DPN: Decoupling Partition and Navigation for Neural Solvers of Min-max Vehicle Routing Problems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a new neural network-based approach called Decoupling Partition and Navigation (DPN) for solving min-max vehicle routing problems
- Decouples the vehicle routing problem into two distinct sub-tasks: partition and navigation
- Demonstrates improved performance compared to previous neural network-based solvers for these types of complex optimization problems
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new way to solve a type of complex logistics problem called the min-max vehicle routing problem using artificial intelligence (AI) techniques. These problems involve finding the most efficient routes for a fleet of vehicles to deliver goods to multiple locations, while minimizing the maximum travel time or distance for any individual vehicle.
The researchers developed a neural network-based approach called Decoupling Partition and Navigation (DPN) that breaks down the problem into two separate parts. The first part is "partition," where the AI system decides how to divide up the delivery locations among the available vehicles. The second part is "navigation," where the system plans the actual routes for each vehicle.
By separating the problem in this way, the DPN approach is able to outperform previous neural network-based solvers for min-max vehicle routing problems. This is an important advancement, as these types of optimization problems are notoriously difficult to solve, especially at scale. The ability to find high-quality solutions more efficiently has the potential to deliver significant cost savings and sustainability improvements for logistics companies and supply chains.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in the DPN approach is the decoupling of the vehicle routing problem into separate partition and navigation sub-tasks. This builds on prior work on neural combinatorial optimization and generalizable neural solvers for vehicle routing problems.
In the partition sub-task, the model learns to assign delivery locations to vehicles in a way that minimizes the maximum travel time or distance for any individual vehicle. This is formulated as a discrete optimization problem, which the researchers solve using a neural network-based approach.
The navigation sub-task then involves planning the actual routes for each vehicle, given the partitioning determined in the first step. For this, the researchers use a reinforcement learning-based method that learns to navigate through the delivery locations efficiently.
The DPN architecture combines these two sub-networks in an end-to-end fashion, allowing the entire system to be trained jointly. Experiments on benchmark min-max vehicle routing problem instances show that DPN outperforms previous neural network-based solvers, including those that do not decouple the problem.
Critical Analysis
The DPN approach represents a promising step forward in applying neural networks to solve complex combinatorial optimization problems like vehicle routing. By breaking down the problem into more manageable sub-tasks, the system is able to find higher-quality solutions more efficiently.
However, the paper does not address the scalability of the DPN approach as the problem size increases, such as the ability to handle hundreds or thousands of delivery locations. There may also be opportunities to further improve performance by incorporating ideas from other recent work on generalizable neural solvers for vehicle routing.
Additionally, the authors note that the DPN system still underperforms compared to the best specialized heuristic algorithms for min-max vehicle routing problems. Further research may be needed to fully close this gap and make neural network-based solvers truly competitive with the state of the art.
Overall, the DPN approach represents a meaningful advance in neural combinatorial optimization, with potential applications beyond just vehicle routing problems. Continued progress in this area could lead to more efficient and scalable solutions for a wide range of complex real-world logistics and scheduling challenges.
Conclusion
The DPN paper introduces a novel neural network-based method for solving min-max vehicle routing problems, a challenging class of logistics optimization problems. By decoupling the problem into separate partition and navigation sub-tasks, the DPN approach is able to outperform previous neural solvers on benchmark instances.
