Autonomous Driving at Unsignalized Intersections: A Review of Decision-Making Challenges and Reinforcement Learning-Based Solutions

Read original: arXiv:2409.13144 - Published 9/24/2024 by Mohammad Al-Sharman, Luc Edes, Bert Sun, Vishal Jayakumar, Mohamed A. Daoud, Derek Rayside, William Melek
Total Score

0

Autonomous Driving at Unsignalized Intersections: A Review of Decision-Making Challenges and Reinforcement Learning-Based Solutions

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Examines the decision-making challenges faced by autonomous vehicles at unsignalized intersections
  • Reviews reinforcement learning-based solutions to address these challenges
  • Highlights the importance of safe and efficient autonomous navigation in complex urban environments

Plain English Explanation

Autonomous vehicles (AVs) must be able to navigate safely and efficiently through all types of road situations, including unsignalized intersections (those without traffic lights or stop signs). However, decision-making at these intersections can be complex, as AVs must interpret the behaviors of other vehicles and pedestrians in real-time to avoid collisions.

This paper reviews the key challenges involved in autonomous decision-making at unsignalized intersections, and explores how reinforcement learning (RL) techniques can be used to develop effective solutions. RL allows AVs to learn optimal decision-making policies through trial-and-error interactions with their environment, rather than relying on predefined rules.

The paper discusses how RL-based approaches can help AVs assess the intentions of other road users, make safe and efficient crossing decisions, and coordinate with neighboring vehicles to manage the flow of traffic. By leveraging RL, AVs can adapt their behavior to dynamic and uncertain intersection scenarios, paving the way for more robust and intelligent autonomous driving in complex urban settings.

Technical Explanation

The paper first outlines the unique decision-making challenges faced by AVs at unsignalized intersections, including interpreting the behavior of other vehicles, predicting potential conflicts, and coordinating with neighboring vehicles to ensure safe and efficient crossing.

The authors then review how reinforcement learning (RL) techniques can be applied to address these challenges. RL allows AVs to learn optimal decision-making policies by interacting with their environment and receiving rewards for desirable actions, such as avoiding collisions and minimizing delay. This is in contrast to traditional rule-based approaches, which may struggle to handle the complexity and uncertainty of real-world intersection scenarios.

The paper discusses various RL-based frameworks that have been proposed, including multi-agent RL for cooperative decision-making, hierarchical RL for adaptive traffic signal control, and deep RL for sequential optimization of vehicle trajectories. These approaches aim to enable AVs to make safe, efficient, and coordinated decisions in the face of dynamic and uncertain intersection conditions.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the decision-making challenges faced by AVs at unsignalized intersections and the potential of RL-based solutions to address these challenges. However, the authors acknowledge that several limitations and areas for further research remain.

For example, the paper notes that existing RL-based approaches often assume perfect information about the states and actions of other vehicles, which may not be realistic in real-world scenarios. Additionally, the training and deployment of RL-based systems in complex, safety-critical environments like intersections raises concerns about robustness, reliability, and ethical decision-making that warrant further investigation.

Moreover, the paper does not delve into the computational and resource requirements of the proposed RL-based frameworks, which could be a significant practical consideration for their deployment in resource-constrained AV platforms. Addressing these technical and practical challenges will be essential for transitioning RL-based decision-making from research prototypes to real-world autonomous driving applications.

Conclusion

This paper provides a comprehensive review of the decision-making challenges faced by autonomous vehicles at unsignalized intersections and the potential of reinforcement learning-based solutions to address these challenges. By leveraging RL, AVs can learn to make safe, efficient, and coordinated decisions in the face of dynamic and uncertain intersection scenarios, paving the way for more robust and intelligent autonomous driving in complex urban environments.

However, the paper also highlights several limitations and areas for further research, such as the need to account for imperfect information, ensure system robustness and reliability, and address practical deployment considerations. Addressing these challenges will be crucial for the successful integration of RL-based decision-making into real-world autonomous driving applications.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Autonomous Driving at Unsignalized Intersections: A Review of Decision-Making Challenges and Reinforcement Learning-Based Solutions
Total Score

0

Autonomous Driving at Unsignalized Intersections: A Review of Decision-Making Challenges and Reinforcement Learning-Based Solutions

Mohammad Al-Sharman, Luc Edes, Bert Sun, Vishal Jayakumar, Mohamed A. Daoud, Derek Rayside, William Melek

Autonomous driving at unsignalized intersections is still considered a challenging application for machine learning due to the complications associated with handling complex multi-agent scenarios characterized by a high degree of uncertainty. Automating the decision-making process at these safety-critical environments involves comprehending multiple levels of abstractions associated with learning robust driving behaviors to enable the vehicle to navigate efficiently. In this survey, we aim at exploring the state-of-the-art techniques implemented for decision-making applications, with a focus on algorithms that combine Reinforcement Learning (RL) and deep learning for learning traversing policies at unsignalized intersections. The reviewed schemes vary in the proposed driving scenario, in the assumptions made for the used intersection model, in the tackled challenges, and in the learning algorithms that are used. We have presented comparisons for these techniques to highlight their limitations and strengths. Based on our in-depth investigation, it can be discerned that a robust decision-making scheme for navigating real-world unsignalized intersection has yet to be developed. Along with our analysis and discussion, we recommend potential research directions encouraging the interested players to tackle the highlighted challenges. By adhering to our recommendations, decision-making architectures that are both non-overcautious and safe, yet feasible, can be trained and validated in real-world unsignalized intersections environments.

