Causal Bayesian Optimization via Exogenous Distribution Learning
2402.02277
0
0
🛠️
Abstract
Maximizing a target variable as an operational objective in a structural causal model is an important problem. Existing Causal Bayesian Optimization~(CBO) methods either rely on hard interventions that alter the causal structure to maximize the reward; or introduce action nodes to endogenous variables so that the data generation mechanisms are adjusted to achieve the objective. In this paper, a novel method is introduced to learn the distribution of exogenous variables, which is typically ignored or marginalized through expectation by existing methods. Exogenous distribution learning improves the approximation accuracy of structural causal models in a surrogate model that is usually trained with limited observational data. Moreover, the learned exogenous distribution extends existing CBO to general causal schemes beyond Additive Noise Models~(ANM). The recovery of exogenous variables allows us to use a more flexible prior for noise or unobserved hidden variables. We develop a new CBO method by leveraging the learned exogenous distribution. Experiments on different datasets and applications show the benefits of our proposed method.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel method for learning the distribution of exogenous variables in a structured causal model, which can improve the accuracy of the model and extend the applicability of Causal Bayesian Optimization (CBO) techniques.
- Existing CBO methods either rely on hard interventions that alter the causal structure or introduce action nodes to endogenous variables, adjusting the data generation mechanisms to achieve the objective.
- The proposed method learns the distribution of exogenous variables, which is typically ignored or marginalized by existing methods, to better approximate the structured causal model.
- The learned exogenous distribution allows the use of more flexible priors for noise or unobserved hidden variables, extending CBO beyond Additive Noise Models (ANM).
- Experiments on different datasets and applications demonstrate the benefits of the proposed method.
Plain English Explanation
In the world of data analysis and optimization, researchers often need to find ways to maximize a target variable, such as profit or customer satisfaction. This is an important problem that has been studied extensively.
Existing methods, known as Causal Bayesian Optimization (CBO), have taken two main approaches:
- They rely on hard interventions that change the underlying causal structure of the system to maximize the reward.
- They introduce action nodes to endogenous variables, which means they adjust the way the data is generated to achieve the desired objective.
However, these methods often overlook or simplify an important aspect of the problem: the distribution of the exogenous variables, which are factors outside the system that can influence the target variable.
The new method proposed in this paper focuses on learning the distribution of these exogenous variables. By understanding how these external factors behave, the researchers can build a more accurate surrogate model of the causal system. This, in turn, allows them to use a more flexible prior for noise or unobserved hidden variables, extending the CBO techniques beyond the Additive Noise Model.
The experiments show that this approach can provide significant benefits, leading to better optimization and more reliable results.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel method for learning the distribution of exogenous variables in a structured causal model, which is typically ignored or marginalized through expectation by existing Causal Bayesian Optimization (CBO) methods.
Existing CBO methods either rely on hard interventions that alter the causal structure to maximize the reward, or introduce action nodes to endogenous variables so that the data generation mechanisms are adjusted to achieve the objective. In contrast, the proposed method focuses on learning the distribution of exogenous variables, which can improve the approximation accuracy of the structured causal model in a surrogate model usually trained with limited observational data.
Moreover, the learned exogenous distribution extends existing CBO to general causal schemes beyond Additive Noise Models (ANM). The recovery of exogenous variables allows the use of more flexible priors for noise or unobserved hidden variables.
The paper develops a new CBO method that leverages the learned exogenous distribution. Experiments on different datasets and applications, such as demand sampling and generalization, demonstrate the benefits of the proposed approach.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to improving the accuracy and flexibility of Causal Bayesian Optimization (CBO) methods by focusing on learning the distribution of exogenous variables. This is a novel contribution that addresses an important limitation in existing CBO techniques.
One potential caveat is the reliance on limited observational data for training the surrogate model. In real-world scenarios, the availability of high-quality, diverse data can be a challenge. The authors acknowledge this limitation and suggest that further research is needed to explore ways to address this, such as leveraging additional data sources or developing more robust modeling techniques.
Another area for further investigation is the generalization of the proposed method to a wider range of causal schemes beyond Additive Noise Models (ANM). While the authors demonstrate the benefits of their approach in extending CBO to general causal schemes, there may be additional complexities or limitations that could be explored in future studies.
Overall, the paper presents a well-designed and promising approach to improving causal modeling and optimization. The focus on learning exogenous distributions is a valuable contribution that could have significant implications for a variety of applications, from demand forecasting to policy optimization.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel method for learning the distribution of exogenous variables in a structured causal model, which can enhance the accuracy of Causal Bayesian Optimization (CBO) techniques. By addressing the typically ignored or marginalized exogenous variables, the proposed approach extends the applicability of CBO beyond Additive Noise Models and allows for more flexible priors for noise or unobserved hidden variables.
