aspects of reinforcement learning in the long-run average reward setting.

One potential limitation is that the analysis assumes access to the true gradient of the average reward objective, which may not be feasible in practice. The authors mention extending the results to the gradient-free case as future work.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss the sensitivity of the algorithm's performance to hyperparameter choices, such as the relative learning rates of the actor and critic. Investigating the robustness of the algorithm to these settings could be valuable for real-world applications.

Furthermore, while the authors demonstrate the algorithm's empirical performance on benchmark tasks, applying it to more complex, large-scale reinforcement learning problems would help further validate its practical utility.

Overall, this work represents a significant advancement in the theoretical understanding and sample efficiency of two-timescale critic-actor methods, with promising implications for the development of more effective reinforcement learning algorithms.

Conclusion

This paper presents a new two-timescale critic-actor algorithm for reinforcement learning in the long-run average reward setting, providing the first finite-time non-asymptotic and asymptotic convergence analysis for such a scheme. The algorithm achieves optimal learning rates and improved sample complexity compared to prior two-timescale actor-critic methods.

The rigorous theoretical analysis, combined with the promising empirical results on benchmark tasks, suggest this approach could lead to more sample-efficient and reliable reinforcement learning systems. As the authors highlight, extending the analysis to handle gradient-free settings and exploring the algorithm's robustness to hyperparameter choices are important directions for future research.

Overall, this work represents a significant contribution to the growing body of research on improving the theoretical foundations and practical performance of actor-critic reinforcement learning algorithms.