Understanding and Mitigating Compositional Issues in Text-to-Image Generative Models
2406.07844
0
0
Abstract
Recent text-to-image diffusion-based generative models have the stunning ability to generate highly detailed and photo-realistic images and achieve state-of-the-art low FID scores on challenging image generation benchmarks. However, one of the primary failure modes of these text-to-image generative models is in composing attributes, objects, and their associated relationships accurately into an image. In our paper, we investigate this compositionality-based failure mode and highlight that imperfect text conditioning with CLIP text-encoder is one of the primary reasons behind the inability of these models to generate high-fidelity compositional scenes. In particular, we show that (i) there exists an optimal text-embedding space that can generate highly coherent compositional scenes which shows that the output space of the CLIP text-encoder is sub-optimal, and (ii) we observe that the final token embeddings in CLIP are erroneous as they often include attention contributions from unrelated tokens in compositional prompts. Our main finding shows that the best compositional improvements can be achieved (without harming the model's FID scores) by fine-tuning {it only} a simple linear projection on CLIP's representation space in Stable-Diffusion variants using a small set of compositional image-text pairs. This result demonstrates that the sub-optimality of the CLIP's output space is a major error source. We also show that re-weighting the erroneous attention contributions in CLIP can also lead to improved compositional performances, however these improvements are often less significant than those achieved by solely learning a linear projection head, highlighting erroneous attentions to be only a minor error source.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines compositional issues in text-to-image generative models, which are AI systems that create images from text descriptions.
- The researchers identify several challenges related to the ability of these models to properly compose and combine visual elements, and propose various techniques to mitigate these problems.
- The paper covers recent advancements in text-to-image generation, including the development of models like ComCLIP, Compositional Text-to-Image Generation, and RealCompo.
Plain English Explanation
Text-to-image generative models are AI systems that can create images based on text descriptions. For example, if you provide a description like "a dog playing fetch in a park", the model would generate a unique image matching that description.
However, these models can sometimes struggle with properly composing and combining the different visual elements required to depict complex scenes. For instance, the model might have trouble accurately placing the dog, the ball, and the park environment in a cohesive way.
This paper explores these "compositional issues" in detail and proposes several techniques to help mitigate them. The goal is to improve the ability of text-to-image models to generate images that are not just realistic, but also well-composed and true to the provided textual description.
Some of the key ideas discussed include using specialized training approaches like Subject-Enhanced Attention Guidance and dense blob representations to better capture the relationships between different visual elements. The paper also explores ways to balance realism and compositionality to create more coherent and faithful images.
Overall, this research aims to advance the state-of-the-art in text-to-image generation and make these models more robust and effective at depicting complex visual scenes.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by outlining the key challenges faced by text-to-image generative models in terms of compositionality. The authors note that while these models have made impressive strides in generating realistic-looking images, they often struggle to properly combine and arrange the various visual elements required to depict more complex scenes.
To address this, the researchers explore several novel technical approaches. One is the use of Subject-Enhanced Attention Guidance, which aims to better capture the relationships between different objects and entities in the generated images. Another is the dense blob representation, which encodes spatial and semantic information about visual components to facilitate more coherent composition.
The paper also discusses the ComCLIP and RealCompo models, which incorporate techniques to balance realism and compositionality in the generated images. By carefully managing this tradeoff, these models are able to produce visuals that are both faithful to the input text and visually cohesive.
Through extensive experiments, the researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of these approaches in improving the compositional quality of text-to-image generation. They provide detailed quantitative and qualitative analyses to showcase the benefits of their techniques compared to existing methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thoughtful and comprehensive analysis of the compositional challenges faced by text-to-image generative models. The researchers identify several crucial issues, such as the difficulty in properly arranging visual elements and maintaining coherence, and propose innovative solutions to address these problems.
One potential limitation of the work is that it primarily focuses on improving compositional quality, without explicitly considering the overall realism or artistic merit of the generated images. While the proposed techniques do aim to balance realism and compositionality, there may be cases where prioritizing composition could come at the expense of other desirable qualities.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the computational and memory requirements of the various models and techniques discussed. As text-to-image generation systems become more complex, the scalability and efficiency of these approaches may become an important consideration.
Further research could also explore the impact of these compositional techniques on specific application domains, such as generating illustrations, diagrams, or other visually-rich content. Understanding how these models perform in diverse real-world scenarios would provide valuable insights for practitioners.
Overall, this paper represents a significant contribution to the field of text-to-image generation, and the proposed methods offer a promising path forward for addressing the crucial challenge of compositional coherence. As the technology continues to evolve, continued exploration of these issues will be essential for unlocking the full potential of these powerful AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper delves into the compositional challenges faced by text-to-image generative models and presents several innovative techniques to address these problems. By focusing on improving the ability of these models to properly compose and combine visual elements, the researchers aim to enhance the overall coherence and fidelity of the generated images.
The proposed approaches, such as Subject-Enhanced Attention Guidance, dense blob representations, and balanced realism-compositionality modeling, demonstrate the potential to significantly advance the state-of-the-art in text-to-image generation. As these models become more widely adopted and integrated into various applications, addressing compositional issues will be crucial for unlocking their full potential and delivering visually compelling and meaningful images.
