Video Editing for Video Retrieval
0
🧠
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Pre-training vision-language models can provide significant benefits for video-text retrieval from large-scale web videos.
- However, fine-tuning these models still plays a critical role, requiring manually annotated video clips with start and end times, which is labor-intensive.
- To address this issue, the paper explores using a cheaper source of annotations - single timestamps - to warm up a retrieval model.
- A video clip editing method is then proposed to refine the initial rough boundaries and improve retrieval performance.
- This approach is model-agnostic and applicable to various retrieval models.
Plain English Explanation
Video-text retrieval is the task of finding relevant videos based on text queries, or vice versa. Pre-training vision-language models on large-scale web data can provide a strong starting point for this task. However, to get the best performance, these models still need to be fine-tuned on manually annotated video clips, where the start and end times of the relevant segments are provided. This manual annotation process is time-consuming and expensive.
To address this, the researchers explored using a cheaper source of annotations - single timestamps - to initialize the video clips for fine-tuning. They developed a video clip editing method that refines these initial rough boundaries to improve the overall retrieval performance. This involves a "student-teacher" network, where the teacher model edits the training set clips, and the student model learns from the edited clips.
The key idea is to leverage the single timestamp annotations as a starting point, and then automatically refine the video clip boundaries to get better retrieval results, without requiring the same level of manual effort as full start and end time annotations. This approach can be used with different retrieval models, making it a flexible and widely applicable technique.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a method to address the issue of the high cost of manually annotating video clips with start and end times for video-text retrieval tasks. They explore using single timestamps as a cheaper source of annotations to initialize video clips, and then refine these initial boundaries using a video clip editing approach.
The overall workflow is as follows:
- Initialization: The researchers use a heuristic to initialize video clips from the single timestamp annotations, creating rough clip boundaries.
- Clip Editing: They then introduce a "student-teacher" network for video clip editing. The teacher model is used to edit the clips in the training set, and the student model learns from these edited clips.
- Model Training: The retrieval model is trained on the edited clips, with the teacher's weights updated from the student's after the student's performance increases.
This approach is model-agnostic and can be applied to various state-of-the-art retrieval models, such as COOT, VideoCLIP, and CLIP4Clip. Experiments on three video retrieval datasets (YouCook2, DiDeMo, and ActivityNet-Captions) show that the edited clips consistently improve retrieval performance over the initial clips across all the tested models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and practical approach to address the challenge of obtaining high-quality video clip annotations for video-text retrieval tasks. By leveraging single timestamp annotations as a cheaper source of data, and then automatically refining the clip boundaries, the method can improve retrieval performance without the same level of manual effort required for full start and end time annotations.
One potential limitation is that the effectiveness of the clip editing method may depend on the quality and characteristics of the initial single timestamp annotations. If the timestamps are not well-aligned with the relevant video content, the clip editing process may struggle to produce high-quality boundaries. Further research could explore strategies to better utilize the single timestamp information or incorporate additional cues to improve the initial clip initialization.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach across multiple retrieval models, it would be valuable to understand the model-specific factors that influence the performance gains from the edited clips. This could help guide the selection or development of retrieval models that are particularly well-suited to benefit from this type of clip editing technique.
Overall, the proposed method represents an important step forward in reducing the annotation burden for video-text retrieval tasks, and the findings suggest promising avenues for further research and development in this area.
Conclusion
This paper presents an innovative approach to address the challenge of obtaining high-quality video clip annotations for video-text retrieval tasks. By leveraging single timestamp annotations as a cheaper source of data and then automatically refining the clip boundaries using a student-teacher network, the method can improve retrieval performance without the same level of manual effort required for full start and end time annotations.
The findings demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach across multiple state-of-the-art retrieval models, suggesting that it could be a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working on video-text understanding and retrieval. As the field continues to advance, techniques like this that can reduce the annotation burden while maintaining high performance will become increasingly important for enabling the widespread adoption and real-world application of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
0
Video Editing for Video Retrieval
Bin Zhu, Kevin Flanagan, Adriano Fragomeni, Michael Wray, Dima Damen
Though pre-training vision-language models have demonstrated significant benefits in boosting video-text retrieval performance from large-scale web videos, fine-tuning still plays a critical role with manually annotated clips with start and end times, which requires considerable human effort. To address this issue, we explore an alternative cheaper source of annotations, single timestamps, for video-text retrieval. We initialise clips from timestamps in a heuristic way to warm up a retrieval model. Then a video clip editing method is proposed to refine the initial rough boundaries to improve retrieval performance. A student-teacher network is introduced for video clip editing. The teacher model is employed to edit the clips in the training set whereas the student model trains on the edited clips. The teacher weights are updated from the student's after the student's performance increases. Our method is model agnostic and applicable to any retrieval models. We conduct experiments based on three state-of-the-art retrieval models, COOT, VideoCLIP and CLIP4Clip. Experiments conducted on three video retrieval datasets, YouCook2, DiDeMo and ActivityNet-Captions show that our edited clips consistently improve retrieval performance over initial clips across all the three retrieval models.
