Weak-to-Strong Extrapolation Expedites Alignment
2404.16792
0
0
👁️
Abstract
The open-source community is experiencing a surge in the release of large language models (LLMs) that are trained to follow instructions and align with human preference. However, further training to improve them still requires expensive computational resources and data annotations. Is it possible to bypass additional training and cost-effectively acquire better-aligned models? Inspired by the literature on model interpolation, we propose a simple method called ExPO to boost LLMs' alignment with human preference. Utilizing a model that has undergone alignment training (e.g., via DPO or RLHF) and its initial SFT checkpoint, ExPO directly obtains a better-aligned model by extrapolating from the weights of the initial and the aligned models, which implicitly optimizes the alignment objective via first-order approximation. Through experiments with twelve open-source LLMs on HuggingFace, we demonstrate that ExPO consistently improves off-the-shelf DPO/RLHF models, as evaluated on the mainstream LLM benchmarks AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench. Moreover, ExPO exhibits remarkable scalability across various model sizes (from 1.8B to 70B) and capabilities. Through controlled experiments and further empirical analyses, we shed light on the essence of ExPO amplifying the reward signal learned during alignment training. Our work demonstrates the efficacy of model extrapolation in expediting the alignment of LLMs with human preference, suggesting a promising direction for future research.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a method called ExPO to boost the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human preferences.
- It suggests that a moderately trained LLM can be further improved by interpolating it between a less-aligned (weaker) model and a better-aligned (stronger) one, rather than requiring additional training.
- The method is shown to push models trained with less preference data to reach and even surpass the fully-trained model, without any additional training.
- ExPO also significantly improves off-the-shelf DPO/RLHF models and exhibits decent scalability across model sizes from 7B to 70B.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful tools that can be trained on massive amounts of data to perform a wide range of tasks. However, even the most capable LLMs have limitations due to the finite resources available for their training. The paper presents a method called ExPO that aims to exploit the potential of a moderately trained LLM and cheaply acquire a stronger model.
The key idea behind ExPO is that a medium-aligned LLM can be improved by interpolating it between a less-aligned (weaker) model and a better-aligned (stronger) one. This means that the researchers can directly obtain the stronger model by extrapolating from the weights of the former two relatively weaker models, without the need for additional training.
The paper demonstrates that ExPO can push models trained with less preference data (e.g., 10% or 20%) to reach and even surpass the fully-trained model, without any additional training. This suggests that ExPO can be used to improve the performance of language models that have been trained on limited data.
Furthermore, the researchers show that ExPO can significantly improve off-the-shelf DPO/RLHF models, which are widely used techniques for aligning LLMs with human preferences. The method also exhibits decent scalability across model sizes from 7B to 70B, indicating that it can be applied to a wide range of LLM architectures.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind the ExPO method is to exploit the potential of a moderately trained LLM by interpolating it between a less-aligned (weaker) model and a better-aligned (stronger) one. The researchers assume that the medium-aligned model can be improved by directly obtaining the stronger model through extrapolation, without requiring additional training.
To test this hypothesis, the researchers evaluated ExPO on the AlpacaEval 2.0 benchmark, which measures the alignment of LLMs with human preferences. They showed that ExPO can push models trained with less preference data (e.g., 10% or 20%) to reach and even surpass the fully-trained model, without any additional training.
Furthermore, the researchers demonstrated that ExPO can significantly improve the performance of off-the-shelf DPO/RLHF models, which are widely used techniques for aligning LLMs with human preferences. They also found that ExPO exhibits decent scalability across model sizes from 7B to 70B, suggesting that it can be applied to a wide range of LLM architectures.
The paper's findings suggest that model extrapolation, as demonstrated by ExPO, can be a promising direction for exploiting the capabilities of LLMs and improving their alignment with human preferences, even when working with limited resources.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to improving the alignment of LLMs with human preferences, but it also raises some potential concerns and areas for further research.
One limitation mentioned in the paper is the scalability of ExPO across larger model sizes. While the method exhibited decent scalability from 7B to 70B models, it's unclear how well it would perform on even larger LLMs, such as the 200B-parameter GPT-4 or future generations of even more massive models.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential drawbacks or unintended consequences of using ExPO to push models trained on limited data to surpass fully-trained models. There may be risks or biases introduced by this approach that should be carefully explored.
Furthermore, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the underlying mechanisms or theoretical foundations of ExPO. While the empirical results are promising, a deeper understanding of the principles behind the method could help researchers better assess its limitations and potential applicability to other domains, such as teaching large language models new languages or improving factuality in language models.
Overall, the paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of language model alignment, but further research is needed to fully understand the implications and limitations of the ExPO method.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a simple yet effective method called ExPO that can boost the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. By interpolating a moderately trained LLM between a less-aligned (weaker) model and a better-aligned (stronger) one, ExPO can directly obtain the stronger model through extrapolation, without the need for additional training.
