Which exceptional low-dimensional projections of a Gaussian point cloud can be found in polynomial time?
0
📉
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the asymptotic behavior of the empirical distributions of high-dimensional Gaussian projections.
- In the proportional asymptotics regime, where the number of data points and dimensionality both grow large, the authors show that the set of feasible projection distributions contains non-Gaussian distributions.
- The authors study a subset of this set that can be realized by iterative algorithms, and characterize it in terms of a stochastic optimal control problem.
- As a result, they obtain computationally achievable values for a class of random optimization problems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at what happens when you take a bunch of high-dimensional data points that follow a normal (Gaussian) distribution, and then project them onto a lower-dimensional space. Specifically, the authors consider the case where the number of data points and the original dimensionality both grow very large, but the ratio between them stays finite.
In this setting, the authors show that the set of possible distributions you can get for the projected data points includes some that are not normal. These non-Gaussian distributions correspond to "exceptional" subspaces that the data gets projected onto.
To better understand this, the authors focus on a subset of the possible projection distributions - the ones that can be obtained using an iterative algorithm. They show that this subset is characterized by solving a particular optimization problem, which extends a famous formula from statistical physics called the Parisi formula.
As a result of this analysis, the authors are able to compute the best possible values for a class of random optimization problems, including some models inspired by neuroscience (the "generalized spherical perceptron" models).
Technical Explanation
The paper studies the asymptotic behavior of the empirical distributions of $m$-dimensional projections of $d$-dimensional standard Gaussian vectors $\boldsymbol{x}_1, \dots, \boldsymbol{x}_n$, in the proportional asymptotics regime where $n, d \to \infty$ with $n/d \to \alpha \in (0, \infty)$.
In contrast to the well-known result of Diaconis and Freedman (1984) that all such distributions converge to the standard Gaussian when $n/d \to \infty$, the authors show that the set $\mathscr{F}_{m,\alpha}$ of feasible projection distributions in the proportional asymptotics regime contains non-Gaussian distributions corresponding to exceptional subspaces.
Motivated by the goal of putting a formula from statistical physics (the generalized Parisi formula) on a rigorous basis, the authors study the subset $\mathscr{F}^{\rm alg}
As a byproduct, the authors obtain computationally achievable values for a class of random optimization problems, including "generalized spherical perceptron" models similar to those studied in Learning general Gaussian mixtures with efficient score matching and Best approximation by finite Gaussian mixtures.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes an important theoretical contribution by characterizing the set of feasible projection distributions in the proportional asymptotics regime, going beyond the previously known result of convergence to the Gaussian in the $n/d \to \infty$ regime.
However, the authors acknowledge that their analysis relies on non-rigorous methods from statistical physics, and further work would be needed to put the generalized Parisi formula on a fully rigorous footing. Additionally, the practical implications of the results for tasks like high-dimensional data analysis or optimization are not entirely clear from the current presentation.
It would be interesting to see more discussion of potential applications, as well as comparisons to other dimensionality reduction techniques like N-dimensional Gaussians for Fitting High-Dimensional Functions or Generalization Bound for Learning Methods via Data-Driven Projections. Overall, the paper provides a valuable theoretical contribution, but more work may be needed to fully understand its practical significance.
Conclusion
This paper explores the asymptotic behavior of high-dimensional Gaussian projections, showing that in the proportional asymptotics regime, the set of feasible projection distributions includes non-Gaussian distributions. By characterizing a subset of this set that can be realized by iterative algorithms, the authors obtain computationally achievable values for a class of random optimization problems.
While the theoretical insights are significant, more work may be needed to understand the practical implications and applications of this research. Nonetheless, the paper represents an important step forward in understanding the rich structure of high-dimensional data projections.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📉
0
Which exceptional low-dimensional projections of a Gaussian point cloud can be found in polynomial time?