Read more9/10/2024
🖼️
0
Learning text-to-video retrieval from image captioning
Lucas Ventura, Cordelia Schmid, Gul Varol
We describe a protocol to study text-to-video retrieval training with unlabeled videos, where we assume (i) no access to labels for any videos, i.e., no access to the set of ground-truth captions, but (ii) access to labeled images in the form of text. Using image expert models is a realistic scenario given that annotating images is cheaper therefore scalable, in contrast to expensive video labeling schemes. Recently, zero-shot image experts such as CLIP have established a new strong baseline for video understanding tasks. In this paper, we make use of this progress and instantiate the image experts from two types of models: a text-to-image retrieval model to provide an initial backbone, and image captioning models to provide supervision signal into unlabeled videos. We show that automatically labeling video frames with image captioning allows text-to-video retrieval training. This process adapts the features to the target domain at no manual annotation cost, consequently outperforming the strong zero-shot CLIP baseline. During training, we sample captions from multiple video frames that best match the visual content, and perform a temporal pooling over frame representations by scoring frames according to their relevance to each caption. We conduct extensive ablations to provide insights and demonstrate the effectiveness of this simple framework by outperforming the CLIP zero-shot baselines on text-to-video retrieval on three standard datasets, namely ActivityNet, MSR-VTT, and MSVD.
Read more4/29/2024
👁️
0
Retrieval Enhanced Zero-Shot Video Captioning
Yunchuan Ma, Laiyun Qing, Guorong Li, Yuankai Qi, Quan Z. Sheng, Qingming Huang
Despite the significant progress of fully-supervised video captioning, zero-shot methods remain much less explored. In this paper, we propose to take advantage of existing pre-trained large-scale vision and language models to directly generate captions with test time adaptation. Specifically, we bridge video and text using three key models: a general video understanding model XCLIP, a general image understanding model CLIP, and a text generation model GPT-2, due to their source-code availability. The main challenge is how to enable the text generation model to be sufficiently aware of the content in a given video so as to generate corresponding captions. To address this problem, we propose using learnable tokens as a communication medium between frozen GPT-2 and frozen XCLIP as well as frozen CLIP. Differing from the conventional way to train these tokens with training data, we update these tokens with pseudo-targets of the inference data under several carefully crafted loss functions which enable the tokens to absorb video information catered for GPT-2. This procedure can be done in just a few iterations (we use 16 iterations in the experiments) and does not require ground truth data. Extensive experimental results on three widely used datasets, MSR-VTT, MSVD, and VATEX, show 4% to 20% improvements in terms of the main metric CIDEr compared to the existing state-of-the-art methods.
Read more5/14/2024
0
Optimizing CLIP Models for Image Retrieval with Maintained Joint-Embedding Alignment
Konstantin Schall, Kai Uwe Barthel, Nico Hezel, Klaus Jung
Contrastive Language and Image Pairing (CLIP), a transformative method in multimedia retrieval, typically trains two neural networks concurrently to generate joint embeddings for text and image pairs. However, when applied directly, these models often struggle to differentiate between visually distinct images that have similar captions, resulting in suboptimal performance for image-based similarity searches. This paper addresses the challenge of optimizing CLIP models for various image-based similarity search scenarios, while maintaining their effectiveness in text-based search tasks such as text-to-image retrieval and zero-shot classification. We propose and evaluate two novel methods aimed at refining the retrieval capabilities of CLIP without compromising the alignment between text and image embeddings. The first method involves a sequential fine-tuning process: initially optimizing the image encoder for more precise image retrieval and subsequently realigning the text encoder to these optimized image embeddings. The second approach integrates pseudo-captions during the retrieval-optimization phase to foster direct alignment within the embedding space. Through comprehensive experiments, we demonstrate that these methods enhance CLIP's performance on various benchmarks, including image retrieval, k-NN classification, and zero-shot text-based classification, while maintaining robustness in text-to-image retrieval. Our optimized models permit maintaining a single embedding per image, significantly simplifying the infrastructure needed for large-scale multi-modal similarity search systems.
Read more9/4/2024