The experimental results demonstrate the benefits of this method across different datasets and applications, suggesting that this research could have important implications for a wide range of optimization and decision-making problems. As the availability and complexity of data continue to grow, the ability to effectively model and optimize causal relationships will become increasingly crucial. This paper represents an important step forward in advancing the field of causal modeling and optimization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Bayesian Intervention Optimization for Causal Discovery
Yuxuan Wang, Mingzhou Liu, Xinwei Sun, Wei Wang, Yizhou Wang
0
0
Causal discovery is crucial for understanding complex systems and informing decisions. While observational data can uncover causal relationships under certain assumptions, it often falls short, making active interventions necessary. Current methods, such as Bayesian and graph-theoretical approaches, do not prioritize decision-making and often rely on ideal conditions or information gain, which is not directly related to hypothesis testing. We propose a novel Bayesian optimization-based method inspired by Bayes factors that aims to maximize the probability of obtaining decisive and correct evidence. Our approach uses observational data to estimate causal models under different hypotheses, evaluates potential interventions pre-experimentally, and iteratively updates priors to refine interventions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method through various experiments. Our contributions provide a robust framework for efficient causal discovery through active interventions, enhancing the practical application of theoretical advancements.
6/18/2024
🛠️
Learning Relevant Contextual Variables Within Bayesian Optimization
Julien Martinelli, Ayush Bharti, Armi Tiihonen, S. T. John, Louis Filstroff, Sabina J. Sloman, Patrick Rinke, Samuel Kaski
0
0
Contextual Bayesian Optimization (CBO) efficiently optimizes black-box functions with respect to design variables, while simultaneously integrating contextual information regarding the environment, such as experimental conditions. However, the relevance of contextual variables is not necessarily known beforehand. Moreover, contextual variables can sometimes be optimized themselves at an additional cost, a setting overlooked by current CBO algorithms. Cost-sensitive CBO would simply include optimizable contextual variables as part of the design variables based on their cost. Instead, we adaptively select a subset of contextual variables to include in the optimization, based on the trade-off between their relevance and the additional cost incurred by optimizing them compared to leaving them to be determined by the environment. We learn the relevance of contextual variables by sensitivity analysis of the posterior surrogate model while minimizing the cost of optimization by leveraging recent developments on early stopping for BO. We empirically evaluate our proposed Sensitivity-Analysis-Driven Contextual BO (SADCBO) method against alternatives on both synthetic and real-world experiments, together with extensive ablation studies, and demonstrate a consistent improvement across examples.
5/27/2024
🛠️
Heteroscedastic Preferential Bayesian Optimization with Informative Noise Distributions
Marshal Arijona Sinaga, Julien Martinelli, Vikas Garg, Samuel Kaski
0
0
Preferential Bayesian optimization (PBO) is a sample-efficient framework for learning human preferences between candidate designs. PBO classically relies on homoscedastic noise models to represent human aleatoric uncertainty. Yet, such noise fails to accurately capture the varying levels of human aleatoric uncertainty, particularly when the user possesses partial knowledge among different pairs of candidates. For instance, a chemist with solid expertise in glucose-related molecules may easily compare two compounds from that family while struggling to compare alcohol-related molecules. Currently, PBO overlooks this uncertainty during the search for a new candidate through the maximization of the acquisition function, consequently underestimating the risk associated with human uncertainty. To address this issue, we propose a heteroscedastic noise model to capture human aleatoric uncertainty. This model adaptively assigns noise levels based on the distance of a specific input to a predefined set of reliable inputs known as anchors provided by the human. Anchors encapsulate partial knowledge and offer insight into the comparative difficulty of evaluating different candidate pairs. Such a model can be seamlessly integrated into the acquisition function, thus leading to candidate design pairs that elegantly trade informativeness and ease of comparison for the human expert. We perform an extensive empirical evaluation of the proposed approach, demonstrating a consistent improvement over homoscedastic PBO.
5/24/2024
➖
Optimization-based Causal Estimation from Heterogenous Environments
Mingzhang Yin, Yixin Wang, David M. Blei
0
0
This paper presents a new optimization approach to causal estimation. Given data that contains covariates and an outcome, which covariates are causes of the outcome, and what is the strength of the causality? In classical machine learning (ML), the goal of optimization is to maximize predictive accuracy. However, some covariates might exhibit a non-causal association with the outcome. Such spurious associations provide predictive power for classical ML, but they prevent us from causally interpreting the result. This paper proposes CoCo, an optimization algorithm that bridges the gap between pure prediction and causal inference. CoCo leverages the recently-proposed idea of environments, datasets of covariates/response where the causal relationships remain invariant but where the distribution of the covariates changes from environment to environment. Given datasets from multiple environments-and ones that exhibit sufficient heterogeneity-CoCo maximizes an objective for which the only solution is the causal solution. We describe the theoretical foundations of this approach and demonstrate its effectiveness on simulated and real datasets. Compared to classical ML and existing methods, CoCo provides more accurate estimates of the causal model and more accurate predictions under interventions.
6/12/2024