Universality in Transfer Learning for Linear Models
0
🔄
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Transfer learning is a useful approach for problems with limited data or costly data collection.
- One common transfer learning method is model-based, where a model is pre-trained on data from an easier-to-acquire source distribution, then fine-tuned on a small dataset from the target distribution.
- This paper studies transfer learning in linear models for regression and binary classification, using stochastic gradient descent (SGD) to fine-tune pre-trained models on small target datasets.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at a technique called transfer learning that can be useful when you don't have a lot of data to train a model, or when collecting data is expensive. The idea is to start with a model that has already been trained on some other, more easily available data. Then, you fine-tune that pre-trained model by doing a bit more training on the specific dataset you care about.
The researchers focused on using this approach with linear models, which are a relatively simple type of machine learning model. They looked at how well this transfer learning approach works for both regression problems (where the model predicts a number) and binary classification problems (where the model predicts one of two categories).
The key insight is that the performance of the fine-tuned model depends on how "close" the original dataset is to the new dataset you care about. If they are similar, then the fine-tuned model should work well even with just a small amount of training on the new data. The paper provides a rigorous mathematical analysis to understand exactly when this transfer learning approach will be better than just training a new model from scratch.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes the use of stochastic gradient descent (SGD) to fine-tune a pre-trained linear model on a small dataset from the target distribution. They provide an exact and rigorous analysis of the generalization error (for regression) and classification error (for binary classification) of the pre-trained and fine-tuned models.
The key theoretical insight is that the performance of the fine-tuned model depends only on the first and second order statistics of the target distribution, and not on any other details. This extends prior work that made stronger Gaussian assumptions.
The analysis shows that under certain conditions, the fine-tuned model can outperform the pre-trained model, even when the target dataset is small. This provides a theoretical foundation for the empirical success of transfer learning in practice.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes several important contributions, including a rigorous mathematical analysis of transfer learning in linear models and the insight that performance depends only on low-order statistics of the data. This extends prior work that relied on stronger distributional assumptions.
However, the analysis is limited to linear models, and it remains an open question how these results would extend to more complex non-linear models, which are commonly used in practice. Additionally, the paper does not consider potential issues like domain shift between the source and target distributions.
Further research could explore the performance of transfer learning in other model families, as well as techniques for mitigating domain shift, such as domain adaptation. It would also be valuable to see empirical validations of the theoretical insights on real-world datasets.
Conclusion
This paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for the use of transfer learning in linear models, showing that it can outperform training from scratch under certain conditions. The key insight is that performance depends only on low-order statistics of the data, rather than detailed distributional assumptions.
While limited to linear models, this work lays the groundwork for a better understanding of the principles underlying the success of transfer learning, which has become an increasingly important tool for building effective machine learning models, especially in domains with limited data availability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔄
0
New!Universality in Transfer Learning for Linear Models
Reza Ghane, Danil Akhtiamov, Babak Hassibi
Transfer learning is an attractive framework for problems where there is a paucity of data, or where data collection is costly. One common approach to transfer learning is referred to as model-based, and involves using a model that is pretrained on samples from a source distribution, which is easier to acquire, and then fine-tuning the model on a few samples from the target distribution. The hope is that, if the source and target distributions are ``close, then the fine-tuned model will perform well on the target distribution even though it has seen only a few samples from it. In this work, we study the problem of transfer learning in linear models for both regression and binary classification. In particular, we consider the use of stochastic gradient descent (SGD) on a linear model initialized with pretrained weights and using a small training data set from the target distribution. In the asymptotic regime of large models, we provide an exact and rigorous analysis and relate the generalization errors (in regression) and classification errors (in binary classification) for the pretrained and fine-tuned models. In particular, we give conditions under which the fine-tuned model outperforms the pretrained one. An important aspect of our work is that all the results are universal, in the sense that they depend only on the first and second order statistics of the target distribution. They thus extend well beyond the standard Gaussian assumptions commonly made in the literature.
Read more10/4/2024
🔄
0
The Common Intuition to Transfer Learning Can Win or Lose: Case Studies for Linear Regression
Yehuda Dar, Daniel LeJeune, Richard G. Baraniuk
We study a fundamental transfer learning process from source to target linear regression tasks, including overparameterized settings where there are more learned parameters than data samples. The target task learning is addressed by using its training data together with the parameters previously computed for the source task. We define a transfer learning approach to the target task as a linear regression optimization with a regularization on the distance between the to-be-learned target parameters and the already-learned source parameters. We analytically characterize the generalization performance of our transfer learning approach and demonstrate its ability to resolve the peak in generalization errors in double descent phenomena of the minimum L2-norm solution to linear regression. Moreover, we show that for sufficiently related tasks, the optimally tuned transfer learning approach can outperform the optimally tuned ridge regression method, even when the true parameter vector conforms to an isotropic Gaussian prior distribution. Namely, we demonstrate that transfer learning can beat the minimum mean square error (MMSE) solution of the independent target task. Our results emphasize the ability of transfer learning to extend the solution space to the target task and, by that, to have an improved MMSE solution. We formulate the linear MMSE solution to our transfer learning setting and point out its key differences from the common design philosophy to transfer learning.
Read more6/3/2024
0
Understanding Optimal Feature Transfer via a Fine-Grained Bias-Variance Analysis
Yufan Li, Subhabrata Sen, Ben Adlam
In the transfer learning paradigm models learn useful representations (or features) during a data-rich pretraining stage, and then use the pretrained representation to improve model performance on data-scarce downstream tasks. In this work, we explore transfer learning with the goal of optimizing downstream performance. We introduce a simple linear model that takes as input an arbitrary pretrained feature transform. We derive exact asymptotics of the downstream risk and its fine-grained bias-variance decomposition. Our finding suggests that using the ground-truth featurization can result in double-divergence of the asymptotic risk, indicating that it is not necessarily optimal for downstream performance. We then identify the optimal pretrained representation by minimizing the asymptotic downstream risk averaged over an ensemble of downstream tasks. Our analysis reveals the relative importance of learning the task-relevant features and structures in the data covariates and characterizes how each contributes to controlling the downstream risk from a bias-variance perspective. Moreover, we uncover a phase transition phenomenon where the optimal pretrained representation transitions from hard to soft selection of relevant features and discuss its connection to principal component regression.
Read more4/22/2024
0
Transfer Learning in $ell_1$ Regularized Regression: Hyperparameter Selection Strategy based on Sharp Asymptotic Analysis
Koki Okajima, Tomoyuki Obuchi
Transfer learning techniques aim to leverage information from multiple related datasets to enhance prediction quality against a target dataset. Such methods have been adopted in the context of high-dimensional sparse regression, and some Lasso-based algorithms have been invented: Trans-Lasso and Pretraining Lasso are such examples. These algorithms require the statistician to select hyperparameters that control the extent and type of information transfer from related datasets. However, selection strategies for these hyperparameters, as well as the impact of these choices on the algorithm's performance, have been largely unexplored. To address this, we conduct a thorough, precise study of the algorithm in a high-dimensional setting via an asymptotic analysis using the replica method. Our approach reveals a surprisingly simple behavior of the algorithm: Ignoring one of the two types of information transferred to the fine-tuning stage has little effect on generalization performance, implying that efforts for hyperparameter selection can be significantly reduced. Our theoretical findings are also empirically supported by real-world applications on the IMDb dataset.
Read more9/27/2024