CLOSURE: Fast Quantification of Pose Uncertainty Sets
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents a new method called CLOSURE for quickly estimating the uncertainty in the 6D pose of an object.
- CLOSURE uses a dynamical system perspective to efficiently compute the minimum enclosing geodesic ball, which represents the pose uncertainty set.
- The method is computationally efficient and can be used to quantify the uncertainty in deep learning-based 6D object pose estimation systems.
Plain English Explanation
CLOSURE is a new technique that can quickly figure out how uncertain the 6D pose (position and orientation) of an object is. When you use a machine learning model to estimate the 6D pose of an object, there is always some uncertainty in the prediction. CLOSURE provides a way to efficiently calculate a region that contains all the possible poses the object could be in, given the uncertainty in the prediction.
The key idea is to think of the pose prediction as a point moving in a special space called the Special Orthogonal group, which represents all possible 3D rotations. CLOSURE uses a dynamical system perspective to track the movement of this point and find the smallest ball in this space that contains all the possible poses. This ball represents the overall uncertainty in the 6D pose estimate.
By using this efficient computational approach, CLOSURE can quickly quantify the uncertainty in 6D pose estimates from deep learning models, without needing to run many expensive simulations. This makes it a useful tool for understanding the reliability of AI systems that predict the 3D poses of objects.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new method called CLOSURE for efficiently computing the minimum enclosing geodesic ball (MEGB) that represents the uncertainty set of a 6D object pose estimate. CLOSURE takes a dynamical systems perspective, modeling the pose prediction as a point moving in the Special Orthogonal group, the space of all 3D rotations.
By analyzing the properties of this dynamical system, the authors show that the MEGB can be computed by solving a simple optimization problem. This is in contrast to previous approaches that required expensive Monte Carlo sampling to estimate the pose uncertainty set.
The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of CLOSURE on both synthetic and real-world datasets, showing that it can accurately quantify the uncertainty in 6D pose estimates from deep learning models much more efficiently than existing methods. This has important implications for developing reliable AI systems for 3D pose estimation and uncertainty-aware 3D human pose estimation.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a novel and computationally efficient approach to quantifying the uncertainty in 6D object pose estimates. However, the authors acknowledge that CLOSURE relies on some simplifying assumptions, such as assuming the pose uncertainty follows a Gaussian distribution. In practice, the true uncertainty distributions may be more complex, which could limit the accuracy of CLOSURE in certain scenarios.
Additionally, the paper only evaluates CLOSURE on a relatively small set of test cases. Further research would be needed to understand how well the method generalizes to a wider range of object types, sensing modalities, and real-world application domains. There may also be additional factors to consider when estimating pose uncertainty, such as the quality of the training data and model architecture.
Overall, the CLOSURE method represents an important step forward in efficiently quantifying pose uncertainty, but more work is needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and practical implications for building reliable 3D perception systems.
Conclusion
The CLOSURE method presented in this paper provides a computationally efficient way to quantify the uncertainty in 6D object pose estimates from deep learning models. By taking a dynamical systems perspective and solving a simple optimization problem, CLOSURE can quickly compute a minimum enclosing geodesic ball that represents the pose uncertainty set.
