WangLab at MEDIQA-M3G 2024: Multimodal Medical Answer Generation using Large Language Models

Overview

• This paper describes two standalone solutions submitted by the authors to the MEDIQA2024 Multilingual and Multimodal Medical Answer Generation (M3G) shared task.
• The first solution involved using the Claude 3 Opus API in a two-step process, while the second solution trained a CLIP-style image-disease label joint embedding for image classification.
• These two solutions achieved the top two spots on the competition leaderboard, outperforming the next best solution by a significant margin.
• The authors also discuss insights gained from post-competition experiments and identify the multi-stage LLM approach and the CLIP image classification approach as promising avenues for further investigation.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes two different approaches the authors used to tackle a challenging task in the field of medical AI. The first approach involved using an existing language model called Claude 3 Opus in a two-step process to generate answers to medical questions. The second approach trained a new model that could classify images of medical conditions and diseases.

Both of these approaches performed very well in a competition where teams competed to see who could best answer medical questions using both text and images. In fact, the authors' two approaches came in first and second place, significantly outperforming the next best solution.

After the competition, the authors did some additional experiments and identified the key strengths of each approach. They believe that using multiple language models in sequence (PEFOMED: Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Multimodal Large Language Models) and training models to classify medical images (MedExpQA: Multilingual Benchmarking of Large Language Models on Medical Question Answering) are promising directions for further research in this area.

Technical Explanation

The paper describes two standalone solutions the authors submitted to the MEDIQA2024 Multilingual and Multimodal Medical Answer Generation (M3G) shared task.

The first solution involved using the Claude 3 Opus API in a two-step process. First, the model was used to generate a preliminary answer to a medical question. Then, the model was fine-tuned on a dataset of medical question-answer pairs to produce a refined final answer. This multi-stage LLM approach (WangLab at MEDIQA-CORR 2024: Optimized LLM for Multilingual Medical QA) allowed the model to leverage the broad knowledge of the pre-trained Claude 3 Opus while also incorporating task-specific medical knowledge.

The second solution trained a CLIP-style image-disease label joint embedding model for image classification. This model was trained to learn a joint representation of medical images and their associated disease labels, allowing it to accurately classify images of medical conditions. This CLIP-based approach (Medical-MT5: Open-Source Multilingual Text-to-Text Transformer for Medical Domain, Introducing L2M3: A Multilingual Medical Large Language Model) proved to be a powerful technique for the visual component of the medical question answering task.

These two solutions significantly outperformed the next best submission on the competition leaderboard, demonstrating the effectiveness of the multi-stage LLM approach and the CLIP-style image classification approach for this challenging task.

Critical Analysis

While the performance of the authors' two solutions was impressive, the paper acknowledges that there is still substantial room for improvement in the field of medical visual question answering. The shared task itself was highly challenging, and the authors note that medical visual question answering remains a difficult problem in general.

The paper also highlights the need for further research and experimentation to fully unlock the potential of the multi-stage LLM approach and the CLIP-style image classification approach. The authors suggest that these techniques are promising avenues for future work, but more work is needed to refine and optimize these methods.

Additionally, the paper does not address potential biases or limitations of the training data or model architectures used. It would be valuable for future research to examine these aspects more closely and consider ways to mitigate any issues that may arise.

Overall, the paper presents two innovative solutions that performed exceptionally well in the MEDIQA2024 shared task. However, the authors rightly acknowledge that this is a complex and difficult problem, and more research is needed to further advance the state of the art in medical visual question answering.

Conclusion

This paper outlines the authors' submission to the MEDIQA2024 Multilingual and Multimodal Medical Answer Generation (M3G) shared task, which involved two standalone solutions that achieved the top two spots on the competition leaderboard.

The first solution leveraged the Claude 3 Opus API in a two-step process, while the second solution trained a CLIP-style image-disease label joint embedding model for image classification. Both approaches demonstrated strong performance, suggesting that the multi-stage LLM approach and the CLIP-based image classification technique are promising directions for further research in this challenging domain.

Although the authors acknowledge that medical visual question answering remains a difficult problem with significant room for improvement, the insights gained from this work provide valuable guidance for future researchers and practitioners working to advance the state of the art in this field.