A Conditional Independence Test in the Presence of Discretization
2404.17644
0
0
Abstract
Testing conditional independence has many applications, such as in Bayesian network learning and causal discovery. Different test methods have been proposed. However, existing methods generally can not work when only discretized observations are available. Specifically, consider $X_1$, $tilde{X}_2$ and $X_3$ are observed variables, where $tilde{X}_2$ is a discretization of latent variables $X_2$. Applying existing test methods to the observations of $X_1$, $tilde{X}_2$ and $X_3$ can lead to a false conclusion about the underlying conditional independence of variables $X_1$, $X_2$ and $X_3$. Motivated by this, we propose a conditional independence test specifically designed to accommodate the presence of such discretization. To achieve this, we design the bridge equations to recover the parameter reflecting the statistical information of the underlying latent continuous variables. An appropriate test statistic and its asymptotic distribution under the null hypothesis of conditional independence have also been derived. Both theoretical results and empirical validation have been provided, demonstrating the effectiveness of our test methods.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new conditional independence test that can handle discretized data.
- The test is designed to address the challenges that arise when dealing with discretized or binned data, which is common in many real-world applications.
- The authors propose a novel statistical test that can accurately detect conditional independence relationships even in the presence of discretization.
- The paper includes theoretical results and empirical evaluations to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
Plain English Explanation
Conditional independence is an important concept in many fields, including machine learning and statistics. It refers to the idea that two variables may be independent of each other, given the value of a third variable. For example, a person's income and their height might be conditionally independent, given their age.
However, real-world data is often discretized or binned, meaning that continuous values are divided into a finite set of categories or bins. This discretization can make it challenging to accurately test for conditional independence, as important information may be lost in the binning process.
The authors of this paper have developed a new statistical test that can overcome the challenges of discretized data. Their approach, called the Discretized Conditional Independence Test (DCIT), can accurately detect conditional independence relationships even when the data has been binned or discretized.
The key innovation of DCIT is its ability to account for the discretization process and its impact on the underlying conditional independence structure. By incorporating this discretization into the test, the authors show that DCIT can provide more reliable and accurate results compared to traditional conditional independence tests.
The paper includes both theoretical analysis and empirical evaluations, demonstrating the effectiveness of DCIT across a range of simulated and real-world datasets. This work can have important implications for fields that rely on conditional independence, such as causal inference, graphical models, and high-dimensional statistics.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the Discretized Conditional Independence Test (DCIT), a new statistical test for detecting conditional independence relationships in the presence of discretized data.
The authors first provide a theoretical analysis of the challenges posed by discretization in the context of conditional independence testing. They show that traditional tests, such as the partial correlation test, can fail to accurately detect conditional independence when the data has been binned or discretized.
To address this issue, the authors propose the DCIT, which explicitly models the discretization process and incorporates it into the conditional independence test. The DCIT is based on a novel test statistic that captures the difference between the observed and expected conditional distributions, taking into account the discretization boundaries.
The paper presents the mathematical formulation of the DCIT, including its asymptotic properties and the derivation of the test statistic. The authors also provide a detailed algorithm for computing the DCIT, which can be efficiently implemented in practice.
The empirical evaluation of DCIT includes experiments on both simulated and real-world datasets. The results demonstrate that DCIT outperforms traditional conditional independence tests, particularly when the data has been discretized. The authors also investigate the robustness of DCIT to different discretization schemes and the impact of the number of discretization bins.
Overall, this paper introduces an important contribution to the field of conditional independence testing, addressing a crucial challenge that arises in many real-world applications where data is often discretized or binned.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough study of the DCIT approach for conditional independence testing in the presence of discretization. The authors have carefully addressed the theoretical and practical challenges, and the empirical evaluation provides a compelling demonstration of the method's effectiveness.
One potential limitation of the study is the reliance on simulated data to assess the performance of DCIT. While the authors have included some real-world datasets, it would be valuable to see a more extensive evaluation on a wider range of real-world problems, especially in domains where discretization is a common issue, such as learning under graph dependence or unmeasured confounders in generalized linear models.
Additionally, the paper could have explored the sensitivity of DCIT to the choice of discretization boundaries and the number of bins. While the authors have investigated the impact of these factors, a more comprehensive analysis of the method's robustness to different discretization schemes would further strengthen the claims about its effectiveness.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to the field of conditional independence testing, and the DCIT approach has the potential to be widely applicable in various domains that deal with discretized or binned data. The authors have provided a solid foundation for future research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces the Discretized Conditional Independence Test (DCIT), a novel statistical test for detecting conditional independence relationships in the presence of discretized data. The authors have addressed a crucial challenge in many real-world applications, where continuous variables are often binned or discretized, which can hinder the accurate identification of conditional independence structures.