This has important applications in developing reliable AI systems for 3D perception tasks that need to reason about the confidence and limitations of their predictions. While the method relies on some simplifying assumptions, the paper demonstrates its effectiveness on both synthetic and real-world data, paving the way for more uncertainty-aware 3D computer vision and robotics applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
CLOSURE: Fast Quantification of Pose Uncertainty Sets
Yihuai Gao, Yukai Tang, Han Qi, Heng Yang
We investigate uncertainty quantification of 6D pose estimation from learned noisy measurements (e.g. keypoints and pose hypotheses). Assuming unknown-but-bounded measurement noises, a pose uncertainty set (PURSE) is a subset of SE(3) that contains all possible 6D poses compatible with the measurements. Despite being simple to formulate and its ability to embed uncertainty, the PURSE is difficult to manipulate and interpret due to the many abstract nonconvex polynomial constraints. An appealing simplification of PURSE is to find its minimum enclosing geodesic ball (MEGB), i.e., a point pose estimation with minimum worst-case error bound. We contribute (i) a geometric interpretation of the nonconvex PURSE, and (ii) a fast algorithm to inner approximate the MEGB. Particularly, we show the PURSE corresponds to the feasible set of a constrained dynamical system or the intersection of multiple geodesic balls, and this perspective allows us to design an algorithm to densely sample the boundary of the PURSE through strategic random walks. We then use the miniball algorithm to compute the MEGB of PURSE samples, leading to an inner approximation. Our algorithm is named CLOSURE (enClosing baLl frOm purSe boUndaRy samplEs) and it enables computing a certificate of approximation tightness by calculating the relative size ratio between the inner approximation and the outer approximation. Running on a single RTX 3090 GPU, CLOSURE achieves the relative ratio of 92.8% on the LM-O dataset, 91.4% on the 3DMatch dataset and 96.6% on the LM dataset with the average runtime less than 0.3 second. Obtaining comparable worst-case error bound but 398x 833x and 23.6x faster than the outer approximation GRCC, CLOSURE enables uncertainty quantification of 6D pose estimation to be implemented in real-time robot perception applications.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Uncertainty Quantification with Deep Ensembles for 6D Object Pose Estimation
Kira Wursthorn, Markus Hillemann, Markus Ulrich
The estimation of 6D object poses is a fundamental task in many computer vision applications. Particularly, in high risk scenarios such as human-robot interaction, industrial inspection, and automation, reliable pose estimates are crucial. In the last years, increasingly accurate and robust deep-learning-based approaches for 6D object pose estimation have been proposed. Many top-performing methods are not end-to-end trainable but consist of multiple stages. In the context of deep uncertainty quantification, deep ensembles are considered as state of the art since they have been proven to produce well-calibrated and robust uncertainty estimates. However, deep ensembles can only be applied to methods that can be trained end-to-end. In this work, we propose a method to quantify the uncertainty of multi-stage 6D object pose estimation approaches with deep ensembles. For the implementation, we choose SurfEmb as representative, since it is one of the top-performing 6D object pose estimation approaches in the BOP Challenge 2022. We apply established metrics and concepts for deep uncertainty quantification to evaluate the results. Furthermore, we propose a novel uncertainty calibration score for regression tasks to quantify the quality of the estimated uncertainty.
Read more5/3/2024
0
MaskVal: Simple but Effective Uncertainty Quantification for 6D Pose Estimation
Philipp Quentin, Daniel Goehring
For the use of 6D pose estimation in robotic applications, reliable poses are of utmost importance to ensure a safe, reliable and predictable operational performance. Despite these requirements, state-of-the-art 6D pose estimators often do not provide any uncertainty quantification for their pose estimates at all, or if they do, it has been shown that the uncertainty provided is only weakly correlated with the actual true error. To address this issue, we investigate a simple but effective uncertainty quantification, that we call MaskVal, which compares the pose estimates with their corresponding instance segmentations by rendering and does not require any modification of the pose estimator itself. Despite its simplicity, MaskVal significantly outperforms a state-of-the-art ensemble method on both a dataset and a robotic setup. We show that by using MaskVal, the performance of a state-of-the-art 6D pose estimator is significantly improved towards a safe and reliable operation. In addition, we propose a new and specific approach to compare and evaluate uncertainty quantification methods for 6D pose estimation in the context of robotic manipulation.
Read more9/6/2024
🌀
0
Toward Reliable Human Pose Forecasting with Uncertainty
Saeed Saadatnejad, Mehrshad Mirmohammadi, Matin Daghyani, Parham Saremi, Yashar Zoroofchi Benisi, Amirhossein Alimohammadi, Zahra Tehraninasab, Taylor Mordan, Alexandre Alahi
Recently, there has been an arms race of pose forecasting methods aimed at solving the spatio-temporal task of predicting a sequence of future 3D poses of a person given a sequence of past observed ones. However, the lack of unified benchmarks and limited uncertainty analysis have hindered progress in the field. To address this, we first develop an open-source library for human pose forecasting, including multiple models, supporting several datasets, and employing standardized evaluation metrics, with the aim of promoting research and moving toward a unified and consistent evaluation. Second, we devise two types of uncertainty in the problem to increase performance and convey better trust: 1) we propose a method for modeling aleatoric uncertainty by using uncertainty priors to inject knowledge about the pattern of uncertainty. This focuses the capacity of the model in the direction of more meaningful supervision while reducing the number of learned parameters and improving stability; 2) we introduce a novel approach for quantifying the epistemic uncertainty of any model through clustering and measuring the entropy of its assignments. Our experiments demonstrate up to $25%$ improvements in forecasting at short horizons, with no loss on longer horizons on Human3.6M, AMSS, and 3DPW datasets, and better performance in uncertainty estimation. The code is available online at https://github.com/vita-epfl/UnPOSed.
Read more4/15/2024