Read more

9/24/2024

Autonomous Vehicle Decision-Making Framework for Considering Malicious Behavior at Unsignalized Intersections
Total Score

0

Autonomous Vehicle Decision-Making Framework for Considering Malicious Behavior at Unsignalized Intersections

Qing Li, Jinxing Hua, Qiuxia Sun

In this paper, we propose a Q-learning based decision-making framework to improve the safety and efficiency of Autonomous Vehicles when they encounter other maliciously behaving vehicles while passing through unsignalized intersections. In Autonomous Vehicles, conventional reward signals are set as regular rewards regarding feedback factors such as safety and efficiency. In this paper, safety gains are modulated by variable weighting parameters to ensure that safety can be emphasized more in emergency situations. The framework proposed in this paper introduces first-order theory of mind inferences on top of conventional rewards, using first-order beliefs as additional reward signals. The decision framework enables Autonomous Vehicles to make informed decisions when encountering vehicles with potentially malicious behaviors at unsignalized intersections, thereby improving the overall safety and efficiency of Autonomous Vehicle transportation systems. In order to verify the performance of the decision framework, this paper uses Prescan/Simulink co-simulations for simulation, and the results show that the performance of the decision framework can meet the set requirements.

Read more

9/27/2024

🏅

Total Score

0

Reinforcement Learning Aided Sequential Optimization for Unsignalized Intersection Management of Robot Traffic

Nishchal Hoysal G., Pavankumar Tallapragada

We consider the problem of optimal unsignalized intersection management, wherein we seek to obtain safe and optimal trajectories, for a set of robots that arrive randomly and continually. This problem involves repeatedly solving a mixed integer program (with robot acceleration trajectories as decision variables) with different parameters, for which the computation time using a naive optimization algorithm scales exponentially with the number of robots and lanes. Hence, such an approach is not suitable for real-time implementation. In this paper, we propose a solution framework that combines learning and sequential optimization. In particular, we propose an algorithm for learning a shared policy that given the traffic state information, determines the crossing order of the robots. Then, we optimize the trajectories of the robots sequentially according to that crossing order. This approach inherently guarantees safety at all times. We validate the performance of this approach using extensive simulations and compare our approach against $5$ different heuristics from the literature in $9$ different simulation settings. Our approach, on average, significantly outperforms the heuristics from the literature in various metrics like objective function, weighted average of crossing times and computation time. For example, in some scenarios, we have observed that our approach offers up to $150%$ improvement in objective value over the first come first serve heuristic. Even on untrained scenarios, our approach shows a consistent improvement (in objective value) of more than $30%$ over all heuristics under consideration. We also show through simulations that the computation time for our approach scales linearly with the number of robots (assuming all other factors are constant). Learnt policies are implemented on physical robots with slightly modified framework to address real-world challenges.

Read more

8/9/2024

Cooperative Decision-Making for CAVs at Unsignalized Intersections: A MARL Approach with Attention and Hierarchical Game Priors
Total Score

0

Cooperative Decision-Making for CAVs at Unsignalized Intersections: A MARL Approach with Attention and Hierarchical Game Priors

Jiaqi Liu, Peng Hang, Xiaoxiang Na, Chao Huang, Jian Sun

The development of autonomous vehicles has shown great potential to enhance the efficiency and safety of transportation systems. However, the decision-making issue in complex human-machine mixed traffic scenarios, such as unsignalized intersections, remains a challenge for autonomous vehicles. While reinforcement learning (RL) has been used to solve complex decision-making problems, existing RL methods still have limitations in dealing with cooperative decision-making of multiple connected autonomous vehicles (CAVs), ensuring safety during exploration, and simulating realistic human driver behaviors. In this paper, a novel and efficient algorithm, Multi-Agent Game-prior Attention Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (MA-GA-DDPG), is proposed to address these limitations. Our proposed algorithm formulates the decision-making problem of CAVs at unsignalized intersections as a decentralized multi-agent reinforcement learning problem and incorporates an attention mechanism to capture interaction dependencies between ego CAV and other agents. The attention weights between the ego vehicle and other agents are then used to screen interaction objects and obtain prior hierarchical game relations, based on which a safety inspector module is designed to improve the traffic safety. Furthermore, both simulation and hardware-in-the-loop experiments were conducted, demonstrating that our method outperforms other baseline approaches in terms of driving safety, efficiency, and comfort.

Read more

9/10/2024