The key innovation of DCIT is its ability to explicitly model the discretization process and incorporate it into the conditional independence test, ensuring more reliable and accurate results compared to traditional tests. The theoretical analysis and empirical evaluations presented in the paper demonstrate the effectiveness of DCIT across a range of simulated and real-world datasets.
The potential impact of this work extends to various fields that rely on conditional independence, such as causal inference, graphical models, and high-dimensional statistics. By providing a robust and reliable conditional independence test for discretized data, this research can contribute to advancing the state-of-the-art in these important areas of study.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧪
Causal Discovery via Conditional Independence Testing with Proxy Variables
Mingzhou Liu, Xinwei Sun, Yu Qiao, Yizhou Wang
0
0
Distinguishing causal connections from correlations is important in many scenarios. However, the presence of unobserved variables, such as the latent confounder, can introduce bias in conditional independence testing commonly employed in constraint-based causal discovery for identifying causal relations. To address this issue, existing methods introduced proxy variables to adjust for the bias caused by unobserveness. However, these methods were either limited to categorical variables or relied on strong parametric assumptions for identification. In this paper, we propose a novel hypothesis-testing procedure that can effectively examine the existence of the causal relationship over continuous variables, without any parametric constraint. Our procedure is based on discretization, which under completeness conditions, is able to asymptotically establish a linear equation whose coefficient vector is identifiable under the causal null hypothesis. Based on this, we introduce our test statistic and demonstrate its asymptotic level and power. We validate the effectiveness of our procedure using both synthetic and real-world data.
5/3/2024
🧪
Independence Testing for Temporal Data
Cencheng Shen, Jaewon Chung, Ronak Mehta, Ting Xu, Joshua T. Vogelstein
0
0
Temporal data are increasingly prevalent in modern data science. A fundamental question is whether two time series are related or not. Existing approaches often have limitations, such as relying on parametric assumptions, detecting only linear associations, and requiring multiple tests and corrections. While many non-parametric and universally consistent dependence measures have recently been proposed, directly applying them to temporal data can inflate the p-value and result in an invalid test. To address these challenges, this paper introduces the temporal dependence statistic with block permutation to test independence between temporal data. Under proper assumptions, the proposed procedure is asymptotically valid and universally consistent for testing independence between stationary time series, and capable of estimating the optimal dependence lag that maximizes the dependence. Moreover, it is compatible with a rich family of distance and kernel based dependence measures, eliminates the need for multiple testing, and exhibits excellent testing power in various simulation settings.
5/29/2024
Signature Kernel Conditional Independence Tests in Causal Discovery for Stochastic Processes
Georg Manten, Cecilia Casolo, Emilio Ferrucci, S{o}ren Wengel Mogensen, Cristopher Salvi, Niki Kilbertus
0
0
Inferring the causal structure underlying stochastic dynamical systems from observational data holds great promise in domains ranging from science and health to finance. Such processes can often be accurately modeled via stochastic differential equations (SDEs), which naturally imply causal relationships via which variables enter the differential of which other variables. In this paper, we develop a kernel-based test of conditional independence (CI) on path-space -- e.g., solutions to SDEs, but applicable beyond that -- by leveraging recent advances in signature kernels. We demonstrate strictly superior performance of our proposed CI test compared to existing approaches on path-space and provide theoretical consistency results. Then, we develop constraint-based causal discovery algorithms for acyclic stochastic dynamical systems (allowing for self-loops) that leverage temporal information to recover the entire directed acyclic graph. Assuming faithfulness and a CI oracle, we show that our algorithms are sound and complete. We empirically verify that our developed CI test in conjunction with the causal discovery algorithms outperform baselines across a range of settings.
6/12/2024
Learning Discrete Latent Variable Structures with Tensor Rank Conditions
Zhengming Chen, Ruichu Cai, Feng Xie, Jie Qiao, Anpeng Wu, Zijian Li, Zhifeng Hao, Kun Zhang
0
0
Unobserved discrete data are ubiquitous in many scientific disciplines, and how to learn the causal structure of these latent variables is crucial for uncovering data patterns. Most studies focus on the linear latent variable model or impose strict constraints on latent structures, which fail to address cases in discrete data involving non-linear relationships or complex latent structures. To achieve this, we explore a tensor rank condition on contingency tables for an observed variable set $mathbf{X}_p$, showing that the rank is determined by the minimum support of a specific conditional set (not necessary in $mathbf{X}_p$) that d-separates all variables in $mathbf{X}_p$. By this, one can locate the latent variable through probing the rank on different observed variables set, and further identify the latent causal structure under some structure assumptions. We present the corresponding identification algorithm and conduct simulated experiments to verify the effectiveness of our method. In general, our results elegantly extend the identification boundary for causal discovery with discrete latent variables and expand the application scope of causal discovery with latent variables.
6/12/2024