Closing the Gap: Achieving Global Convergence (Last Iterate) of Actor-Critic under Markovian Sampling with Neural Network Parametrization
2405.01843
0
0
🧠
Abstract
The current state-of-the-art theoretical analysis of Actor-Critic (AC) algorithms significantly lags in addressing the practical aspects of AC implementations. This crucial gap needs bridging to bring the analysis in line with practical implementations of AC. To address this, we advocate for considering the MMCLG criteria: textbf{M}ulti-layer neural network parametrization for actor/critic, textbf{M}arkovian sampling, textbf{C}ontinuous state-action spaces, the performance of the textbf{L}ast iterate, and textbf{G}lobal optimality. These aspects are practically significant and have been largely overlooked in existing theoretical analyses of AC algorithms. In this work, we address these gaps by providing the first comprehensive theoretical analysis of AC algorithms that encompasses all five crucial practical aspects (covers MMCLG criteria). We establish global convergence sample complexity bounds of $tilde{mathcal{O}}left({epsilon^{-3}}right)$. We achieve this result through our novel use of the weak gradient domination property of MDP's and our unique analysis of the error in critic estimation.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper addresses a crucial gap in the theoretical analysis of Actor-Critic (AC) algorithms, which traditionally lags behind practical implementations.
- The authors propose considering the MMCLG criteria: Multi-layer neural network parametrization, Markovian sampling, Continuous state-action spaces, the performance of the Last iterate, and Global optimality.
- The paper provides the first comprehensive theoretical analysis of AC algorithms that encompasses all five crucial practical aspects.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on improving the theoretical understanding of a popular machine learning technique called Actor-Critic (AC) algorithms. These algorithms are widely used in reinforcement learning, which is a type of machine learning that trains agents to make decisions in complex environments.
The key idea behind AC algorithms is to have two separate components: an "actor" that learns how to take actions, and a "critic" that evaluates the quality of those actions. This approach has proven to be effective in many real-world applications, but the theoretical analysis of AC algorithms has not kept up with the practical implementations.
The authors of the paper argue that the current theoretical analysis of AC algorithms is missing several important practical considerations, such as the use of multi-layer neural networks, continuous state-action spaces, and the performance of the final solution. They propose a set of criteria, called MMCLG, that they believe should be included in the theoretical analysis to better reflect the practical realities of AC implementations.
Using these MMCLG criteria, the paper presents a new theoretical analysis of AC algorithms that provides strong guarantees on the algorithm's convergence and performance. This is a significant contribution, as it helps bridge the gap between the theory and practice of these important machine learning techniques.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a comprehensive theoretical analysis of Actor-Critic (AC) algorithms, addressing several practical aspects that have been largely overlooked in previous analyses.
The authors introduce the MMCLG criteria, which stand for:
- Multi-layer neural network parametrization for the actor and critic components
- Markovian sampling of the state-action pairs
- Continuous state-action spaces
- The performance of the Last iterate
- Global optimality
The paper provides the first comprehensive theoretical analysis of AC algorithms that covers all five of these practical aspects. The analysis establishes global convergence sample complexity bounds of $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}\left(\epsilon^{-3}\right)$, which is a measure of how quickly the algorithm converges to an optimal solution.
The authors achieve this result through a novel use of the weak gradient domination property of Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) and a unique analysis of the error in the critic estimation. These technical contributions allow the paper to bridge the gap between the theory and practice of AC algorithms.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a significant contribution by addressing the practical aspects of AC algorithms that have been largely overlooked in previous theoretical analyses. The authors' focus on the MMCLG criteria is a crucial step towards aligning the theory with the practical realities of AC implementations.
However, the paper does not address the potential challenges that may arise when applying the proposed analysis to more complex real-world problems. The theoretical guarantees are established under certain assumptions, such as the availability of a generative model of the MDP, which may not always be the case in practice.
Additionally, the paper does not provide any empirical validation of the theoretical results. It would be valuable to see how the proposed analysis performs on benchmark reinforcement learning tasks and whether the theoretical guarantees translate to practical improvements in algorithm performance.
Furthermore, the paper could have discussed the limitations of the MMCLG criteria and the potential trade-offs or challenges that may arise when trying to satisfy all five aspects simultaneously. Acknowledging and addressing such limitations would help readers understand the scope and applicability of the proposed analysis.
Conclusion
This paper presents a significant advancement in the theoretical understanding of Actor-Critic (AC) algorithms, a widely used technique in reinforcement learning. By incorporating the MMCLG criteria, the authors have developed a comprehensive theoretical analysis that aligns with the practical aspects of AC implementations.
The strong convergence guarantees established in the paper are an important step towards bridging the gap between the theory and practice of AC algorithms. This work has the potential to inform the design of more effective and robust AC-based reinforcement learning systems, which could have far-reaching implications for various applications, from robotics and autonomous systems to game AI and decision-making optimization.
