VerityMath: Advancing Mathematical Reasoning by Self-Verification Through Unit Consistency

Overview

• Large language models (LLMs) are demonstrating increasing proficiency in mathematical reasoning, including solving math word problems.
• Open-source LLMs have shown limited progress in this area, and the challenges they face are not well-studied.
• This paper examines the performance of strong open-source LLMs on math word problems using program-based solving techniques.
• The authors identify a category of problems involving quantities with multiple units as a significant challenge for these models.
• To address this, the authors propose a systematic approach using Unit Consistency Programs (UCPs) to ensure consistency of units during mathematical operations.

Plain English Explanation

Large language models, which are powerful AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text, are getting better at solving math problems. Some closed-source models, like OpenAI's GPT-4 and a model called Claude, have shown impressive results in solving math word problems.

However, open-source language models, which are available for anyone to use and study, have not made as much progress in this area. The researchers in this paper wanted to understand the specific challenges these open-source models face when solving math word problems.

They tested three strong open-source language models - Llama 2, Code Llama, and Mistral - on a variety of math word problems. They found that the models struggled the most with problems involving quantities that had different units, like feet and inches or dollars and cents.

To address this, the researchers developed something called Unit Consistency Programs (UCPs). These are math word problems that have been annotated with information about the units of each quantity, and with routines to check that the units are used correctly during the math operations.

The researchers then fine-tuned the three language models using the UCPs, creating "VerityMath" variants of the models. They found that this approach slightly underperformed compared to not using the UCPs. The researchers then analyzed the errors to try to understand why and suggest ways to improve the approach in the future.

Technical Explanation

The paper examines the performance of open-source large language models (LLMs), including Llama 2 (7B), Code Llama (7B), and Mistral (7B), on math word problem-solving using program-based techniques. The authors identify challenges these models face, particularly with problems involving quantities spanning multiple units.

To address this, the researchers proposed a systematic approach using Unit Consistency Programs (UCPs), an annotated dataset of math word problems paired with programs containing unit specifications and unit verification routines. The authors fine-tuned the Llama 2 (7B), Code Llama (7B), and Mistral (7B) models with the UCPs to produce their "VerityMath" variants.

The findings indicate that the VerityMath approach, which incorporates unit consistency, currently slightly underperforms compared to an approach that does not. The researchers conducted an in-depth error analysis to understand the reasons behind this and suggest options for future improvements.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a valuable contribution by identifying a specific challenge faced by open-source LLMs in solving math word problems - the handling of quantities with multiple units. The proposed solution of using Unit Consistency Programs is a systematic approach to address this issue.

However, the finding that the VerityMath approach slightly underperforms compared to the baseline raises questions about the effectiveness of this solution. The authors' error analysis and suggestions for future improvements are helpful, but more research may be needed to fully understand the limitations and optimize the approach.

Additionally, the paper focuses on a specific set of open-source LLMs, and it would be interesting to see how the findings and proposed solutions apply to a broader range of models, including closed-source ones. Expanding the scope of the research could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the challenges and potential solutions in this area.

Conclusion

This paper highlights the progress of LLMs in mathematical reasoning and the specific challenges they face with math word problems involving quantities across multiple units. The authors' proposed solution of using Unit Consistency Programs is a promising approach, though the current underperformance compared to the baseline suggests room for further refinement and investigation.

The research contributes to the ongoing efforts to improve the mathematical capabilities of LLMs, which could have significant implications for various applications, from education to scientific research. As the field of large language models continues to evolve, studies like this one will be valuable in shaping the future development and real-world deployment of these powerful AI systems.