The researchers demonstrated that ExPO can push models trained with limited preference data to reach and even surpass the fully-trained model, and it can also significantly improve off-the-shelf DPO/RLHF models. The method's decent scalability across model sizes suggests its potential for a wide range of LLM architectures.
These findings highlight the efficacy of model extrapolation in exploiting the capabilities of LLMs and aligning them with human preferences, even when working with limited resources. The paper suggests a promising direction for future research in this area, which could have significant implications for the development of more robust and trustworthy language models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤯
A statistical framework for weak-to-strong generalization
Seamus Somerstep, Felipe Maia Polo, Moulinath Banerjee, Ya'acov Ritov, Mikhail Yurochkin, Yuekai Sun
0
0
Modern large language model (LLM) alignment techniques rely on human feedback, but it is unclear whether the techniques fundamentally limit the capabilities of aligned LLMs. In particular, it is unclear whether it is possible to align (stronger) LLMs with superhuman capabilities with (weaker) human feedback without degrading their capabilities. This is an instance of the weak-to-strong generalization problem: using weaker (less capable) feedback to train a stronger (more capable) model. We prove that weak-to-strong generalization is possible by eliciting latent knowledge from pre-trained LLMs. In particular, we cast the weak-to-strong generalization problem as a transfer learning problem in which we wish to transfer a latent concept from a weak model to a strong pre-trained model. We prove that a naive fine-tuning approach suffers from fundamental limitations, but an alternative refinement-based approach suggested by the problem structure provably overcomes the limitations of fine-tuning. Finally, we demonstrate the practical applicability of the refinement approach with three LLM alignment tasks.
5/28/2024
Aligning Large Language Models via Fine-grained Supervision
Dehong Xu, Liang Qiu, Minseok Kim, Faisal Ladhak, Jaeyoung Do
0
0
Pre-trained large-scale language models (LLMs) excel at producing coherent articles, yet their outputs may be untruthful, toxic, or fail to align with user expectations. Current approaches focus on using reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) to improve model alignment, which works by transforming coarse human preferences of LLM outputs into a feedback signal that guides the model learning process. However, because this approach operates on sequence-level feedback, it lacks the precision to identify the exact parts of the output affecting user preferences. To address this gap, we propose a method to enhance LLM alignment through fine-grained token-level supervision. Specifically, we ask annotators to minimally edit less preferred responses within the standard reward modeling dataset to make them more favorable, ensuring changes are made only where necessary while retaining most of the original content. The refined dataset is used to train a token-level reward model, which is then used for training our fine-grained Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) model. Our experiment results demonstrate that this approach can achieve up to an absolute improvement of $5.1%$ in LLM performance, in terms of win rate against the reference model, compared with the traditional PPO model.
6/6/2024
🚀
Contrastive Preference Optimization: Pushing the Boundaries of LLM Performance in Machine Translation
Haoran Xu, Amr Sharaf, Yunmo Chen, Weiting Tan, Lingfeng Shen, Benjamin Van Durme, Kenton Murray, Young Jin Kim
0
0
Moderate-sized large language models (LLMs) -- those with 7B or 13B parameters -- exhibit promising machine translation (MT) performance. However, even the top-performing 13B LLM-based translation models, like ALMA, does not match the performance of state-of-the-art conventional encoder-decoder translation models or larger-scale LLMs such as GPT-4. In this study, we bridge this performance gap. We first assess the shortcomings of supervised fine-tuning for LLMs in the MT task, emphasizing the quality issues present in the reference data, despite being human-generated. Then, in contrast to SFT which mimics reference translations, we introduce Contrastive Preference Optimization (CPO), a novel approach that trains models to avoid generating adequate but not perfect translations. Applying CPO to ALMA models with only 22K parallel sentences and 12M parameters yields significant improvements. The resulting model, called ALMA-R, can match or exceed the performance of the WMT competition winners and GPT-4 on WMT'21, WMT'22 and WMT'23 test datasets.
6/4/2024
Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Reliability-Aware Alignment
Yue Guo, Yi Yang
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) are now rapidly advancing and surpassing human abilities on many natural language tasks. However, aligning these super-human LLMs with human knowledge remains challenging because the supervision signals from human annotators may be wrong. This issue, known as the super-alignment problem, requires enhancing weak-to-strong generalization, where a strong LLM must generalize from imperfect supervision provided by a weaker source. To address this issue, we propose an approach to improve weak-to-strong generalization by involving the reliability of weak supervision signals in the alignment process. In our method, we query the weak supervisor for multiple answers, estimate the answer reliability, and enhance the alignment process by filtering out uncertain data or re-weighting reliable data. Experiments on four datasets demonstrate that our methods effectively identify the quality of weak labels and significantly enhance weak-to-strong generalization. Our work presents effective techniques for error-robust model alignment, reducing error propagation from noisy supervision and enhancing the accuracy and reliability of LLMs. Codes are publicly available at http://github.com/Irenehere/ReliableAlignment.
6/28/2024