A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Generalized Nested Jailbreak Prompts can Fool Large Language Models Easily
2311.08268
0
0
💬
Abstract
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, are designed to provide useful and safe responses. However, adversarial prompts known as 'jailbreaks' can circumvent safeguards, leading LLMs to generate potentially harmful content. Exploring jailbreak prompts can help to better reveal the weaknesses of LLMs and further steer us to secure them. Unfortunately, existing jailbreak methods either suffer from intricate manual design or require optimization on other white-box models, which compromises either generalization or efficiency. In this paper, we generalize jailbreak prompt attacks into two aspects: (1) Prompt Rewriting and (2) Scenario Nesting. Based on this, we propose ReNeLLM, an automatic framework that leverages LLMs themselves to generate effective jailbreak prompts. Extensive experiments demonstrate that ReNeLLM significantly improves the attack success rate while greatly reducing the time cost compared to existing baselines. Our study also reveals the inadequacy of current defense methods in safeguarding LLMs. Finally, we analyze the failure of LLMs defense from the perspective of prompt execution priority, and propose corresponding defense strategies. We hope that our research can catalyze both the academic community and LLMs developers towards the provision of safer and more regulated LLMs. The code is available at https://github.com/NJUNLP/ReNeLLM.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 are designed to provide useful and safe responses
- However, 'jailbreak' prompts can circumvent their safeguards, leading to potentially harmful content
- Exploring jailbreak prompts can help reveal LLM weaknesses and improve security
- Existing jailbreak methods suffer from manual design or require optimization on other models, compromising generalization or efficiency
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 are very advanced AI systems that can generate human-like text on a wide range of topics. These models are designed with safeguards to ensure they provide useful and safe responses.
However, researchers have discovered that it's possible to bypass these safeguards using a technique called 'jailbreaking'. This involves crafting special prompts that trick the model into generating potentially harmful or undesirable content. By exploring and understanding jailbreak prompts, researchers can better understand the weaknesses of LLMs and work to make them more secure.
The challenge is that existing jailbreak methods either require a lot of manual effort to design the prompts, or they rely on optimizing the prompts on other models, which can limit how well they work on the target LLM. This paper proposes a new approach called ReNeLLM that uses the LLMs themselves to automatically generate effective jailbreak prompts. The researchers show that this approach significantly improves the success rate of the attacks while also being much faster than previous methods.
This research highlights the importance of continually testing and improving the security of large language models as they become more powerful and widely used. By understanding the vulnerabilities of these systems, the academic community and LLM developers can work together to make them safer and more trustworthy for real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
This paper proposes a new framework called ReNeLLM that can automatically generate effective jailbreak prompts for large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4.
The key innovation is that ReNeLLM generalizes jailbreak prompt attacks into two main components: (1) Prompt Rewriting and (2) Scenario Nesting. Prompt Rewriting involves modifying the language of the prompt to bypass the model's safeguards, while Scenario Nesting involves embedding the malicious intent within a benign narrative.
By leveraging the LLMs themselves to generate these jailbreak prompts, ReNeLLM is able to significantly improve the attack success rate compared to existing manual or optimization-based approaches. The authors' extensive experiments demonstrate that ReNeLLM can achieve much higher success rates while also requiring less time to generate the prompts.
The paper also reveals the inadequacy of current defense methods in protecting LLMs from these types of attacks. The authors analyze the failure of LLM defenses from the perspective of prompt execution priority and propose corresponding strategies to improve security.
Critical Analysis
The research presented in this paper makes an important contribution to understanding the security vulnerabilities of large language models. By developing an automated framework for generating effective jailbreak prompts, the authors have shed light on a critical challenge facing the widespread deployment of these powerful AI systems.
That said, the paper does not address some potential limitations and caveats. For instance, it's unclear how generalizable the ReNeLLM approach is to other types of LLMs beyond the ones tested. There may also be ways for model developers to adapt their defenses to become more resilient against this specific type of attack.
Additionally, the paper focuses solely on the technical aspects of jailbreaking and does not consider the broader ethical implications. While the research aims to improve LLM security, there is a risk that the techniques could be misused by bad actors to cause harm. Careful consideration of responsible disclosure and development practices is essential.
Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in jailbreaking research and prompt-based attacks on large language models. However, continued vigilance and a collaborative approach between researchers, developers, and end-users will be necessary to ensure these powerful AI systems are deployed in a safe and ethical manner.
Conclusion
This paper introduces ReNeLLM, a new framework for automatically generating effective jailbreak prompts that can bypass the safeguards of large language models like ChatGPT and GPT-4. The research demonstrates that ReNeLLM significantly outperforms existing jailbreak methods in terms of both success rate and efficiency.
By revealing the inadequacy of current LLM defense strategies, this work highlights the critical need for continued security research and development in this rapidly evolving field. The authors' analysis of prompt execution priority provides a promising direction for improving the robustness of these systems.
Overall, this paper represents an important contribution to the ongoing effort to make large language models more secure and trustworthy. As these AI systems become increasingly integrated into our daily lives, ensuring their safety and reliability will be of paramount importance. The insights and techniques presented here can help catalyze further progress towards that goal.
