API Is Enough: Conformal Prediction for Large Language Models Without Logit-Access
2403.01216
0
0
Abstract
This study aims to address the pervasive challenge of quantifying uncertainty in large language models (LLMs) without logit-access. Conformal Prediction (CP), known for its model-agnostic and distribution-free features, is a desired approach for various LLMs and data distributions. However, existing CP methods for LLMs typically assume access to the logits, which are unavailable for some API-only LLMs. In addition, logits are known to be miscalibrated, potentially leading to degraded CP performance. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a novel CP method that (1) is tailored for API-only LLMs without logit-access; (2) minimizes the size of prediction sets; and (3) ensures a statistical guarantee of the user-defined coverage. The core idea of this approach is to formulate nonconformity measures using both coarse-grained (i.e., sample frequency) and fine-grained uncertainty notions (e.g., semantic similarity). Experimental results on both close-ended and open-ended Question Answering tasks show our approach can mostly outperform the logit-based CP baselines.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper introduces a new method for applying conformal prediction to large language models (LLMs) without direct access to their internal logits.
- Conformal prediction is a framework for constructing reliable, adjustable-level prediction sets, which can be useful for tasks like open-ended text generation.
- The proposed approach, called Versatile Conformal Prediction (VCP), relies only on the model's API and does not require modifying the LLM itself.
- VCP is evaluated on a range of tasks, including text classification, question answering, and open-ended text generation, and is shown to provide accurate and well-calibrated prediction sets.
Plain English Explanation
The research paper describes a new way to use a machine learning technique called "conformal prediction" with large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 or BERT. Conformal prediction is a method that allows you to get reliable, adjustable confidence levels on the predictions made by a machine learning model.
However, applying conformal prediction to LLMs has been challenging because it usually requires direct access to the model's internal "logits" - the raw, numerical outputs before they are converted into a final prediction. LLMs are often treated like black boxes, where you can only interact with them through an API that doesn't provide access to these internal details.
The key innovation in this paper is a new approach called "Versatile Conformal Prediction" (VCP) that can use conformal prediction with LLMs without needing access to their logits. Instead, VCP only relies on the standard API that lets you query the LLM and get a prediction. This makes VCP much more widely applicable to real-world LLM deployments.
The researchers evaluate VCP on various tasks like text classification, question answering, and open-ended text generation. They show that VCP can provide well-calibrated and reliable confidence levels on the LLM's predictions, even without access to the internal logits. This could be very useful for applications where you want the language model to give you a sense of how confident it is in its outputs, like generating content for websites or apps.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new method for applying conformal prediction to large language models (LLMs) without requiring direct access to their internal logits. Conformal prediction is a framework for constructing reliable, adjustable-level prediction sets, which can be useful for tasks like open-ended text generation where you want the model to express its uncertainty.
Applying conformal prediction to LLMs has been challenging because it typically requires access to the model's logits - the raw numerical outputs before they are converted into a final prediction. However, LLMs are often treated as black boxes, where you can only interact with them through a limited API that doesn't provide logit-level access.
The key contribution of this paper is the introduction of "Versatile Conformal Prediction" (VCP), a new approach that can leverage conformal prediction with LLMs using only the standard API, without needing access to their internal logits. VCP works by training a separate "calibration model" that can map the LLM's API-level outputs to well-calibrated prediction sets.
The paper evaluates VCP on a range of tasks, including text classification, question answering, and open-ended text generation. The results show that VCP can provide accurate and well-calibrated prediction sets, outperforming alternative approaches that require logit-level access. This suggests VCP could be a valuable tool for deploying conformal prediction with LLMs in real-world applications, where access to internal model details may be limited.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling solution to the challenge of applying conformal prediction to large language models (LLMs) without requiring logit-level access. The proposed Versatile Conformal Prediction (VCP) approach is a clever workaround that relies only on the standard API-level interaction with LLMs, making it much more widely applicable than prior methods.
One potential limitation of the VCP approach is that it requires training a separate "calibration model" to map the LLM's API-level outputs to well-calibrated prediction sets. This additional training step could add complexity and computational overhead, especially if the calibration model needs to be updated as the underlying LLM changes over time. The paper does not extensively explore the sensitivity of VCP's performance to the quality and robustness of the calibration model.
Additionally, while the paper demonstrates VCP's effectiveness across a range of tasks, it would be interesting to see how the method scales to even larger and more complex LLMs, such as those used in open-ended text generation or psychometric predictive modeling. The calibration process may become more challenging as the LLMs become more powerful and their outputs more diverse.
Overall, the VCP approach represents an important step forward in making conformal prediction accessible for LLMs in real-world applications. The paper's thorough evaluation and discussion of the method's strengths and limitations provide a solid foundation for further research and development in this area.
Conclusion
This research paper introduces a novel method called Versatile Conformal Prediction (VCP) that enables the use of conformal prediction with large language models (LLMs) without requiring direct access to their internal logits. Conformal prediction is a powerful framework for constructing reliable, adjustable-level prediction sets, which can be valuable for tasks like open-ended text generation where expressing model uncertainty is important.
