Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs: A survey

2404.03499

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/5/2024 by Simon Schramm, Christoph Wehner, Ute Schmid
Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs: A survey

Abstract

Artificial Intelligence applications gradually move outside the safe walls of research labs and invade our daily lives. This is also true for Machine Learning methods on Knowledge Graphs, which has led to a steady increase in their application since the beginning of the 21st century. However, in many applications, users require an explanation of the Artificial Intelligences decision. This led to increased demand for Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence. Knowledge Graphs epitomize fertile soil for Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence, due to their ability to display connected data, i.e. knowledge, in a human- as well as machine-readable way. This survey gives a short history to Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs. Furthermore, we contribute by arguing that the concept Explainable Artificial Intelligence is overloaded and overlapping with Interpretable Machine Learning. By introducing the parent concept Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence, we provide a clear-cut distinction of both concepts while accounting for their similarities. Thus, we provide in this survey a case for Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs consisting of Interpretable Machine Learning on Knowledge Graphs and Explainable Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs. This leads to the introduction of a novel taxonomy for Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs. In addition, a comprehensive overview of the research on Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs is presented and put into the context of the taxonomy. Finally, research gaps in the field of Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence on Knowledge Graphs are identified for future research.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper provides a comprehensive survey on the topic of Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence (CAI) on Knowledge Graphs (KGs).
  • It examines the necessity and importance of developing CAI systems that can effectively leverage the wealth of information stored in KGs.
  • The paper covers the history, key concepts, and state-of-the-art approaches in the field of CAI on KGs.

Plain English Explanation

Knowledge graphs are large databases that store information about the world in a structured way, like a map of connected facts and relationships. Comprehensible AI systems are designed to work with these knowledge graphs in a way that is easy for humans to understand.

The paper explains why it's important to have AI systems that can make sense of knowledge graphs in a transparent and interpretable manner. As AI becomes more powerful and ubiquitous, it's crucial that we can understand how these systems are using and reasoning about the information they have access to. This is especially important for critical applications like healthcare, finance, and policy-making, where AI decisions can have significant real-world impacts.

The paper traces the historical development of CAI systems, looking at how researchers have tried to make AI more "comprehensible" by drawing on techniques like explainable AI, knowledge representation, and reasoning. It also covers the latest advances in areas like natural language processing and recommender systems that are helping to bridge the gap between AI and human understanding.

Technical Explanation

The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the field of Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence (CAI) on Knowledge Graphs (KGs). It begins by discussing the growing need for AI systems that can effectively leverage the wealth of information stored in KGs in a transparent and interpretable manner.

The authors trace the historical development of CAI, covering key concepts and approaches from the fields of explainable AI, knowledge representation, and reasoning. They examine how researchers have tried to make AI systems more comprehensible by improving their ability to explain their decision-making processes and interact with humans in more natural ways.

The paper then delves into the state-of-the-art in CAI on KGs, highlighting recent advances in areas like natural language processing and recommender systems that are helping to bridge the gap between AI and human understanding. It also covers emerging techniques for constructing and reasoning about knowledge graphs, and discusses how these approaches can be leveraged to create more comprehensible AI systems.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and well-researched overview of the field of CAI on KGs. The authors clearly articulate the growing importance of this area, given the increasing prominence of AI systems in critical domains like healthcare, finance, and policy-making.

However, the paper also acknowledges the significant challenges involved in developing truly comprehensible AI systems. As the authors note, even the most advanced techniques for explainable AI still fall short in terms of capturing the full complexity of AI decision-making processes. There are also open questions around the extent to which humans can truly understand the inner workings of AI systems, especially as they become more sophisticated.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential ethical and societal implications of CAI on KGs. As these systems become more widely deployed, there will be important questions to consider around issues like data privacy, algorithmic bias, and the potential for AI to influence or manipulate human decision-making.

Overall, the paper provides a comprehensive and valuable overview of the field, but future research in this area would benefit from a more critical examination of the limitations and potential risks associated with CAI on KGs.

Conclusion

The paper presents a thorough survey of the field of Comprehensible Artificial Intelligence (CAI) on Knowledge Graphs (KGs), highlighting the growing importance of this area as AI systems become increasingly prominent in critical domains.

The authors trace the historical development of CAI, cover the key concepts and state-of-the-art approaches, and discuss the significant challenges involved in creating AI systems that can effectively leverage the wealth of information stored in KGs in a transparent and interpretable manner.