Related Papers
🤔
AdvPrompter: Fast Adaptive Adversarial Prompting for LLMs
Anselm Paulus, Arman Zharmagambetov, Chuan Guo, Brandon Amos, Yuandong Tian
0
0
While recently Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable successes, they are vulnerable to certain jailbreaking attacks that lead to generation of inappropriate or harmful content. Manual red-teaming requires finding adversarial prompts that cause such jailbreaking, e.g. by appending a suffix to a given instruction, which is inefficient and time-consuming. On the other hand, automatic adversarial prompt generation often leads to semantically meaningless attacks that can easily be detected by perplexity-based filters, may require gradient information from the TargetLLM, or do not scale well due to time-consuming discrete optimization processes over the token space. In this paper, we present a novel method that uses another LLM, called the AdvPrompter, to generate human-readable adversarial prompts in seconds, $sim800times$ faster than existing optimization-based approaches. We train the AdvPrompter using a novel algorithm that does not require access to the gradients of the TargetLLM. This process alternates between two steps: (1) generating high-quality target adversarial suffixes by optimizing the AdvPrompter predictions, and (2) low-rank fine-tuning of the AdvPrompter with the generated adversarial suffixes. The trained AdvPrompter generates suffixes that veil the input instruction without changing its meaning, such that the TargetLLM is lured to give a harmful response. Experimental results on popular open source TargetLLMs show state-of-the-art results on the AdvBench dataset, that also transfer to closed-source black-box LLM APIs. Further, we demonstrate that by fine-tuning on a synthetic dataset generated by AdvPrompter, LLMs can be made more robust against jailbreaking attacks while maintaining performance, i.e. high MMLU scores.
4/29/2024
JailbreakLens: Visual Analysis of Jailbreak Attacks Against Large Language Models
Yingchaojie Feng, Zhizhang Chen, Zhining Kang, Sijia Wang, Minfeng Zhu, Wei Zhang, Wei Chen
0
0
The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has underscored concerns regarding their security vulnerabilities, notably against jailbreak attacks, where adversaries design jailbreak prompts to circumvent safety mechanisms for potential misuse. Addressing these concerns necessitates a comprehensive analysis of jailbreak prompts to evaluate LLMs' defensive capabilities and identify potential weaknesses. However, the complexity of evaluating jailbreak performance and understanding prompt characteristics makes this analysis laborious. We collaborate with domain experts to characterize problems and propose an LLM-assisted framework to streamline the analysis process. It provides automatic jailbreak assessment to facilitate performance evaluation and support analysis of components and keywords in prompts. Based on the framework, we design JailbreakLens, a visual analysis system that enables users to explore the jailbreak performance against the target model, conduct multi-level analysis of prompt characteristics, and refine prompt instances to verify findings. Through a case study, technical evaluations, and expert interviews, we demonstrate our system's effectiveness in helping users evaluate model security and identify model weaknesses.
4/16/2024
Jailbreaking Leading Safety-Aligned LLMs with Simple Adaptive Attacks
Maksym Andriushchenko, Francesco Croce, Nicolas Flammarion
0
0
We show that even the most recent safety-aligned LLMs are not robust to simple adaptive jailbreaking attacks. First, we demonstrate how to successfully leverage access to logprobs for jailbreaking: we initially design an adversarial prompt template (sometimes adapted to the target LLM), and then we apply random search on a suffix to maximize the target logprob (e.g., of the token Sure), potentially with multiple restarts. In this way, we achieve nearly 100% attack success rate -- according to GPT-4 as a judge -- on GPT-3.5/4, Llama-2-Chat-7B/13B/70B, Gemma-7B, and R2D2 from HarmBench that was adversarially trained against the GCG attack. We also show how to jailbreak all Claude models -- that do not expose logprobs -- via either a transfer or prefilling attack with 100% success rate. In addition, we show how to use random search on a restricted set of tokens for finding trojan strings in poisoned models -- a task that shares many similarities with jailbreaking -- which is the algorithm that brought us the first place in the SaTML'24 Trojan Detection Competition. The common theme behind these attacks is that adaptivity is crucial: different models are vulnerable to different prompting templates (e.g., R2D2 is very sensitive to in-context learning prompts), some models have unique vulnerabilities based on their APIs (e.g., prefilling for Claude), and in some settings it is crucial to restrict the token search space based on prior knowledge (e.g., for trojan detection). We provide the code, prompts, and logs of the attacks at https://github.com/tml-epfl/llm-adaptive-attacks.
4/3/2024
Subtoxic Questions: Dive Into Attitude Change of LLM's Response in Jailbreak Attempts
Tianyu Zhang, Zixuan Zhao, Jiaqi Huang, Jingyu Hua, Sheng Zhong
0
0
As Large Language Models (LLMs) of Prompt Jailbreaking are getting more and more attention, it is of great significance to raise a generalized research paradigm to evaluate attack strengths and a basic model to conduct subtler experiments. In this paper, we propose a novel approach by focusing on a set of target questions that are inherently more sensitive to jailbreak prompts, aiming to circumvent the limitations posed by enhanced LLM security. Through designing and analyzing these sensitive questions, this paper reveals a more effective method of identifying vulnerabilities in LLMs, thereby contributing to the advancement of LLM security. This research not only challenges existing jailbreaking methodologies but also fortifies LLMs against potential exploits.
4/15/2024