Your Finetuned Large Language Model is Already a Powerful Out-of-distribution Detector
2404.08679
0
0
Abstract
We revisit the likelihood ratio between a pretrained large language model (LLM) and its finetuned variant as a criterion for out-of-distribution (OOD) detection. The intuition behind such a criterion is that, the pretrained LLM has the prior knowledge about OOD data due to its large amount of training data, and once finetuned with the in-distribution data, the LLM has sufficient knowledge to distinguish their difference. Leveraging the power of LLMs, we show that, for the first time, the likelihood ratio can serve as an effective OOD detector. Moreover, we apply the proposed LLM-based likelihood ratio to detect OOD questions in question-answering (QA) systems, which can be used to improve the performance of specialized LLMs for general questions. Given that likelihood can be easily obtained by the loss functions within contemporary neural network frameworks, it is straightforward to implement this approach in practice. Since both the pretrained LLMs and its various finetuned models are available, our proposed criterion can be effortlessly incorporated for OOD detection without the need for further training. We conduct comprehensive evaluation across on multiple settings, including far OOD, near OOD, spam detection, and QA scenarios, to demonstrate the effectiveness of the method.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the powerful out-of-distribution (OOD) detection capabilities of large language models (LLMs) that have been finetuned on specific tasks.
- The authors demonstrate that these finetuned LLMs can effectively distinguish in-distribution data from OOD samples, even without any explicit OOD training.
- This capability arises from the rich representations learned by the LLMs during pretraining and finetuning, which capture high-level semantic and syntactic features.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 are very powerful AI systems that have been trained on massive amounts of text data. These models can understand and generate human-like language. But what happens when you take an LLM and "finetune" it to perform a specific task, like answering questions or summarizing text?
The researchers who wrote this paper found that these finetuned LLMs can actually do a really good job of detecting when they're being shown something that's very different from the kind of data they were trained on. In other words, they can tell when something is an "out-of-distribution" (OOD) sample, even without any explicit training on OOD data.
This is a really useful capability, because it means these finetuned LLMs can act as powerful detectors for spotting when someone is trying to get them to do something they weren't designed for. This could be important for things like making sure AI systems don't get tricked into doing something harmful or unexpected.
The reason these finetuned LLMs are so good at OOD detection is because of the rich, high-level representations they've learned during pretraining and finetuning. They've developed a deep understanding of language and semantics, which allows them to recognize when something is very different from the kind of data they're used to.
Technical Explanation
The authors demonstrate that finetuned large language models (LLMs) can effectively detect out-of-distribution (OOD) samples, even without any explicit OOD training. This capability arises from the rich representations learned by the LLMs during pretraining and finetuning.
The likelihood of an autoregressive language model like GPT-3 can be used as a powerful OOD detector. The authors show that the likelihood scores assigned by a finetuned LLM are generally higher for in-distribution samples compared to OOD samples, indicating the model's ability to distinguish between the two.
This OOD detection performance is further improved by leveraging the high-level semantic and syntactic features learned by the LLM during pretraining and finetuning. The authors find that the model's internal representations capture meaningful information that can be effectively used for OOD detection, even without any explicit OOD training.
The paper also discusses connections to related work on learnability of out-of-distribution detection, unified representation learning frameworks for OOD detection, and the role of negative labels in OOD detection.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a compelling demonstration of the inherent OOD detection capabilities of finetuned LLMs, without requiring any explicit OOD training. This is a significant insight, as it suggests that these powerful models can serve as robust detectors for identifying inputs that are quite different from their training distribution.
However, the authors also acknowledge some potential limitations and areas for further research. For instance, the paper does not explore the extent to which the OOD detection performance may depend on the specific finetuning task or dataset. Additionally, the authors note that the model's representations may not be equally effective for detecting all types of OOD samples, and further investigation is needed to understand the model's failure modes.
Another aspect that could be explored in future work is the connection to generalized knowledge distillation techniques for improving OOD detection, as well as the role of noisy training signals in developing robust OOD detection capabilities.
Conclusion
This paper presents an important finding: finetuned large language models can inherently act as powerful out-of-distribution detectors, without any explicit OOD training. This capability arises from the rich representations learned by the models during pretraining and finetuning, which capture high-level semantic and syntactic features.
The implications of this research are significant, as it suggests that these finetuned LLMs could be leveraged as robust detectors for identifying inputs that are outside the model's intended use case. This could have important applications in ensuring the safety and reliability of AI systems, as well as in developing more advanced out-of-distribution detection techniques.
While the paper highlights some potential limitations and areas for further exploration, the core insight – that powerful language models can detect OOD samples through their learned representations – represents an important step forward in understanding the capabilities and limitations of large-scale AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛸
How Good Are LLMs at Out-of-Distribution Detection?
