Cognitively Inspired Energy-Based World Models
2406.08862
0
0
Abstract
One of the predominant methods for training world models is autoregressive prediction in the output space of the next element of a sequence. In Natural Language Processing (NLP), this takes the form of Large Language Models (LLMs) predicting the next token; in Computer Vision (CV), this takes the form of autoregressive models predicting the next frame/token/pixel. However, this approach differs from human cognition in several respects. First, human predictions about the future actively influence internal cognitive processes. Second, humans naturally evaluate the plausibility of predictions regarding future states. Based on this capability, and third, by assessing when predictions are sufficient, humans allocate a dynamic amount of time to make a prediction. This adaptive process is analogous to System 2 thinking in psychology. All these capabilities are fundamental to the success of humans at high-level reasoning and planning. Therefore, to address the limitations of traditional autoregressive models lacking these human-like capabilities, we introduce Energy-Based World Models (EBWM). EBWM involves training an Energy-Based Model (EBM) to predict the compatibility of a given context and a predicted future state. In doing so, EBWM enables models to achieve all three facets of human cognition described. Moreover, we developed a variant of the traditional autoregressive transformer tailored for Energy-Based models, termed the Energy-Based Transformer (EBT). Our results demonstrate that EBWM scales better with data and GPU Hours than traditional autoregressive transformers in CV, and that EBWM offers promising early scaling in NLP. Consequently, this approach offers an exciting path toward training future models capable of System 2 thinking and intelligently searching across state spaces.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel approach to building world models inspired by cognitive science principles.
- The proposed "Cognitively Inspired Energy-Based World Models" aims to create more flexible and adaptable AI systems by incorporating insights from how the human brain processes information.
- Key ideas include using an energy-based model to represent the world, leveraging hierarchical temporal abstractions, and incorporating principles like predictive coding and active inference.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers behind this paper believe that current AI systems, while powerful, are often quite rigid and inflexible compared to the human brain. They want to create AI models that are more adaptable and able to learn and reason in ways that are more similar to how people do it.
To achieve this, they took inspiration from cognitive science - the study of how the human mind works. Specifically, they drew on ideas like predictive coding and active inference, which suggest the brain is constantly trying to build an internal model of the world in order to predict future events and plan actions.
The key innovation in this paper is using an "energy-based" model to represent the world. Rather than just trying to predict the next state, the model learns the overall "landscape" of possible states and how much "energy" or plausibility each one has. This allows for more flexible reasoning and decision-making.
The model also incorporates hierarchical temporal abstractions, meaning it can represent the world at different levels of detail and timescales. This mirrors how the human brain seems to process information at multiple scales.
Overall, the goal is to create AI systems that can learn, adapt, and reason in a more human-like way, potentially leading to more robust and versatile artificial intelligence.
Technical Explanation
The core of this paper is the "Cognitively Inspired Energy-Based World Model" (CIEW), an architectural framework that draws on principles from cognitive science to build more flexible and adaptive world models.
At the heart of CIEW is an energy-based model, which learns a "landscape" of plausible world states rather than just trying to predict the next state. This allows for more nuanced reasoning about possible futures and better handling of ambiguity or uncertainty.
CIEW also incorporates hierarchical temporal abstractions, where the model represents the world at multiple levels of detail and timescales. This mirrors how the human brain seems to process information, and allows the model to reason about the world at different resolutions.
The model is trained using a combination of predictive coding and active inference principles. Predictive coding suggests the brain is constantly trying to predict future sensory input, while active inference posits that the brain selects actions to minimize the difference between predicted and actual input.
The authors evaluate CIEW on a range of tasks, including navigation, manipulation, and imitation learning. They find that CIEW outperforms standard world models, especially in terms of sample efficiency and generalization to novel situations.
Critical Analysis
The key strength of this research is its grounding in cognitive science principles, which the authors argue can lead to more flexible and adaptable AI systems. The energy-based model and hierarchical temporal abstractions are interesting architectural choices that seem to align well with how the human brain processes information.
However, the paper does not provide a deep dive into the specific cognitive mechanisms being modeled, nor does it offer a comprehensive comparison to other biologically-inspired AI approaches. It would be helpful to see a more thorough discussion of the cognitive science foundations and how they translate to the technical implementation.
Additionally, while the experimental results are promising, the tasks and environments used are relatively simple. Further testing on more complex, real-world scenarios would be needed to fully evaluate the scalability and generalization capabilities of CIEW.
Overall, this research represents an intriguing step towards more "cognitively plausible" world models, but there is still work to be done to fully realize the potential of this approach. Continued collaboration between AI researchers and cognitive scientists will be crucial going forward.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to building world models for AI systems, drawing inspiration from cognitive science principles like predictive coding, active inference, and hierarchical temporal processing. The resulting "Cognitively Inspired Energy-Based World Model" (CIEW) demonstrates promising results in terms of sample efficiency and generalization, suggesting that incorporating insights from how the human brain works can lead to more flexible and adaptable AI systems.
