Understanding the User: An Intent-Based Ranking Dataset

Overview

• As information retrieval (IR) systems evolve, accurate evaluation and benchmarking become crucial.
• Many web search datasets, like MS MARCO, provide short keyword queries without intent or descriptions, making it challenging to understand the underlying information need.
• This paper proposes an approach to augment such datasets by annotating informative query descriptions, focusing on the TREC-DL-21 and TREC-DL-22 benchmark datasets.

Plain English Explanation

When you search for something online, you might type in a few keywords, like "best restaurants near me." But behind those simple keywords, there's usually an underlying intent or information need that the search engine needs to understand to give you the best results. For example, you might be looking for highly rated restaurants, restaurants that are open now, or restaurants that offer delivery.

The researchers in this paper recognized that many popular web search datasets, like MS MARCO, only provide the keyword queries without any additional context about the user's intent. This makes it hard for researchers and developers to truly understand what the user is looking for and how to build better search and information retrieval systems.

To address this, the researchers came up with a way to add more detailed descriptions to the queries in two prominent benchmark datasets: TREC-DL-21 and TREC-DL-22. They used advanced language models to analyze the queries and extract the key semantic elements, then used that information to create rich, contextual descriptions of the user's intent.

For example, the query "best restaurants near me" might get a description like "Find highly rated, open-now restaurants that offer delivery or takeout within a 5-mile radius of my current location."

By creating these more informative query descriptions, the researchers hope to provide a valuable resource for evaluating and improving search and information retrieval systems, such as by helping with tasks like ranking, query rewriting, or other areas.

Technical Explanation

The researchers' approach involves leveraging state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) to analyze and comprehend the implicit intent within individual queries from benchmark datasets. By extracting key semantic elements, such as the user's information need, context, and preferences, they construct detailed and contextually rich descriptions for these queries.

To validate the generated query descriptions, the researchers employ crowdsourcing as a reliable means of obtaining diverse human perspectives on the accuracy and informativeness of the descriptions. This crowdsourced evaluation data can then be used as a benchmark for tasks like ranking, query rewriting, or other information retrieval applications.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that their approach relies on the capabilities of the LLMs used, and the quality of the generated descriptions may be influenced by the model's training data and architecture. Additionally, the crowdsourcing validation process, while helpful, may still introduce some subjectivity and bias in the evaluation.

Further research could explore ways to improve the robustness and generalizability of the query description generation, such as by incorporating user feedback or other contextual signals. Evaluating the impact of these query descriptions on downstream information retrieval tasks would also be an interesting area for future study.

Conclusion

This research presents a novel approach to augmenting web search benchmark datasets by annotating queries with informative descriptions that capture the underlying user intent. By leveraging advanced language models and crowdsourcing, the researchers have created a valuable resource for evaluating and improving information retrieval systems.

The availability of these richer query descriptions has the potential to drive significant advancements in areas like purchase intention comprehension, intent-aware recommendation, and hybrid semantic search. This work highlights the importance of understanding user intent in information retrieval and the value of creating high-quality benchmark datasets to support ongoing research and development in this field.