Andrea Montanari, Kangjie Zhou
Given $d$-dimensional standard Gaussian vectors $boldsymbol{x}_1,dots, boldsymbol{x}_n$, we consider the set of all empirical distributions of its $m$-dimensional projections, for $m$ a fixed constant. Diaconis and Freedman (1984) proved that, if $n/dto infty$, all such distributions converge to the standard Gaussian distribution. In contrast, we study the proportional asymptotics, whereby $n,dto infty$ with $n/dto alpha in (0, infty)$. In this case, the projection of the data points along a typical random subspace is again Gaussian, but the set $mathscr{F}_{m,alpha}$ of all probability distributions that are asymptotically feasible as $m$-dimensional projections contains non-Gaussian distributions corresponding to exceptional subspaces. Non-rigorous methods from statistical physics yield an indirect characterization of $mathscr{F}_{m,alpha}$ in terms of a generalized Parisi formula. Motivated by the goal of putting this formula on a rigorous basis, and to understand whether these projections can be found efficiently, we study the subset $mathscr{F}^{rm alg}_{m,alpha}subseteq mathscr{F}_{m,alpha}$ of distributions that can be realized by a class of iterative algorithms. We prove that this set is characterized by a certain stochastic optimal control problem, and obtain a dual characterization of this problem in terms of a variational principle that extends Parisi's formula. As a byproduct, we obtain computationally achievable values for a class of random optimization problems including `generalized spherical perceptron' models.
Read more6/6/2024
🏷️
0
Approximation and generalization properties of the random projection classification method
Mireille Boutin, Evzenie Coupkova
The generalization gap of a classifier is related to the complexity of the set of functions among which the classifier is chosen. We study a family of low-complexity classifiers consisting of thresholding a random one-dimensional feature. The feature is obtained by projecting the data on a random line after embedding it into a higher-dimensional space parametrized by monomials of order up to k. More specifically, the extended data is projected n-times and the best classifier among those n, based on its performance on training data, is chosen. We show that this type of classifier is extremely flexible as, given full knowledge of the class conditional densities, under mild conditions, the error of these classifiers would converge to the optimal (Bayes) error as k and n go to infinity. We also bound the generalization gap of the random classifiers. In general, these bounds are better than those for any classifier with VC dimension greater than O(ln n). In particular, the bounds imply that, unless the number of projections n is extremely large, the generalization gap of the random projection approach is significantly smaller than that of a linear classifier in the extended space. Thus, for certain classification problems (e.g., those with a large Rashomon ratio), there is a potntially large gain in generalization properties by selecting parameters at random, rather than selecting the best one amongst the class.
Read more9/12/2024
📉
0
Mixtures of Gaussians are Privately Learnable with a Polynomial Number of Samples
Mohammad Afzali, Hassan Ashtiani, Christopher Liaw
We study the problem of estimating mixtures of Gaussians under the constraint of differential privacy (DP). Our main result is that $text{poly}(k,d,1/alpha,1/varepsilon,log(1/delta))$ samples are sufficient to estimate a mixture of $k$ Gaussians in $mathbb{R}^d$ up to total variation distance $alpha$ while satisfying $(varepsilon, delta)$-DP. This is the first finite sample complexity upper bound for the problem that does not make any structural assumptions on the GMMs. To solve the problem, we devise a new framework which may be useful for other tasks. On a high level, we show that if a class of distributions (such as Gaussians) is (1) list decodable and (2) admits a locally small'' cover (Bun et al., 2021) with respect to total variation distance, then the class of its mixtures is privately learnable. The proof circumvents a known barrier indicating that, unlike Gaussians, GMMs do not admit a locally small cover (Aden-Ali et al., 2021b).
Read more4/24/2024
📉
0
On the best approximation by finite Gaussian mixtures
Yun Ma, Yihong Wu, Pengkun Yang
We consider the problem of approximating a general Gaussian location mixture by finite mixtures. The minimum order of finite mixtures that achieve a prescribed accuracy (measured by various $f$-divergences) is determined within constant factors for the family of mixing distributions with compactly support or appropriate assumptions on the tail probability including subgaussian and subexponential. While the upper bound is achieved using the technique of local moment matching, the lower bound is established by relating the best approximation error to the low-rank approximation of certain trigonometric moment matrices, followed by a refined spectral analysis of their minimum eigenvalue. In the case of Gaussian mixing distributions, this result corrects a previous lower bound in [Allerton Conference 48 (2010) 620-628].
Read more4/16/2024