Comparative Evaluation of 3D Reconstruction Methods for Object Pose Estimation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper compares different 3D reconstruction methods for estimating the pose of objects.
- The authors evaluate the performance of several 3D reconstruction techniques on a dataset of object images.
- The goal is to determine which 3D reconstruction method works best for estimating the position and orientation of objects in 3D space.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores different ways to reconstruct 3D models of objects from 2D images. The authors compare several 3D reconstruction methods and evaluate how well each one can estimate the pose, or position and orientation, of the objects in the images.
Estimating object pose is important for many applications like robotics, augmented reality, and computer vision. The researchers want to understand which 3D reconstruction technique works best for this task.
They test the 3D reconstruction methods on a dataset of object images and measure how accurately each one can predict the true 3D pose of the objects. The results provide insights into the strengths and limitations of different 3D reconstruction approaches for estimating object pose.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates the performance of several 3D reconstruction methods for estimating the 6-DoF (degree-of-freedom) pose of objects. The authors compare the accuracy of different 3D reconstruction techniques on a dataset of object images.
The 3D reconstruction methods tested include:
- Structure-from-Motion (SfM)
- Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM)
- Deep learning-based approaches
The researchers measure the pose estimation error for each reconstruction method and analyze the tradeoffs in terms of accuracy, robustness, and computational efficiency. The results provide guidance on which 3D reconstruction technique is most suitable for various object pose estimation applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of 3D reconstruction methods for object pose estimation, but it does not address some potential limitations. For example, the dataset used may not capture the full diversity of object types and imaging conditions encountered in real-world scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific failure modes or edge cases of the different reconstruction techniques. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each method in more detail could inform the development of more robust and adaptive pose estimation systems.
Further research could also explore the integration of multiple 3D reconstruction approaches, potentially achieving better overall performance by leveraging the complementary strengths of different techniques.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comparative evaluation of 3D reconstruction methods for object pose estimation. The results provide valuable insights into the tradeoffs between accuracy, robustness, and efficiency for different reconstruction approaches.
The findings can inform the design of more effective object pose estimation systems used in robotics, augmented reality, and other applications. Future work could explore ways to combine multiple 3D reconstruction techniques to further improve pose estimation capabilities.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Comparative Evaluation of 3D Reconstruction Methods for Object Pose Estimation
Varun Burde, Assia Benbihi, Pavel Burget, Torsten Sattler
Object pose estimation is essential to many industrial applications involving robotic manipulation, navigation, and augmented reality. Current generalizable object pose estimators, i.e., approaches that do not need to be trained per object, rely on accurate 3D models. Predominantly, CAD models are used, which can be hard to obtain in practice. At the same time, it is often possible to acquire images of an object. Naturally, this leads to the question whether 3D models reconstructed from images are sufficient to facilitate accurate object pose estimation. We aim to answer this question by proposing a novel benchmark for measuring the impact of 3D reconstruction quality on pose estimation accuracy. Our benchmark provides calibrated images for object reconstruction registered with the test images of the YCB-V dataset for pose evaluation under the BOP benchmark format. Detailed experiments with multiple state-of-the-art 3D reconstruction and object pose estimation approaches show that the geometry produced by modern reconstruction methods is often sufficient for accurate pose estimation. Our experiments lead to interesting observations: (1) Standard metrics for measuring 3D reconstruction quality are not necessarily indicative of pose estimation accuracy, which shows the need for dedicated benchmarks such as ours. (2) Classical, non-learning-based approaches can perform on par with modern learning-based reconstruction techniques and can even offer a better reconstruction time-pose accuracy tradeoff. (3) There is still a sizable gap between performance with reconstructed and with CAD models. To foster research on closing this gap, our benchmark is publicly available at https://github.com/VarunBurde/reconstruction_pose_benchmark}.
Read more8/16/2024
0
Deep Learning-Based Object Pose Estimation: A Comprehensive Survey
Jian Liu, Wei Sun, Hui Yang, Zhiwen Zeng, Chongpei Liu, Jin Zheng, Xingyu Liu, Hossein Rahmani, Nicu Sebe, Ajmal Mian
Object pose estimation is a fundamental computer vision problem with broad applications in augmented reality and robotics. Over the past decade, deep learning models, due to their superior accuracy and robustness, have increasingly supplanted conventional algorithms reliant on engineered point pair features. Nevertheless, several challenges persist in contemporary methods, including their dependency on labeled training data, model compactness, robustness under challenging conditions, and their ability to generalize to novel unseen objects. A recent survey discussing the progress made on different aspects of this area, outstanding challenges, and promising future directions, is missing. To fill this gap, we discuss the recent advances in deep learning-based object pose estimation, covering all three formulations of the problem, emph{i.e.}, instance-level, category-level, and unseen object pose estimation. Our survey also covers multiple input data modalities, degrees-of-freedom of output poses, object properties, and downstream tasks, providing the readers with a holistic understanding of this field. Additionally, it discusses training paradigms of different domains, inference modes, application areas, evaluation metrics, and benchmark datasets, as well as reports the performance of current state-of-the-art methods on these benchmarks, thereby facilitating the readers in selecting the most suitable method for their application. Finally, the survey identifies key challenges, reviews the prevailing trends along with their pros and cons, and identifies promising directions for future research. We also keep tracing the latest works at https://github.com/CNJianLiu/Awesome-Object-Pose-Estimation.
Read more6/3/2024
0
Markerless Multi-view 3D Human Pose Estimation: a survey
Ana Filipa Rodrigues Nogueira, H'elder P. Oliveira, Lu'is F. Teixeira
3D human pose estimation aims to reconstruct the human skeleton of all the individuals in a scene by detecting several body joints. The creation of accurate and efficient methods is required for several real-world applications including animation, human-robot interaction, surveillance systems or sports, among many others. However, several obstacles such as occlusions, random camera perspectives, or the scarcity of 3D labelled data, have been hampering the models' performance and limiting their deployment in real-world scenarios. The higher availability of cameras has led researchers to explore multi-view solutions due to the advantage of being able to exploit different perspectives to reconstruct the pose. Thus, the goal of this survey is to present an overview of the methodologies used to estimate the 3D pose in multi-view settings, understand what were the strategies found to address the various challenges and also, identify their limitations. Based on the reviewed articles, it was possible to find that no method is yet capable of solving all the challenges associated with the reconstruction of the 3D pose. Due to the existing trade-off between complexity and performance, the best method depends on the application scenario. Therefore, further research is still required to develop an approach capable of quickly inferring a highly accurate 3D pose with bearable computation cost. To this goal, techniques such as active learning, methods that learn with a low level of supervision, the incorporation of temporal consistency, view selection, estimation of depth information and multi-modal approaches might be interesting strategies to keep in mind when developing a new methodology to solve this task.
Read more7/8/2024
0
Extending 6D Object Pose Estimators for Stereo Vision
Thomas Pollabauer, Jan Emrich, Volker Knauthe, Arjan Kuijper
Estimating the 6D pose of objects accurately, quickly, and robustly remains a difficult task. However, recent methods for directly regressing poses from RGB images using dense features have achieved state-of-the-art results. Stereo vision, which provides an additional perspective on the object, can help reduce pose ambiguity and occlusion. Moreover, stereo can directly infer the distance of an object, while mono-vision requires internalized knowledge of the object's size. To extend the state-of-the-art in 6D object pose estimation to stereo, we created a BOP compatible stereo version of the YCB-V dataset. Our method outperforms state-of-the-art 6D pose estimation algorithms by utilizing stereo vision and can easily be adopted for other dense feature-based algorithms.
Read more9/11/2024