Bo Liu, Liming Zhan, Zexin Lu, Yujie Feng, Lei Xue, Xiao-Ming Wu
0
0
Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection plays a vital role in enhancing the reliability of machine learning (ML) models. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has catalyzed a paradigm shift within the ML community, showcasing their exceptional capabilities across diverse natural language processing tasks. While existing research has probed OOD detection with relative small-scale Transformers like BERT, RoBERTa and GPT-2, the stark differences in scales, pre-training objectives, and inference paradigms call into question the applicability of these findings to LLMs. This paper embarks on a pioneering empirical investigation of OOD detection in the domain of LLMs, focusing on LLaMA series ranging from 7B to 65B in size. We thoroughly evaluate commonly-used OOD detectors, scrutinizing their performance in both zero-grad and fine-tuning scenarios. Notably, we alter previous discriminative in-distribution fine-tuning into generative fine-tuning, aligning the pre-training objective of LLMs with downstream tasks. Our findings unveil that a simple cosine distance OOD detector demonstrates superior efficacy, outperforming other OOD detectors. We provide an intriguing explanation for this phenomenon by highlighting the isotropic nature of the embedding spaces of LLMs, which distinctly contrasts with the anisotropic property observed in smaller BERT family models. The new insight enhances our understanding of how LLMs detect OOD data, thereby enhancing their adaptability and reliability in dynamic environments. We have released the source code at url{https://github.com/Awenbocc/LLM-OOD} for other researchers to reproduce our results.
4/17/2024
Envisioning Outlier Exposure by Large Language Models for Out-of-Distribution Detection
Chentao Cao, Zhun Zhong, Zhanke Zhou, Yang Liu, Tongliang Liu, Bo Han
0
0
Detecting out-of-distribution (OOD) samples is essential when deploying machine learning models in open-world scenarios. Zero-shot OOD detection, requiring no training on in-distribution (ID) data, has been possible with the advent of vision-language models like CLIP. Existing methods build a text-based classifier with only closed-set labels. However, this largely restricts the inherent capability of CLIP to recognize samples from large and open label space. In this paper, we propose to tackle this constraint by leveraging the expert knowledge and reasoning capability of large language models (LLM) to Envision potential Outlier Exposure, termed EOE, without access to any actual OOD data. Owing to better adaptation to open-world scenarios, EOE can be generalized to different tasks, including far, near, and fine-grained OOD detection. Technically, we design (1) LLM prompts based on visual similarity to generate potential outlier class labels specialized for OOD detection, as well as (2) a new score function based on potential outlier penalty to distinguish hard OOD samples effectively. Empirically, EOE achieves state-of-the-art performance across different OOD tasks and can be effectively scaled to the ImageNet-1K dataset. The code is publicly available at: https://github.com/tmlr-group/EOE.
6/4/2024
Reframing the Relationship in Out-of-Distribution Detection
YuXiao Lee, Xiaofeng Cao
0
0
The remarkable achievements of Large Language Models (LLMs) have captivated the attention of both academia and industry, transcending their initial role in dialogue generation. The utilization of LLMs as intermediary agents in various tasks has yielded promising results, sparking a wave of innovation in artificial intelligence. Building on these breakthroughs, we introduce a novel approach that integrates the agent paradigm into the Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection task, aiming to enhance its robustness and adaptability. Our proposed method, Concept Matching with Agent (CMA), employs neutral prompts as agents to augment the CLIP-based OOD detection process. These agents function as dynamic observers and communication hubs, interacting with both In-distribution (ID) labels and data inputs to form vector triangle relationships. This triangular framework offers a more nuanced approach than the traditional binary relationship, allowing for better separation and identification of ID and OOD inputs. Our extensive experimental results showcase the superior performance of CMA over both zero-shot and training-required methods in a diverse array of real-world scenarios.
5/28/2024
Language-Enhanced Latent Representations for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Autonomous Driving
Zhenjiang Mao, Dong-You Jhong, Ao Wang, Ivan Ruchkin
0
0
Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is essential in autonomous driving, to determine when learning-based components encounter unexpected inputs. Traditional detectors typically use encoder models with fixed settings, thus lacking effective human interaction capabilities. With the rise of large foundation models, multimodal inputs offer the possibility of taking human language as a latent representation, thus enabling language-defined OOD detection. In this paper, we use the cosine similarity of image and text representations encoded by the multimodal model CLIP as a new representation to improve the transparency and controllability of latent encodings used for visual anomaly detection. We compare our approach with existing pre-trained encoders that can only produce latent representations that are meaningless from the user's standpoint. Our experiments on realistic driving data show that the language-based latent representation performs better than the traditional representation of the vision encoder and helps improve the detection performance when combined with standard representations.
5/6/2024