Blocking Bandits

Overview

• The paper explores a novel stochastic multi-armed bandit setting where playing an arm makes it unavailable for a fixed number of time slots afterwards.
• This models situations where reusing an arm too often is undesirable or infeasible, such as making the same product recommendation repeatedly or scheduling compute jobs on machines.
• The authors analyze the complexity of the problem and propose algorithms to optimize cumulative reward in this setting.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at a new kind of multi-armed bandit problem. In a standard multi-armed bandit, you have a set of "arms" (options) you can pull, each with a different probability of giving you a reward. The goal is to maximize your total reward over time by figuring out which arms are most rewarding.

In this new setting, playing an arm makes it unavailable for a fixed number of time slots afterwards. This could model a real-world scenario like making product recommendations - you don't want to recommend the same product over and over to the same customer. Or it could model scheduling compute jobs on machines, where a machine is unavailable for a period after running a job.

The key challenge is that you have to balance exploiting the most rewarding arms while also exploring to find new rewarding arms that haven't been played recently. The paper analyzes the theoretical complexity of this problem and proposes algorithms to tackle it effectively.

Technical Explanation

The paper shows that with full knowledge of the rewards and delays of all the arms, the problem of optimizing cumulative reward is computationally intractable. The authors prove this by mapping the problem to the PINWHEEL scheduling problem, which is known to be NP-hard.

However, the authors then show that a simple greedy algorithm, which plays the available arm with the highest reward, is asymptotically (1-1/e) optimal. This means it achieves at least 63% of the optimal reward, which is a strong guarantee.

When the rewards are unknown, the authors design a UCB (Upper Confidence Bound) based algorithm that achieves bounded regret compared to the greedy algorithm. Regret measures how much reward is lost compared to the optimal strategy. The algorithm leverages the "free exploration" provided by the unavailability of arms - when an arm is unavailable, the algorithm can explore other arms without sacrificing reward.

Finally, the authors consider the case where all the delays are equal. In this setting, the problem reduces to a Combinatorial Semi-bandit problem, for which they provide a lower bound on the achievable regret.

Critical Analysis

The paper tackles an interesting and practical extension of the multi-armed bandit problem. The theoretical analysis of the problem complexity and the design of near-optimal algorithms are both strong contributions.

One potential limitation is that the paper assumes the rewards and delays of the arms are known in advance. In many real-world scenarios, this information may not be available, and the algorithms would need to learn it from experience. The authors do address the unknown rewards case, but further research could investigate more realistic settings with partial information.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the objective of maximizing cumulative reward. In some applications, other objectives such as fairness or exploration may be more relevant. Extending the framework to handle multiple, potentially conflicting objectives could be an interesting direction for future work.

Overall, this paper presents a novel multi-armed bandit setting and provides valuable theoretical insights and algorithmic techniques that could inform the design of real-world systems facing similar constraints.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new stochastic multi-armed bandit problem where playing an arm makes it unavailable for a fixed number of time slots. The authors analyze the computational complexity of the problem and propose efficient algorithms to optimize cumulative reward in this setting.

The key contributions are:

1. Showing the intractability of the problem with full information
2. Providing a simple greedy algorithm with strong asymptotic guarantees
3. Designing a UCB-based algorithm that achieves bounded regret under unknown rewards
4. Establishing a lower bound for the special case of equal delays

These results offer valuable insights for developing multi-armed bandit systems that need to account for constraints on arm usage, with applications in recommendation systems, job scheduling, and beyond.