The insights and methods discussed in this paper represent an important step forward in the field of AI-powered visual content creation. By continuing to explore and refine these techniques, researchers and developers can work towards text-to-image models that not only generate realistic images, but also accurately convey the intended meaning and composition of the original textual description.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🖼️
ComCLIP: Training-Free Compositional Image and Text Matching
Kenan Jiang, Xuehai He, Ruize Xu, Xin Eric Wang
0
0
Contrastive Language-Image Pretraining (CLIP) has demonstrated great zero-shot performance for matching images and text. However, it is still challenging to adapt vision-lanaguage pretrained models like CLIP to compositional image and text matching -- a more challenging image and text matching task requiring the model understanding of compositional word concepts and visual components. Towards better compositional generalization in zero-shot image and text matching, in this paper, we study the problem from a causal perspective: the erroneous semantics of individual entities are essentially confounders that cause the matching failure. Therefore, we propose a novel textbf{textit{training-free}} compositional CLIP model (ComCLIP). ComCLIP disentangles input images into subjects, objects, and action sub-images and composes CLIP's vision encoder and text encoder to perform evolving matching over compositional text embedding and sub-image embeddings. In this way, ComCLIP can mitigate spurious correlations introduced by the pretrained CLIP models and dynamically evaluate the importance of each component. Experiments on four compositional image-text matching datasets: SVO, ComVG, Winoground, and VL-checklist, and two general image-text retrieval datasets: Flick30K, and MSCOCO demonstrate the effectiveness of our plug-and-play method, which boosts the textbf{textit{zero-shot}} inference ability of CLIP, SLIP, and BLIP2 even without further training or fine-tuning. Our codes can be found at https://github.com/eric-ai-lab/ComCLIP.
4/16/2024
TokenCompose: Text-to-Image Diffusion with Token-level Supervision
Zirui Wang, Zhizhou Sha, Zheng Ding, Yilin Wang, Zhuowen Tu
0
0
We present TokenCompose, a Latent Diffusion Model for text-to-image generation that achieves enhanced consistency between user-specified text prompts and model-generated images. Despite its tremendous success, the standard denoising process in the Latent Diffusion Model takes text prompts as conditions only, absent explicit constraint for the consistency between the text prompts and the image contents, leading to unsatisfactory results for composing multiple object categories. TokenCompose aims to improve multi-category instance composition by introducing the token-wise consistency terms between the image content and object segmentation maps in the finetuning stage. TokenCompose can be applied directly to the existing training pipeline of text-conditioned diffusion models without extra human labeling information. By finetuning Stable Diffusion, the model exhibits significant improvements in multi-category instance composition and enhanced photorealism for its generated images. Project link: https://mlpc-ucsd.github.io/TokenCompose
6/26/2024
🛸
Compositional Text-to-Image Generation with Dense Blob Representations
Weili Nie, Sifei Liu, Morteza Mardani, Chao Liu, Benjamin Eckart, Arash Vahdat
0
0
Existing text-to-image models struggle to follow complex text prompts, raising the need for extra grounding inputs for better controllability. In this work, we propose to decompose a scene into visual primitives - denoted as dense blob representations - that contain fine-grained details of the scene while being modular, human-interpretable, and easy-to-construct. Based on blob representations, we develop a blob-grounded text-to-image diffusion model, termed BlobGEN, for compositional generation. Particularly, we introduce a new masked cross-attention module to disentangle the fusion between blob representations and visual features. To leverage the compositionality of large language models (LLMs), we introduce a new in-context learning approach to generate blob representations from text prompts. Our extensive experiments show that BlobGEN achieves superior zero-shot generation quality and better layout-guided controllability on MS-COCO. When augmented by LLMs, our method exhibits superior numerical and spatial correctness on compositional image generation benchmarks. Project page: https://blobgen-2d.github.io.
5/15/2024
🛸
Training-free Subject-Enhanced Attention Guidance for Compositional Text-to-image Generation
Shengyuan Liu, Bo Wang, Ye Ma, Te Yang, Xipeng Cao, Quan Chen, Han Li, Di Dong, Peng Jiang
0
0
Existing subject-driven text-to-image generation models suffer from tedious fine-tuning steps and struggle to maintain both text-image alignment and subject fidelity. For generating compositional subjects, it often encounters problems such as object missing and attribute mixing, where some subjects in the input prompt are not generated or their attributes are incorrectly combined. To address these limitations, we propose a subject-driven generation framework and introduce training-free guidance to intervene in the generative process during inference time. This approach strengthens the attention map, allowing for precise attribute binding and feature injection for each subject. Notably, our method exhibits exceptional zero-shot generation ability, especially in the challenging task of compositional generation. Furthermore, we propose a novel metric GroundingScore to evaluate subject alignment thoroughly. The obtained quantitative results serve as compelling evidence showcasing the effectiveness of our proposed method. The code will be released soon.
5/14/2024