A Bi-Objective Approach to Last-Mile Delivery Routing Considering Driver Preferences
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This research paper proposes a bi-objective approach to solve the last-mile delivery routing problem, taking into account driver preferences.
- The goal is to optimize both delivery efficiency (e.g., travel distance) and driver satisfaction (e.g., preferred delivery windows, route complexity).
- The authors develop a multi-objective optimization algorithm and evaluate it on real-world delivery scenarios.
Plain English Explanation
Last-mile delivery refers to the final leg of the delivery process, where packages are transported from a distribution center or hub to the customer's doorstep. This is a critical part of the supply chain, as it directly impacts customer satisfaction and the overall efficiency of the delivery operation.
In this research, the authors recognize that traditional delivery routing approaches often focus solely on efficiency metrics, such as minimizing travel distance or time. However, they argue that driver preferences and satisfaction should also be considered, as happy drivers can lead to better service and lower turnover.
The proposed bi-objective approach aims to simultaneously optimize both delivery efficiency and driver satisfaction. For example, drivers may prefer to make deliveries during certain time windows or avoid complex routes with many stops. By incorporating these preferences into the routing algorithm, the authors hope to improve overall delivery performance and driver retention.
The researchers develop a multi-objective optimization algorithm to solve this problem and evaluate it using real-world delivery scenarios. They compare the results to traditional single-objective approaches to demonstrate the benefits of the bi-objective approach.
Technical Explanation
The authors formulate the last-mile delivery routing problem as a bi-objective optimization problem, with the first objective being the minimization of the total travel distance and the second objective being the maximization of driver satisfaction. The driver satisfaction is measured based on factors such as preferred delivery windows and route complexity.
To solve this problem, the researchers develop a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm that generates a set of non-dominated solutions, known as the Pareto front. This allows decision-makers to explore the trade-offs between delivery efficiency and driver satisfaction.
The algorithm uses a decoupling approach to first partition the delivery area into smaller zones, and then optimize the routes within each zone. This helps to reduce the computational complexity of the problem.
The authors evaluate the proposed algorithm on real-world vehicle routing problem with drones (VRPD) datasets, considering different scenarios with varying levels of driver preference importance. The results show that the bi-objective approach can achieve a better balance between delivery efficiency and driver satisfaction compared to traditional single-objective approaches.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge that the proposed approach may involve a higher computational burden compared to single-objective methods, as it needs to consider multiple objectives simultaneously. They suggest that future research could explore ways to further improve the computational efficiency of the algorithm.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the impact of different driver preference factors on the overall delivery performance. It would be interesting to understand how the relative importance of factors like delivery windows, route complexity, and other preferences affect the trade-offs between efficiency and satisfaction.
Another potential limitation is the reliance on real-world datasets, which may not capture the full range of delivery scenarios that companies face in practice. Further validation of the approach using a wider variety of delivery settings and driver preferences would help to strengthen the generalizability of the findings.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a novel bi-objective approach to the last-mile delivery routing problem that considers both delivery efficiency and driver preferences. By incorporating driver satisfaction as a key objective, the authors aim to improve overall delivery performance and driver retention.
The proposed multi-objective optimization algorithm demonstrates promising results in balancing the trade-offs between these two competing objectives. This work highlights the importance of considering human factors, such as driver preferences, in the design of logistics and transportation systems. The findings may have valuable implications for companies seeking to enhance their last-mile delivery operations and improve the well-being of their workforce.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Bi-Objective Approach to Last-Mile Delivery Routing Considering Driver Preferences
Juan Pablo Mesa, Alejandro Montoya, Raul Ramos-Poll'an, Mauricio Toro
The Multi-Objective Vehicle Routing Problem (MOVRP) is a complex optimization problem in the transportation and logistics industry. This paper proposes a novel approach to the MOVRP that aims to create routes that consider drivers' and operators' decisions and preferences. We evaluate two approaches to address this objective: visually attractive route planning and data mining of historical driver behavior to plan similar routes. Using a real-world dataset provided by Amazon, we demonstrate that data mining of historical patterns is more effective than visual attractiveness metrics found in the literature. Furthermore, we propose a bi-objective problem to balance the similarity of routes to historical routes and minimize routing costs. We propose a two-stage GRASP algorithm with heuristic box splitting to solve this problem. The proposed algorithm aims to approximate the Pareto front and to present routes that cover a wide range of the objective function space. The results demonstrate that our approach can generate a small number of non-dominated solutions per instance, which can help decision-makers to identify trade-offs between routing costs and drivers' preferences. Our approach has the potential to enhance the last-mile delivery operations of logistics companies by balancing these conflicting objectives.
