Best Arm Identification for Stochastic Rising Bandits

Overview

• The paper introduces "Stochastic Rising Bandits" (SRBs), which model sequential decision-making problems where the expected reward of available options increases over time as they are selected.
• This setting captures scenarios like online best model selection, where options (e.g., machine learning models) improve in performance as they are used.
• The paper focuses on the "Best Arm Identification" (BAI) problem for SRBs, where the goal is to identify the best option given a fixed budget of rounds.
• Two algorithms are proposed: R-UCBE, which uses a UCB-like approach, and R-SR, which employs a successive reject procedure.
• The paper provides theoretical guarantees on the probability of correctly identifying the optimal option and the simple regret, and also derives a lower bound on the error probability.
• The proposed algorithms are validated on both synthetic and realistic environments.

Plain English Explanation

The paper examines a type of decision-making problem called "Stochastic Rising Bandits" (SRBs). In these problems, the available options (like different machine learning models) get better over time as they are used more. For example, an online system might be choosing between several models to deploy, and the models improve in performance as they are selected and tested.

The specific problem the paper focuses on is called "Best Arm Identification" (BAI). In this setting, you have a fixed budget of rounds (e.g., a limited number of times you can test the models), and at the end, you need to recommend the single best option.

The paper proposes two algorithms to solve this BAI problem for SRBs. The first, called R-UCBE, uses an approach similar to the popular "Upper Confidence Bound" (UCB) algorithm. The second, called R-SR, employs a "successive reject" procedure.

The key contributions of the paper are:

• Proving that with a large enough budget, the proposed algorithms can accurately identify the truly optimal option with high probability.
• Deriving a lower bound on the error probability, showing that a large budget is fundamentally necessary in the SRB setting.
• Validating the algorithms on both synthetic data and real-world problems, demonstrating their practical effectiveness.

The main significance is that the paper provides principled, provably-correct techniques for identifying the best option in settings where the available choices are continuously improving, which is an important real-world scenario.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the "Stochastic Rising Bandits" (SRB) model, which captures sequential decision-making problems where the expected reward of the available options increases each time they are selected. This setting is motivated by scenarios like online best model selection, where machine learning models improve in performance as they are used more.

While previous works have focused on regret minimization in SRBs, this paper tackles the "Best Arm Identification" (BAI) problem. In the BAI setting, the goal is to identify the single best option at the end of a fixed budget of rounds, rather than minimizing cumulative regret.

The authors propose two algorithms to solve the BAI problem for SRBs:

1. R-UCBE: This algorithm uses a UCB-like approach, maintaining upper confidence bounds on the expected rewards of each option and selecting the option with the highest bound.
2. R-SR: This algorithm employs a successive reject procedure, iteratively eliminating the worst-performing option until only the estimated best option remains.

The paper provides theoretical guarantees for these algorithms. Specifically, it shows that with a sufficiently large budget, both R-UCBE and R-SR can achieve high probability of correctly identifying the optimal option, and they also provide bounds on the simple regret (the difference between the expected reward of the recommended option and the true optimal option).

Furthermore, the authors derive a fundamental lower bound on the error probability for the BAI problem in the SRB setting. This lower bound demonstrates that a large enough budget is necessary for accurate identification, as the information gain about the options' rewards becomes more challenging over time.

The proposed algorithms are evaluated on both synthetic data and real-world problems, such as graph-feedback bandits and imprecise multi-armed bandits, where they are shown to outperform baseline approaches.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes several important contributions to the literature on sequential decision-making and best arm identification. The introduction of the SRB model captures a realistic and relevant scenario, and the proposed algorithms provide principled and provably-correct solutions for the BAI problem in this setting.

One potential limitation is that the theoretical guarantees rely on the assumption of a sufficiently large budget. While the authors demonstrate the necessity of this assumption through the derived lower bound, the practical implications of this requirement are not fully explored. It would be interesting to understand how the budget size affects the empirical performance of the algorithms, and whether there are ways to mitigate the impact of a limited budget.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the single-player, non-adversarial setting. It would be valuable to investigate extensions of the SRB model and the proposed algorithms to more complex scenarios, such as adversarial restless multi-armed bandits or Bayes-optimal algorithms for frequentist best arm identification.

Overall, the paper presents a novel and insightful take on the best arm identification problem, with robust theoretical foundations and promising practical results. The work opens up several avenues for further research and exploration in the field of sequential decision-making under uncertainty.

Conclusion

The paper introduces the "Stochastic Rising Bandits" (SRB) model, which captures sequential decision-making problems where the available options improve in expected reward as they are selected. The authors focus on the Best Arm Identification (BAI) problem in this setting, where the goal is to identify the single best option given a fixed budget of rounds.

To address this problem, the paper proposes two algorithms: R-UCBE, which uses a UCB-like approach, and R-SR, which employs a successive reject procedure. The authors prove that these algorithms can accurately identify the optimal option with high probability, given a sufficiently large budget, and also derive a lower bound on the error probability.

The practical significance of this work lies in its ability to provide principled solutions for identifying the best option in scenarios where the available choices are continuously improving, such as online model selection or graph-feedback bandits. The empirical validation of the proposed algorithms on both synthetic and realistic environments further demonstrates their effectiveness.

Overall, this paper contributes valuable theoretical insights and practical techniques for sequential decision-making problems, and it opens up avenues for future research to extend the SRB model and explore more complex settings.