While the DPN system still has room for improvement, particularly in terms of scaling to larger problem sizes, this work represents an important step forward in applying modern AI techniques to complex combinatorial optimization problems. Further research building on these ideas could lead to significant advancements in the ability to efficiently solve real-world logistics challenges, with potential benefits for cost, sustainability, and efficiency across a wide range of industries.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
DPN: Decoupling Partition and Navigation for Neural Solvers of Min-max Vehicle Routing Problems
Zhi Zheng, Shunyu Yao, Zhenkun Wang, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan, Ke Tang
The min-max vehicle routing problem (min-max VRP) traverses all given customers by assigning several routes and aims to minimize the length of the longest route. Recently, reinforcement learning (RL)-based sequential planning methods have exhibited advantages in solving efficiency and optimality. However, these methods fail to exploit the problem-specific properties in learning representations, resulting in less effective features for decoding optimal routes. This paper considers the sequential planning process of min-max VRPs as two coupled optimization tasks: customer partition for different routes and customer navigation in each route (i.e., partition and navigation). To effectively process min-max VRP instances, we present a novel attention-based Partition-and-Navigation encoder (P&N Encoder) that learns distinct embeddings for partition and navigation. Furthermore, we utilize an inherent symmetry in decoding routes and develop an effective agent-permutation-symmetric (APS) loss function. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed Decoupling-Partition-Navigation (DPN) method significantly surpasses existing learning-based methods in both single-depot and multi-depot min-max VRPs. Our code is available at
Read more6/7/2024
0
Deep Reinforcement Learning for Multi-Truck Vehicle Routing Problems with Multi-Leg Demand Routes
Joshua Levin, Randall Correll, Takanori Ide, Takafumi Suzuki, Takaho Saito, Alan Arai
Deep reinforcement learning (RL) has been shown to be effective in producing approximate solutions to some vehicle routing problems (VRPs), especially when using policies generated by encoder-decoder attention mechanisms. While these techniques have been quite successful for relatively simple problem instances, there are still under-researched and highly complex VRP variants for which no effective RL method has been demonstrated. In this work we focus on one such VRP variant, which contains multiple trucks and multi-leg routing requirements. In these problems, demand is required to move along sequences of nodes, instead of just from a start node to an end node. With the goal of making deep RL a viable strategy for real-world industrial-scale supply chain logistics, we develop new extensions to existing encoder-decoder attention models which allow them to handle multiple trucks and multi-leg routing requirements. Our models have the advantage that they can be trained for a small number of trucks and nodes, and then embedded into a large supply chain to yield solutions for larger numbers of trucks and nodes. We test our approach on a real supply chain environment arising in the operations of Japanese automotive parts manufacturer Aisin Corporation, and find that our algorithm outperforms Aisin's previous best solution.
Read more8/28/2024
0
Multi-Task Learning for Routing Problem with Cross-Problem Zero-Shot Generalization
Fei Liu, Xi Lin, Zhenkun Wang, Qingfu Zhang, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan
Vehicle routing problems (VRPs), which can be found in numerous real-world applications, have been an important research topic for several decades. Recently, the neural combinatorial optimization (NCO) approach that leverages a learning-based model to solve VRPs without manual algorithm design has gained substantial attention. However, current NCO methods typically require building one model for each routing problem, which significantly hinders their practical application for real-world industry problems with diverse attributes. In this work, we make the first attempt to tackle the crucial challenge of cross-problem generalization. In particular, we formulate VRPs as different combinations of a set of shared underlying attributes and solve them simultaneously via a single model through attribute composition. In this way, our proposed model can successfully solve VRPs with unseen attribute combinations in a zero-shot generalization manner. Extensive experiments are conducted on eleven VRP variants, benchmark datasets, and industry logistic scenarios. The results show that the unified model demonstrates superior performance in the eleven VRPs, reducing the average gap to around 5% from over 20% in the existing approach and achieving a significant performance boost on benchmark datasets as well as a real-world logistics application. The source code is included in https://github.com/FeiLiu36/MTNCO.
Read more4/15/2024
🧠
0
Genetic Algorithms with Neural Cost Predictor for Solving Hierarchical Vehicle Routing Problems
Abhay Sobhanan, Junyoung Park, Jinkyoo Park, Changhyun Kwon
When vehicle routing decisions are intertwined with higher-level decisions, the resulting optimization problems pose significant challenges for computation. Examples are the multi-depot vehicle routing problem (MDVRP), where customers are assigned to depots before delivery, and the capacitated location routing problem (CLRP), where the locations of depots should be determined first. A simple and straightforward approach for such hierarchical problems would be to separate the higher-level decisions from the complicated vehicle routing decisions. For each higher-level decision candidate, we may evaluate the underlying vehicle routing problems to assess the candidate. As this approach requires solving vehicle routing problems multiple times, it has been regarded as impractical in most cases. We propose a novel deep-learning-based approach called Genetic Algorithm with Neural Cost Predictor (GANCP) to tackle the challenge and simplify algorithm developments. For each higher-level decision candidate, we predict the objective function values of the underlying vehicle routing problems using a pre-trained graph neural network without actually solving the routing problems. In particular, our proposed neural network learns the objective values of the HGS-CVRP open-source package that solves capacitated vehicle routing problems. Our numerical experiments show that this simplified approach is effective and efficient in generating high-quality solutions for both MDVRP and CLRP and has the potential to expedite algorithm developments for complicated hierarchical problems. We provide computational results evaluated in the standard benchmark instances used in the literature.
Read more9/10/2024