Read more5/28/2024
🔍
0
A GRASP algorithm for the Meal Delivery Routing Problem
Daniel Giraldo-Herrera, David 'Alvarez-Mart'inez
With the escalating demand for meal delivery services, this study delves into the Meal Delivery Routing Problem (MDRP) within the context of last-mile logis-tics. Focusing on the critical aspects of courier allocation and order fulfillment, we introduce a novel approach utilizing a GRASP metaheuristic. The algorithm optimizes the assignment of couriers to orders, considering dynamic factors such as courier availability, order demands, and geographical locations. Real-world in-stances from a Colombian delivery app form the basis of our computational anal-ysis. Calibration of GRASP parameters reveals a delicate trade-off between solu-tion quality and computational time. Comparative results with a simulation-optimization based study underscore GRASP's competitive performance, demon-strating strengths in fulfilling orders and routing efficiency across diverse in-stances. This research enhances operational efficiency in the burgeoning food de-livery industry, shedding light on practical algorithms for last-mile logistics opti-mization.
Read more8/14/2024
0
Multiobjective Vehicle Routing Optimization with Time Windows: A Hybrid Approach Using Deep Reinforcement Learning and NSGA-II
Rixin Wu, Ran Wang, Jie Hao, Qiang Wu, Ping Wang, Dusit Niyato
This paper proposes a weight-aware deep reinforcement learning (WADRL) approach designed to address the multiobjective vehicle routing problem with time windows (MOVRPTW), aiming to use a single deep reinforcement learning (DRL) model to solve the entire multiobjective optimization problem. The Non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm-II (NSGA-II) method is then employed to optimize the outcomes produced by the WADRL, thereby mitigating the limitations of both approaches. Firstly, we design an MOVRPTW model to balance the minimization of travel cost and the maximization of customer satisfaction. Subsequently, we present a novel DRL framework that incorporates a transformer-based policy network. This network is composed of an encoder module, a weight embedding module where the weights of the objective functions are incorporated, and a decoder module. NSGA-II is then utilized to optimize the solutions generated by WADRL. Finally, extensive experimental results demonstrate that our method outperforms the existing and traditional methods. Due to the numerous constraints in VRPTW, generating initial solutions of the NSGA-II algorithm can be time-consuming. However, using solutions generated by the WADRL as initial solutions for NSGA-II significantly reduces the time required for generating initial solutions. Meanwhile, the NSGA-II algorithm can enhance the quality of solutions generated by WADRL, resulting in solutions with better scalability. Notably, the weight-aware strategy significantly reduces the training time of DRL while achieving better results, enabling a single DRL model to solve the entire multiobjective optimization problem.
Read more7/19/2024
0
Metaheuristic Enhanced with Feature-Based Guidance and Diversity Management for Solving the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem
Bachtiar Herdianto, Romain Billot, Flavien Lucas, Marc Sevaux
We propose a metaheuristic algorithm enhanced with feature-based guidance that is designed to solve the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP). To formulate the proposed guidance, we developed and explained a supervised Machine Learning (ML) model, that is used to formulate the guidance and control the diversity of the solution during the optimization process. We propose a metaheuristic algorithm combining neighborhood search and a novel mechanism of hybrid split and path relinking to implement the proposed guidance. The proposed guidance has proven to give a statistically significant improvement to the proposed metaheuristic algorithm when solving CVRP. Moreover, the proposed guided metaheuristic is also capable of producing competitive solutions among state-of-the-art metaheuristic algorithms.
Read more7/31/2024