Actively Learning Combinatorial Optimization Using a Membership Oracle
2405.14090
0
0
๐ ๏ธ
Abstract
We consider solving a combinatorial optimization problem with an unknown linear constraint using a membership oracle that, given a solution, determines whether it is feasible or infeasible with absolute certainty. The goal of the decision maker is to find the best possible solution subject to a budget on the number of oracle calls. Inspired by active learning based on Support Vector Machines (SVMs), we adapt a classical framework in order to solve the problem by learning and exploiting a surrogate linear constraint. The resulting new framework includes training a linear separator on the labeled points and selecting new points to be labeled, which is achieved by applying a sampling strategy and solving a 0-1 integer linear program. Following the active learning literature, one can consider using SVM as a linear classifier and the information-based sampling strategy known as Simple margin. We improve on both sides: we propose an alternative sampling strategy based on mixed-integer quadratic programming and a linear separation method inspired by an algorithm for convex optimization in the oracle model. We conduct experiments on the pure knapsack problem and on a college study plan problem from the literature to show how different linear separation methods and sampling strategies influence the quality of the results in terms of objective value.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Solving a combinatorial optimization problem with an unknown linear constraint
- Using a membership oracle to determine feasibility of solutions
- Goal is to find the best solution within a budget of oracle calls
- Adapting an active learning framework inspired by Support Vector Machines (SVMs)
Plain English Explanation
The researchers are studying a type of optimization problem where the goal is to find the best possible solution, subject to certain constraints. In this case, the constraints are not fully known - there is an unknown linear constraint that determines whether a proposed solution is feasible or not.
To solve this problem, the researchers use a special "oracle" that can tell them with certainty whether a given solution is feasible or not. However, there is a limit on the number of times they can ask the oracle for this information.
Inspired by a machine learning technique called active learning based on Support Vector Machines (SVMs), the researchers develop a new framework to efficiently learn and exploit the unknown linear constraint. This involves training a linear separator (similar to an SVM classifier) on the feasible and infeasible solutions they've encountered so far, and then strategically selecting new solutions to test with the oracle.
The key innovations in this work are an improved sampling strategy for selecting new solutions to test, and a new linear separation method that is more efficient than using a standard SVM. The researchers test their approach on both a classic optimization problem (the knapsack problem) and a real-world problem related to college course planning.
Technical Explanation
The researchers are studying a combinatorial optimization problem where the goal is to find the best possible solution, subject to an unknown linear constraint. They assume the existence of a "membership oracle" that can determine with absolute certainty whether a proposed solution is feasible or infeasible.
The researchers' objective is to find the optimal solution while minimizing the number of queries made to the oracle. To this end, they adapt a classical active learning framework inspired by Support Vector Machines (SVMs). This involves:
- Training a linear separator to learn and represent the unknown linear constraint, using the feasible and infeasible solutions encountered so far.
- Applying a sampling strategy to intelligently select new solutions to be evaluated by the oracle, in order to refine the linear separator.
The researchers propose two key innovations:
- An alternative sampling strategy based on mixed-integer quadratic programming, which aims to select the most informative new solutions.
- A linear separation method inspired by an algorithm for convex optimization in the oracle model, which is more efficient than using a standard SVM.
The researchers evaluate their approach on two problem instances: the classic pure knapsack problem and a college study plan problem from the literature. They analyze how the different linear separation methods and sampling strategies impact the quality of the final results, in terms of the objective value.
Critical Analysis
The researchers have presented a novel and interesting approach to solving combinatorial optimization problems with unknown linear constraints. By adapting an active learning framework inspired by SVMs, they have developed a principled way to efficiently learn and exploit the unknown constraint.
One potential limitation of the approach is its reliance on the existence of a perfect "membership oracle" that can determine the feasibility of solutions with absolute certainty. In practice, such an oracle may not always be available, and the researchers do not discuss how their framework would handle noisy or imperfect feasibility information.
Additionally, the researchers' experiments are limited to relatively small-scale problems (the knapsack problem and the college study plan problem). It would be interesting to see how their approach scales to larger, more complex combinatorial optimization problems.
That said, the researchers' innovations in sampling strategy and linear separation method are quite promising. The mixed-integer quadratic programming approach for selecting informative new solutions to test, and the convex optimization-inspired linear separation method, could potentially be applied to a wider range of active learning and optimization problems.
