What characteristics define disinformation and fake news?: review of taxonomies and definitions

Overview

• Disinformation and fake news are important phenomena with complex characteristics
• This technical note provides a comprehensive analysis of 46 definitions to highlight 4 key points about their fundamental characteristics
• The research adopts the Prisma 2020 method, analyzing 237 reviewed articles across 4 databases in Portuguese and English

Plain English Explanation

This research paper examines the characteristics that define disinformation and fake news. It takes a deep dive into 46 different definitions to identify 4 key points about the fundamental nature of these issues.

The researchers used a rigorous research method called Prisma 2020 to analyze 237 articles from 4 different databases in both Portuguese and English. This allowed them to take a comprehensive look at the topic and synthesize the existing knowledge.

At the core, disinformation is information that is partially or completely false, created intentionally to mislead people. It often contains opportunistic content designed to manipulate reality. The way individuals interpret this information and the broader context they're in can also play a big role in how disinformation spreads and takes hold.

The paper breaks down 4 critical elements of disinformation and fake news: the sender, the content, the receiver, and the environment it exists in. Understanding these different factors is key to addressing the challenge of disinformation.

Technical Explanation

The researchers adopted the Prisma 2020 method to conduct a comprehensive analysis of disinformation and fake news. They selected 5 search sets with the Boolean operator AND in both Portuguese and English, applying them across 4 databases. This resulted in 237 reviewed articles.

After a meticulous analysis, the researchers identified relevant articles and excluded duplicates and inaccessible documents. They synthesized 46 definitions to highlight 4 key points about the fundamental characteristics of disinformation and fake news:

1. Sender: Disinformation is information that is totally or partially false, crafted by a sender with the aim of misleading.
2. Content: The content is opportunistic, designed to manipulate reality.
3. Receiver: The information is amplified by individual characteristics of the receiver in their interpretation.
4. Environment: Contextual factors in which the receiver is embedded also play a role.

This comprehensive approach allowed the researchers to examine disinformation and fake news beyond just the content itself, taking into account the complex interplay of the sender, receiver, and the broader environment.

Critical Analysis

The technical note provides a well-rounded and nuanced analysis of the characteristics of disinformation and fake news. By synthesizing 46 definitions, the researchers were able to distill the key elements that define these phenomena.

However, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific tactics and techniques used by creators of disinformation, nor does it explore the motivations and incentive structures that drive the production and spread of false information. Further research in these areas could provide additional insights.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the general characteristics of disinformation, but does not address the particular challenges of identifying and combating it in the context of emerging technologies like large language models. Exploring these cutting-edge issues could be a fruitful area for future study.

Overall, this technical note provides a solid foundation for understanding the complex nature of disinformation and fake news. By highlighting the importance of the sender, content, receiver, and environment, it offers a useful framework for further investigating and addressing these critical problems.

Conclusion

This technical note offers a comprehensive analysis of the fundamental characteristics of disinformation and fake news. By synthesizing 46 definitions, the researchers identified four key elements: the sender, the content, the receiver, and the broader environment.

This multi-faceted approach allows for a more nuanced understanding of these phenomena, going beyond just the content itself. It underscores the importance of considering the complex interplay of various factors in the production, dissemination, and interpretation of false information.

The insights provided in this paper can inform efforts to detect, mitigate, and combat disinformation and fake news, which have significant societal implications. As technology continues to evolve, further research will be needed to address emerging challenges, but this technical note lays important groundwork for understanding the core characteristics of these critical issues.