Two-timescale Extragradient for Finding Local Minimax Points
2305.16242
0
0
🤔
Abstract
Minimax problems are notoriously challenging to optimize. However, we present that the two-timescale extragradient method can be a viable solution. By utilizing dynamical systems theory, we show that it converges to points that satisfy the second-order necessary condition of local minimax points, under mild conditions that the two-timescale gradient descent ascent fails to work. This work provably improves upon all previous results on finding local minimax points, by eliminating a crucial assumption that the Hessian with respect to the maximization variable is nondegenerate.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Minimax problems are challenging to optimize
- The paper presents the two-timescale extragradient method as a viable solution
- By using dynamical systems theory, the method is shown to converge to points satisfying the second-order necessary condition for local minimax points
- This work improves upon previous results by eliminating a crucial assumption that the Hessian with respect to the maximization variable is nondegenerate
Plain English Explanation
Minimax problems are a type of optimization challenge where you're trying to minimize one value while another value is trying to maximize. These types of problems are notoriously difficult to solve. However, this paper introduces a new method called the two-timescale extragradient method that can be an effective solution.
The key insight is that by using dynamical systems theory, the paper shows that this new method can converge to points that satisfy a key mathematical condition for being a local minimax point. This is an important advance, as previous methods required an assumption that the Hessian matrix (a mathematical object describing the curvature of the function) with respect to the maximization variable was not degenerate. This new method eliminates that assumption, representing a significant improvement over prior work on finding local minimax points.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the two-timescale extragradient method as a solution for optimizing minimax problems. By leveraging dynamical systems theory, the authors prove that this method converges to points satisfying the second-order necessary condition for local minimax points, under conditions where the two-timescale gradient descent ascent method fails.
The key innovation is that this method eliminates the requirement that the Hessian with respect to the maximization variable be nondegenerate, which was a crucial assumption in previous results on finding local minimax points. This represents a significant improvement over prior work in this area.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis and proof of convergence for the two-timescale extragradient method. However, the authors acknowledge that the practical implementation of this method may be challenging, as it requires careful tuning of the step sizes and careful initialization. Additionally, the paper does not provide any empirical evaluation of the method's performance compared to other state-of-the-art minimax optimization techniques, such as sharpness-aware minimization.
Further research could explore the practical applicability of this method, its performance on real-world minimax problems, and ways to make the implementation more robust and user-friendly. Additionally, extending this work to the non-convex-concave setting or exploring the connections to other minimax optimization techniques could yield important insights.
Conclusion
This paper presents a significant theoretical advancement in the field of minimax optimization by introducing the two-timescale extragradient method and proving its convergence to local minimax points under weaker assumptions than previous work. While the practical implementation may be challenging, this research opens up new avenues for exploring efficient and robust solutions to these notoriously difficult optimization problems, which have wide-ranging applications in machine learning, game theory, and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Explicit Second-Order Min-Max Optimization Methods with Optimal Convergence Guarantee
Tianyi Lin, Panayotis Mertikopoulos, Michael I. Jordan
0
0
We propose and analyze several inexact regularized Newton-type methods for finding a global saddle point of emph{convex-concave} unconstrained min-max optimization problems. Compared to first-order methods, our understanding of second-order methods for min-max optimization is relatively limited, as obtaining global rates of convergence with second-order information is much more involved. In this paper, we examine how second-order information can be used to speed up extra-gradient methods, even under inexactness. Specifically, we show that the proposed methods generate iterates that remain within a bounded set and that the averaged iterates converge to an $epsilon$-saddle point within $O(epsilon^{-2/3})$ iterations in terms of a restricted gap function. This matched the theoretically established lower bound in this context. We also provide a simple routine for solving the subproblem at each iteration, requiring a single Schur decomposition and $O(loglog(1/epsilon))$ calls to a linear system solver in a quasi-upper-triangular system. Thus, our method improves the existing line-search-based second-order min-max optimization methods by shaving off an $O(loglog(1/epsilon))$ factor in the required number of Schur decompositions. Finally, we present numerical experiments on synthetic and real data that demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed methods.
4/24/2024
🛠️
Adaptive and Optimal Second-order Optimistic Methods for Minimax Optimization
Ruichen Jiang, Ali Kavis, Qiujiang Jin, Sujay Sanghavi, Aryan Mokhtari
0
0
We propose adaptive, line search-free second-order methods with optimal rate of convergence for solving convex-concave min-max problems. By means of an adaptive step size, our algorithms feature a simple update rule that requires solving only one linear system per iteration, eliminating the need for line search or backtracking mechanisms. Specifically, we base our algorithms on the optimistic method and appropriately combine it with second-order information. Moreover, distinct from common adaptive schemes, we define the step size recursively as a function of the gradient norm and the prediction error in the optimistic update. We first analyze a variant where the step size requires knowledge of the Lipschitz constant of the Hessian. Under the additional assumption of Lipschitz continuous gradients, we further design a parameter-free version by tracking the Hessian Lipschitz constant locally and ensuring the iterates remain bounded. We also evaluate the practical performance of our algorithm by comparing it to existing second-order algorithms for minimax optimization.
6/5/2024
🏅
Fast Two-Time-Scale Stochastic Gradient Method with Applications in Reinforcement Learning
Sihan Zeng, Thinh T. Doan
0
0
Two-time-scale optimization is a framework introduced in Zeng et al. (2024) that abstracts a range of policy evaluation and policy optimization problems in reinforcement learning (RL). Akin to bi-level optimization under a particular type of stochastic oracle, the two-time-scale optimization framework has an upper level objective whose gradient evaluation depends on the solution of a lower level problem, which is to find the root of a strongly monotone operator. In this work, we propose a new method for solving two-time-scale optimization that achieves significantly faster convergence than the prior arts. The key idea of our approach is to leverage an averaging step to improve the estimates of the operators in both lower and upper levels before using them to update the decision variables. These additional averaging steps eliminate the direct coupling between the main variables, enabling the accelerated performance of our algorithm. We characterize the finite-time convergence rates of the proposed algorithm under various conditions of the underlying objective function, including strong convexity, convexity, Polyak-Lojasiewicz condition, and general non-convexity. These rates significantly improve over the best-known complexity of the standard two-time-scale stochastic approximation algorithm. When applied to RL, we show how the proposed algorithm specializes to novel online sample-based methods that surpass or match the performance of the existing state of the art. Finally, we support our theoretical results with numerical simulations in RL.
6/11/2024
🧠
Stochastic Newton Proximal Extragradient Method
Ruichen Jiang, Micha{l} Derezi'nski, Aryan Mokhtari
0
0
Stochastic second-order methods achieve fast local convergence in strongly convex optimization by using noisy Hessian estimates to precondition the gradient. However, these methods typically reach superlinear convergence only when the stochastic Hessian noise diminishes, increasing per-iteration costs over time. Recent work in [arXiv:2204.09266] addressed this with a Hessian averaging scheme that achieves superlinear convergence without higher per-iteration costs. Nonetheless, the method has slow global convergence, requiring up to $tilde{O}(kappa^2)$ iterations to reach the superlinear rate of $tilde{O}((1/t)^{t/2})$, where $kappa$ is the problem's condition number. In this paper, we propose a novel stochastic Newton proximal extragradient method that improves these bounds, achieving a faster global linear rate and reaching the same fast superlinear rate in $tilde{O}(kappa)$ iterations. We accomplish this by extending the Hybrid Proximal Extragradient (HPE) framework, achieving fast global and local convergence rates for strongly convex functions with access to a noisy Hessian oracle.
6/4/2024