While the paper does not address all the potential challenges and limitations, it lays the groundwork for further research and refinement of the theoretical analysis of AC algorithms. As the field of reinforcement learning continues to evolve, this work serves as a valuable contribution to the ongoing effort to deepen our understanding of these powerful machine learning techniques.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🗣️
Non-Asymptotic Analysis for Single-Loop (Natural) Actor-Critic with Compatible Function Approximation
Yudan Wang, Yue Wang, Yi Zhou, Shaofeng Zou
0
0
Actor-critic (AC) is a powerful method for learning an optimal policy in reinforcement learning, where the critic uses algorithms, e.g., temporal difference (TD) learning with function approximation, to evaluate the current policy and the actor updates the policy along an approximate gradient direction using information from the critic. This paper provides the textit{tightest} non-asymptotic convergence bounds for both the AC and natural AC (NAC) algorithms. Specifically, existing studies show that AC converges to an $epsilon+varepsilon_{text{critic}}$ neighborhood of stationary points with the best known sample complexity of $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-2})$ (up to a log factor), and NAC converges to an $epsilon+varepsilon_{text{critic}}+sqrt{varepsilon_{text{actor}}}$ neighborhood of the global optimum with the best known sample complexity of $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-3})$, where $varepsilon_{text{critic}}$ is the approximation error of the critic and $varepsilon_{text{actor}}$ is the approximation error induced by the insufficient expressive power of the parameterized policy class. This paper analyzes the convergence of both AC and NAC algorithms with compatible function approximation. Our analysis eliminates the term $varepsilon_{text{critic}}$ from the error bounds while still achieving the best known sample complexities. Moreover, we focus on the challenging single-loop setting with a single Markovian sample trajectory. Our major technical novelty lies in analyzing the stochastic bias due to policy-dependent and time-varying compatible function approximation in the critic, and handling the non-ergodicity of the MDP due to the single Markovian sample trajectory. Numerical results are also provided in the appendix.
6/5/2024
🌿
Finite-Time Analysis of Three-Timescale Constrained Actor-Critic and Constrained Natural Actor-Critic Algorithms
Prashansa Panda, Shalabh Bhatnagar
0
0
Actor Critic methods have found immense applications on a wide range of Reinforcement Learning tasks especially when the state-action space is large. In this paper, we consider actor critic and natural actor critic algorithms with function approximation for constrained Markov decision processes (C-MDP) involving inequality constraints and carry out a non-asymptotic analysis for both of these algorithms in a non-i.i.d (Markovian) setting. We consider the long-run average cost criterion where both the objective and the constraint functions are suitable policy-dependent long-run averages of certain prescribed cost functions. We handle the inequality constraints using the Lagrange multiplier method. We prove that these algorithms are guaranteed to find a first-order stationary point (i.e., $Vert nabla L(theta,gamma)Vert_2^2 leq epsilon$) of the performance (Lagrange) function $L(theta,gamma)$, with a sample complexity of $mathcal{tilde{O}}(epsilon^{-2.5})$ in the case of both Constrained Actor Critic (C-AC) and Constrained Natural Actor Critic (C-NAC) algorithms. We also show the results of experiments on three different Safety-Gym environments.
5/30/2024
Global Optimality without Mixing Time Oracles in Average-reward RL via Multi-level Actor-Critic
Bhrij Patel, Wesley A. Suttle, Alec Koppel, Vaneet Aggarwal, Brian M. Sadler, Amrit Singh Bedi, Dinesh Manocha
0
0
In the context of average-reward reinforcement learning, the requirement for oracle knowledge of the mixing time, a measure of the duration a Markov chain under a fixed policy needs to achieve its stationary distribution, poses a significant challenge for the global convergence of policy gradient methods. This requirement is particularly problematic due to the difficulty and expense of estimating mixing time in environments with large state spaces, leading to the necessity of impractically long trajectories for effective gradient estimation in practical applications. To address this limitation, we consider the Multi-level Actor-Critic (MAC) framework, which incorporates a Multi-level Monte-Carlo (MLMC) gradient estimator. With our approach, we effectively alleviate the dependency on mixing time knowledge, a first for average-reward MDPs global convergence. Furthermore, our approach exhibits the tightest available dependence of $mathcal{O}left( sqrt{tau_{mix}} right)$known from prior work. With a 2D grid world goal-reaching navigation experiment, we demonstrate that MAC outperforms the existing state-of-the-art policy gradient-based method for average reward settings.
6/24/2024
AC4MPC: Actor-Critic Reinforcement Learning for Nonlinear Model Predictive Control
Rudolf Reiter, Andrea Ghezzi, Katrin Baumgartner, Jasper Hoffmann, Robert D. McAllister, Moritz Diehl
0
0
Ac{MPC} and ac{RL} are two powerful control strategies with, arguably, complementary advantages. In this work, we show how actor-critic ac{RL} techniques can be leveraged to improve the performance of ac{MPC}. The ac{RL} critic is used as an approximation of the optimal value function, and an actor roll-out provides an initial guess for primal variables of the ac{MPC}. A parallel control architecture is proposed where each ac{MPC} instance is solved twice for different initial guesses. Besides the actor roll-out initialization, a shifted initialization from the previous solution is used. Thereafter, the actor and the critic are again used to approximately evaluate the infinite horizon cost of these trajectories. The control actions from the lowest-cost trajectory are applied to the system at each time step. We establish that the proposed algorithm is guaranteed to outperform the original ac{RL} policy plus an error term that depends on the accuracy of the critic and decays with the horizon length of the ac{MPC} formulation. Moreover, we do not require globally optimal solutions for these guarantees to hold. The approach is demonstrated on an illustrative toy example and an ac{AD} overtaking scenario.
6/7/2024