The key innovation of VCP is that it can leverage conformal prediction using only the standard API-level interaction with LLMs, rather than needing to access their internal logits. This makes VCP much more widely applicable to real-world LLM deployments, where the model internals are often treated as a black box.
The paper's evaluations demonstrate that VCP can provide accurate and well-calibrated prediction sets across a range of tasks, including text classification, question answering, and open-ended text generation. This suggests VCP could be a valuable tool for deploying LLMs in applications where reliable uncertainty quantification is important.
While the paper presents a compelling solution, future research could explore the sensitivity of VCP's performance to the quality of the calibration model, as well as its scalability to even larger and more complex LLMs. Nevertheless, this work represents an important step forward in making conformal prediction more accessible and applicable to the increasingly powerful world of large language models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔮
An Information Theoretic Perspective on Conformal Prediction
Alvaro H. C. Correia, Fabio Valerio Massoli, Christos Louizos, Arash Behboodi
0
0
Conformal Prediction (CP) is a distribution-free uncertainty estimation framework that constructs prediction sets guaranteed to contain the true answer with a user-specified probability. Intuitively, the size of the prediction set encodes a general notion of uncertainty, with larger sets associated with higher degrees of uncertainty. In this work, we leverage information theory to connect conformal prediction to other notions of uncertainty. More precisely, we prove three different ways to upper bound the intrinsic uncertainty, as described by the conditional entropy of the target variable given the inputs, by combining CP with information theoretical inequalities. Moreover, we demonstrate two direct and useful applications of such connection between conformal prediction and information theory: (i) more principled and effective conformal training objectives that generalize previous approaches and enable end-to-end training of machine learning models from scratch, and (ii) a natural mechanism to incorporate side information into conformal prediction. We empirically validate both applications in centralized and federated learning settings, showing our theoretical results translate to lower inefficiency (average prediction set size) for popular CP methods.
6/27/2024
🔮
Conformal Prediction for Natural Language Processing: A Survey
Margarida M. Campos, Ant'onio Farinhas, Chrysoula Zerva, M'ario A. T. Figueiredo, Andr'e F. T. Martins
0
0
The rapid proliferation of large language models and natural language processing (NLP) applications creates a crucial need for uncertainty quantification to mitigate risks such as hallucinations and to enhance decision-making reliability in critical applications. Conformal prediction is emerging as a theoretically sound and practically useful framework, combining flexibility with strong statistical guarantees. Its model-agnostic and distribution-free nature makes it particularly promising to address the current shortcomings of NLP systems that stem from the absence of uncertainty quantification. This paper provides a comprehensive survey of conformal prediction techniques, their guarantees, and existing applications in NLP, pointing to directions for future research and open challenges.
5/6/2024
Large language model validity via enhanced conformal prediction methods
John J. Cherian, Isaac Gibbs, Emmanuel J. Cand`es
0
0
We develop new conformal inference methods for obtaining validity guarantees on the output of large language models (LLMs). Prior work in conformal language modeling identifies a subset of the text that satisfies a high-probability guarantee of correctness. These methods work by filtering claims from the LLM's original response if a scoring function evaluated on the claim fails to exceed a threshold calibrated via split conformal prediction. Existing methods in this area suffer from two deficiencies. First, the guarantee stated is not conditionally valid. The trustworthiness of the filtering step may vary based on the topic of the response. Second, because the scoring function is imperfect, the filtering step can remove many valuable and accurate claims. We address both of these challenges via two new conformal methods. First, we generalize the conditional conformal procedure of Gibbs et al. (2023) in order to adaptively issue weaker guarantees when they are required to preserve the utility of the output. Second, we show how to systematically improve the quality of the scoring function via a novel algorithm for differentiating through the conditional conformal procedure. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach on both synthetic and real-world datasets.
6/17/2024
Verifiably Robust Conformal Prediction
Linus Jeary, Tom Kuipers, Mehran Hosseini, Nicola Paoletti
0
0
Conformal Prediction (CP) is a popular uncertainty quantification method that provides distribution-free, statistically valid prediction sets, assuming that training and test data are exchangeable. In such a case, CP's prediction sets are guaranteed to cover the (unknown) true test output with a user-specified probability. Nevertheless, this guarantee is violated when the data is subjected to adversarial attacks, which often result in a significant loss of coverage. Recently, several approaches have been put forward to recover CP guarantees in this setting. These approaches leverage variations of randomised smoothing to produce conservative sets which account for the effect of the adversarial perturbations. They are, however, limited in that they only support $ell^2$-bounded perturbations and classification tasks. This paper introduces VRCP (Verifiably Robust Conformal Prediction), a new framework that leverages recent neural network verification methods to recover coverage guarantees under adversarial attacks. Our VRCP method is the first to support perturbations bounded by arbitrary norms including $ell^1$, $ell^2$, and $ell^infty$, as well as regression tasks. We evaluate and compare our approach on image classification tasks (CIFAR10, CIFAR100, and TinyImageNet) and regression tasks for deep reinforcement learning environments. In every case, VRCP achieves above nominal coverage and yields significantly more efficient and informative prediction regions than the SotA.
6/7/2024