While the paper provides a valuable overview of the field, it also acknowledges the limitations of current explainable AI techniques and raises important questions around the ethical and societal implications of CAI on KGs. As this field continues to evolve, further research will be needed to address these complex issues and ensure that the development of CAI systems aligns with the needs and values of the broader society.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Knowledge graphs for empirical concept retrieval

Knowledge graphs for empirical concept retrieval

Lenka Tv{e}tkov'a, Teresa Karen Scheidt, Maria Mandrup Fogh, Ellen Marie Gaunby J{o}rgensen, Finn {AA}rup Nielsen, Lars Kai Hansen

YC

0

Reddit

0

Concept-based explainable AI is promising as a tool to improve the understanding of complex models at the premises of a given user, viz. as a tool for personalized explainability. An important class of concept-based explainability methods is constructed with empirically defined concepts, indirectly defined through a set of positive and negative examples, as in the TCAV approach (Kim et al., 2018). While it is appealing to the user to avoid formal definitions of concepts and their operationalization, it can be challenging to establish relevant concept datasets. Here, we address this challenge using general knowledge graphs (such as, e.g., Wikidata or WordNet) for comprehensive concept definition and present a workflow for user-driven data collection in both text and image domains. The concepts derived from knowledge graphs are defined interactively, providing an opportunity for personalization and ensuring that the concepts reflect the user's intentions. We test the retrieved concept datasets on two concept-based explainability methods, namely concept activation vectors (CAVs) and concept activation regions (CARs) (Crabbe and van der Schaar, 2022). We show that CAVs and CARs based on these empirical concept datasets provide robust and accurate explanations. Importantly, we also find good alignment between the models' representations of concepts and the structure of knowledge graphs, i.e., human representations. This supports our conclusion that knowledge graph-based concepts are relevant for XAI.

Read more

4/11/2024

🛠️

Exploring knowledge graph-based neural-symbolic system from application perspective

Shenzhe Zhu, Shengxiang Sun

YC

0

Reddit

0

Advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and deep neural networks have driven significant progress in vision and text processing. However, achieving human-like reasoning and interpretability in AI systems remains a substantial challenge. The Neural-Symbolic paradigm, which integrates neural networks with symbolic systems, presents a promising pathway toward more interpretable AI. Within this paradigm, Knowledge Graphs (KG) are crucial, offering a structured and dynamic method for representing knowledge through interconnected entities and relationships, typically as triples (subject, predicate, object). This paper explores recent advancements in neural-symbolic integration based on KG, examining how it supports integration in three categories: enhancing the reasoning and interpretability of neural networks with symbolic knowledge (Symbol for Neural), refining the completeness and accuracy of symbolic systems via neural network methodologies (Neural for Symbol), and facilitating their combined application in Hybrid Neural-Symbolic Integration. It highlights current trends and proposes future research directions in Neural-Symbolic AI.

Read more

5/31/2024

🤖

Explainable Generative AI (GenXAI): A Survey, Conceptualization, and Research Agenda

Johannes Schneider

YC

0

Reddit

0

Generative AI (GenAI) marked a shift from AI being able to recognize to AI being able to generate solutions for a wide variety of tasks. As the generated solutions and applications become increasingly more complex and multi-faceted, novel needs, objectives, and possibilities have emerged for explainability (XAI). In this work, we elaborate on why XAI has gained importance with the rise of GenAI and its challenges for explainability research. We also unveil novel and emerging desiderata that explanations should fulfill, covering aspects such as verifiability, interactivity, security, and cost. To this end, we focus on surveying existing works. Furthermore, we provide a taxonomy of relevant dimensions that allows us to better characterize existing XAI mechanisms and methods for GenAI. We discuss different avenues to ensure XAI, from training data to prompting. Our paper offers a short but concise technical background of GenAI for non-technical readers, focusing on text and images to better understand novel or adapted XAI techniques for GenAI. However, due to the vast array of works on GenAI, we decided to forego detailed aspects of XAI related to evaluation and usage of explanations. As such, the manuscript interests both technically oriented people and other disciplines, such as social scientists and information systems researchers. Our research roadmap provides more than ten directions for future investigation.

Read more

4/16/2024

🤔

From Latent to Lucid: Transforming Knowledge Graph Embeddings into Interpretable Structures

Christoph Wehner, Chrysa Iliopoulou, Tarek R. Besold

YC

0

Reddit

0

This paper introduces a post-hoc explainable AI method tailored for Knowledge Graph Embedding models. These models are essential to Knowledge Graph Completion yet criticized for their opaque, black-box nature. Despite their significant success in capturing the semantics of knowledge graphs through high-dimensional latent representations, their inherent complexity poses substantial challenges to explainability. Unlike existing methods, our approach directly decodes the latent representations encoded by Knowledge Graph Embedding models, leveraging the principle that similar embeddings reflect similar behaviors within the Knowledge Graph. By identifying distinct structures within the subgraph neighborhoods of similarly embedded entities, our method identifies the statistical regularities on which the models rely and translates these insights into human-understandable symbolic rules and facts. This bridges the gap between the abstract representations of Knowledge Graph Embedding models and their predictive outputs, offering clear, interpretable insights. Key contributions include a novel post-hoc explainable AI method for Knowledge Graph Embedding models that provides immediate, faithful explanations without retraining, facilitating real-time application even on large-scale knowledge graphs. The method's flexibility enables the generation of rule-based, instance-based, and analogy-based explanations, meeting diverse user needs. Extensive evaluations show our approach's effectiveness in delivering faithful and well-localized explanations, enhancing the transparency and trustworthiness of Knowledge Graph Embedding models.

Read more

6/5/2024