Overall, this paper presents a thoughtful and well-executed approach to a challenging problem. The researchers have made valuable contributions to the field of combinatorial optimization, and their work could inspire further research into active learning techniques for solving complex, constrained optimization problems.
Conclusion
This research paper introduces a novel framework for solving combinatorial optimization problems with unknown linear constraints. By adapting an active learning approach inspired by Support Vector Machines, the researchers have developed a principled way to efficiently learn and exploit the unknown constraint, while minimizing the number of queries to a "membership oracle" that can determine the feasibility of solutions.
The key innovations in this work are an improved sampling strategy for selecting new solutions to test, and a more efficient linear separation method compared to standard SVM techniques. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on both a classic optimization problem (the knapsack problem) and a real-world problem related to college course planning.
While the reliance on a perfect membership oracle and the limited scale of the experiments present some potential limitations, the researchers' contributions represent an important step forward in the field of combinatorial optimization. Their work could inspire further research into active learning techniques for solving complex, constrained optimization problems in a variety of domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Feature selection in linear SVMs via hard cardinality constraint: a scalable SDP decomposition approach
Immanuel Bomze, Federico D'Onofrio, Laura Palagi, Bo Peng
0
0
In this paper, we study the embedded feature selection problem in linear Support Vector Machines (SVMs), in which a cardinality constraint is employed, leading to a fully explainable selection model. The problem is NP-hard due to the presence of the cardinality constraint, even though the original linear SVM amounts to a problem solvable in polynomial time. To handle the hard problem, we first introduce two mixed-integer formulations for which novel SDP relaxations are proposed. Exploiting the sparsity pattern of the relaxations, we decompose the problems and obtain equivalent relaxations in a much smaller cone, making the conic approaches scalable. To make the best usage of the decomposed relaxations, we propose heuristics using the information of its optimal solution. Moreover, an exact procedure is proposed by solving a sequence of mixed-integer decomposed SDPs. Numerical results on classical benchmarking datasets are reported, showing the efficiency and effectiveness of our approach.
4/17/2024
๐
Automated Model Selection for Generalized Linear Models
Benjamin Schwendinger, Florian Schwendinger, Laura Vana-Gur
0
0
In this paper, we show how mixed-integer conic optimization can be used to combine feature subset selection with holistic generalized linear models to fully automate the model selection process. Concretely, we directly optimize for the Akaike and Bayesian information criteria while imposing constraints designed to deal with multicollinearity in the feature selection task. Specifically, we propose a novel pairwise correlation constraint that combines the sign coherence constraint with ideas from classical statistical models like Ridge regression and the OSCAR model.
4/26/2024
๐
Almost exact recovery in noisy semi-supervised learning
Konstantin Avrachenkov, Maximilien Dreveton
0
0
Graph-based semi-supervised learning methods combine the graph structure and labeled data to classify unlabeled data. In this work, we study the effect of a noisy oracle on classification. In particular, we derive the Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) estimator for clustering a Degree Corrected Stochastic Block Model (DC-SBM) when a noisy oracle reveals a fraction of the labels. We then propose an algorithm derived from a continuous relaxation of the MAP, and we establish its consistency. Numerical experiments show that our approach achieves promising performance on synthetic and real data sets, even in the case of very noisy labeled data.
6/6/2024
๐
Adaptive Combinatorial Maximization: Beyond Approximate Greedy Policies
Shlomi Weitzman, Sivan Sabato
0
0
We study adaptive combinatorial maximization, which is a core challenge in machine learning, with applications in active learning as well as many other domains. We study the Bayesian setting, and consider the objectives of maximization under a cardinality constraint and minimum cost coverage. We provide new comprehensive approximation guarantees that subsume previous results, as well as considerably strengthen them. Our approximation guarantees simultaneously support the maximal gain ratio as well as near-submodular utility functions, and include both maximization under a cardinality constraint and a minimum cost coverage guarantee. In addition, we provided an approximation guarantee for a modified prior, which is crucial for obtaining active learning guarantees that do not depend on the smallest probability in the prior. Moreover, we discover a new parameter of adaptive selection policies, which we term the maximal gain ratio. We show that this parameter is strictly less restrictive than the greedy approximation parameter that has been used in previous approximation guarantees, and show that it can be used to provide stronger approximation guarantees than previous results. In particular, we show that the maximal gain ratio is never larger than the greedy approximation factor of a policy, and that it can be considerably smaller. This provides a new insight into the properties that make a policy useful for adaptive combinatorial maximization.
4/3/2024