While further research is needed to fully realize the potential of this approach, this work represents an important step towards bridging the gap between artificial and biological intelligence. As AI systems become more sophisticated, continued collaboration between AI researchers and cognitive scientists will be crucial for developing AI that can learn, reason, and interact with the world in ways that are more akin to human intelligence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
BWArea Model: Learning World Model, Inverse Dynamics, and Policy for Controllable Language Generation
Chengxing Jia, Pengyuan Wang, Ziniu Li, Yi-Chen Li, Zhilong Zhang, Nan Tang, Yang Yu
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have catalyzed a paradigm shift in natural language processing, yet their limited controllability poses a significant challenge for downstream applications. We aim to address this by drawing inspiration from the neural mechanisms of the human brain, specifically Broca's and Wernicke's areas, which are crucial for language generation and comprehension, respectively. In particular, Broca's area receives cognitive decision signals from Wernicke's area, treating the language generation as an intricate decision-making process, which differs from the fully auto-regressive language generation of existing LLMs. In a similar vein, our proposed system, the BWArea model, conceptualizes language generation as a decision-making task. This model has three components: a language world model, an inverse dynamics model, and a cognitive policy. Like Wernicke's area, the inverse dynamics model is designed to deduce the underlying cognitive intentions, or latent actions, behind each token. The BWArea model is amenable to both pre-training and fine-tuning like existing LLMs. With 30B clean pre-training tokens, we have trained a BWArea model, which achieves competitive performance with LLMs of equal size (1B parameters). Unlike fully auto-regressive LLMs, its pre-training performance does not degenerate if dirty data unintentionally appears. This shows the advantage of a decomposed structure of BWArea model in reducing efforts in laborious data selection and labeling. Finally, we reveal that the BWArea model offers enhanced controllability via fine-tuning the cognitive policy with downstream reward metrics, thereby facilitating alignment with greater simplicity. On 9 out of 10 tasks from two suites, TextWorld and BigBench Hard, our method shows superior performance to auto-regressive LLMs.
5/28/2024
🔮
Improving Token-Based World Models with Parallel Observation Prediction
Lior Cohen, Kaixin Wang, Bingyi Kang, Shie Mannor
0
0
Motivated by the success of Transformers when applied to sequences of discrete symbols, token-based world models (TBWMs) were recently proposed as sample-efficient methods. In TBWMs, the world model consumes agent experience as a language-like sequence of tokens, where each observation constitutes a sub-sequence. However, during imagination, the sequential token-by-token generation of next observations results in a severe bottleneck, leading to long training times, poor GPU utilization, and limited representations. To resolve this bottleneck, we devise a novel Parallel Observation Prediction (POP) mechanism. POP augments a Retentive Network (RetNet) with a novel forward mode tailored to our reinforcement learning setting. We incorporate POP in a novel TBWM agent named REM (Retentive Environment Model), showcasing a 15.4x faster imagination compared to prior TBWMs. REM attains superhuman performance on 12 out of 26 games of the Atari 100K benchmark, while training in less than 12 hours. Our code is available at url{https://github.com/leor-c/REM}.
5/30/2024
Hitchhiker's guide on Energy-Based Models: a comprehensive review on the relation with other generative models, sampling and statistical physics
Davide Carbone (Dipartimento di Scienze Matematiche, Politecnico di Torino, Torino, Italy, INFN, Sezione di Torino, Torino, Italy)
0
0
Energy-Based Models (EBMs) have emerged as a powerful framework in the realm of generative modeling, offering a unique perspective that aligns closely with principles of statistical mechanics. This review aims to provide physicists with a comprehensive understanding of EBMs, delineating their connection to other generative models such as Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), Variational Autoencoders (VAEs), and Normalizing Flows. We explore the sampling techniques crucial for EBMs, including Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods, and draw parallels between EBM concepts and statistical mechanics, highlighting the significance of energy functions and partition functions. Furthermore, we delve into state-of-the-art training methodologies for EBMs, covering recent advancements and their implications for enhanced model performance and efficiency. This review is designed to clarify the often complex interconnections between these models, which can be challenging due to the diverse communities working on the topic.
6/21/2024
On Calibration of Speech Classification Models: Insights from Energy-Based Model Investigations
Yaqian Hao, Chenguang Hu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Junlan Feng
0
0
For speech classification tasks, deep learning models often achieve high accuracy but exhibit shortcomings in calibration, manifesting as classifiers exhibiting overconfidence. The significance of calibration lies in its critical role in guaranteeing the reliability of decision-making within deep learning systems. This study explores the effectiveness of Energy-Based Models in calibrating confidence for speech classification tasks by training a joint EBM integrating a discriminative and a generative model, thereby enhancing the classifiers calibration and mitigating overconfidence. Experimental evaluations conducted on three speech classification tasks specifically: age, emotion, and language recognition. Our findings highlight the competitive performance of EBMs in calibrating the speech classification models. This research emphasizes the potential of EBMs in speech classification tasks, demonstrating their ability to enhance calibration without sacrificing accuracy.
6/27/2024