Independence Testing for Temporal Data
0
๐งช
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Examines how to determine if two time series are related
- Existing methods have limitations like relying on assumptions or only detecting linear relationships
- Proposes a new approach using a temporal dependence statistic and block permutation to test for independence in time series data
Plain English Explanation
Temporal data, or data that changes over time, is becoming increasingly common in the field of data science. A key question researchers often try to answer is whether two sets of temporal data, known as time series, are related to each other in some way.
The existing methods for testing the relationship between time series often have limitations. They may rely on making certain assumptions about the data, only be able to detect linear relationships, or require running multiple statistical tests and corrections.
To address these challenges, this paper introduces a new approach that uses a temporal dependence statistic and block permutation to test whether two time series are independent. Under the right conditions, this proposed method is shown to be valid and able to consistently detect relationships, even nonlinear ones. It can also identify the optimal time lag where the two time series exhibit the strongest relationship.
Importantly, the method works with a variety of dependence measures, avoiding the need for multiple separate tests. The simulations demonstrate that it has excellent statistical power to detect dependencies in different scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new approach for testing the independence of two time series. It uses a temporal dependence statistic that can capture both linear and nonlinear relationships. To account for the serial correlation inherent in time series data, the method employs a block permutation procedure.
Under suitable assumptions about the stationarity of the time series, the proposed test is shown to be asymptotically valid and universally consistent for detecting independence. This means the test will correctly identify the true relationship (or lack thereof) between the time series as the sample size grows large.
A key advantage is that the method is compatible with a wide range of distance-based and kernel-based dependence measures. This eliminates the need to run multiple statistical tests and correct for multiple comparisons.
The paper demonstrates the excellent performance of the proposed approach through extensive simulations. It is shown to have high statistical power to detect dependencies, even in complex nonlinear settings. The ability to estimate the optimal time lag where the dependence is maximized is also highlighted as a useful feature.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling solution to the problem of testing independence between time series data. By using a temporal dependence statistic and block permutation, the method addresses key limitations of existing approaches.
One potential caveat is the reliance on the assumption of stationarity in the time series. Real-world data may not always satisfy this assumption, and further research could explore relaxing this requirement or developing adaptive methods.
Additionally, while the simulations demonstrate strong performance, it would be valuable to see the method applied to real-world datasets to understand its practical implications and any potential challenges that may arise.
Finally, the paper does not delve into the computational complexity of the proposed approach. As the size of time series data continues to grow, the efficiency of the testing procedure may become an important consideration.
Overall, this research represents a notable contribution to the field of time series analysis, providing a robust and versatile tool for researchers and practitioners to investigate dependencies in temporal data.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new method for testing the independence of two time series. By using a temporal dependence statistic and block permutation, the approach addresses key limitations of existing techniques, such as reliance on parametric assumptions and inability to detect nonlinear relationships.
The proposed procedure is shown to be asymptotically valid and universally consistent, performing well in a variety of simulation settings. It can also estimate the optimal time lag where the dependence between the time series is maximized.
This research advances the field of time series analysis, providing a flexible and powerful tool for researchers and practitioners to better understand the relationships within their temporal data. As the prevalence of such data continues to grow, methods like the one presented in this paper will become increasingly valuable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
๐งช
0
Independence Testing for Temporal Data
Cencheng Shen, Jaewon Chung, Ronak Mehta, Ting Xu, Joshua T. Vogelstein
Temporal data are increasingly prevalent in modern data science. A fundamental question is whether two time series are related or not. Existing approaches often have limitations, such as relying on parametric assumptions, detecting only linear associations, and requiring multiple tests and corrections. While many non-parametric and universally consistent dependence measures have recently been proposed, directly applying them to temporal data can inflate the p-value and result in an invalid test. To address these challenges, this paper introduces the temporal dependence statistic with block permutation to test independence between temporal data. Under proper assumptions, the proposed procedure is asymptotically valid and universally consistent for testing independence between stationary time series, and capable of estimating the optimal dependence lag that maximizes the dependence. Moreover, it is compatible with a rich family of distance and kernel based dependence measures, eliminates the need for multiple testing, and exhibits excellent testing power in various simulation settings.
Read more5/29/2024
โ
0
Universally Consistent K-Sample Tests via Dependence Measures
Sambit Panda, Cencheng Shen, Ronan Perry, Jelle Zorn, Antoine Lutz, Carey E. Priebe, Joshua T. Vogelstein
The K-sample testing problem involves determining whether K groups of data points are each drawn from the same distribution. Analysis of variance is arguably the most classical method to test mean differences, along with several recent methods to test distributional differences. In this paper, we demonstrate the existence of a transformation that allows K-sample testing to be carried out using any dependence measure. Consequently, universally consistent K-sample testing can be achieved using a universally consistent dependence measure, such as distance correlation and the Hilbert-Schmidt independence criterion. This enables a wide range of dependence measures to be easily applied to K-sample testing.
Read more9/17/2024
0
A Conditional Independence Test in the Presence of Discretization
Boyang Sun, Yu Yao, Huangyuan Hao, Yumou Qiu, Kun Zhang
Testing conditional independence has many applications, such as in Bayesian network learning and causal discovery. Different test methods have been proposed. However, existing methods generally can not work when only discretized observations are available. Specifically, consider $X_1$, $tilde{X}_2$ and $X_3$ are observed variables, where $tilde{X}_2$ is a discretization of latent variables $X_2$. Applying existing test methods to the observations of $X_1$, $tilde{X}_2$ and $X_3$ can lead to a false conclusion about the underlying conditional independence of variables $X_1$, $X_2$ and $X_3$. Motivated by this, we propose a conditional independence test specifically designed to accommodate the presence of such discretization. To achieve this, we design the bridge equations to recover the parameter reflecting the statistical information of the underlying latent continuous variables. An appropriate test statistic and its asymptotic distribution under the null hypothesis of conditional independence have also been derived. Both theoretical results and empirical validation have been provided, demonstrating the effectiveness of our test methods.
Read more5/6/2024
๐ฎ
0
Temporally Disentangled Representation Learning under Unknown Nonstationarity
Xiangchen Song, Weiran Yao, Yewen Fan, Xinshuai Dong, Guangyi Chen, Juan Carlos Niebles, Eric Xing, Kun Zhang
In unsupervised causal representation learning for sequential data with time-delayed latent causal influences, strong identifiability results for the disentanglement of causally-related latent variables have been established in stationary settings by leveraging temporal structure. However, in nonstationary setting, existing work only partially addressed the problem by either utilizing observed auxiliary variables (e.g., class labels and/or domain indexes) as side information or assuming simplified latent causal dynamics. Both constrain the method to a limited range of scenarios. In this study, we further explored the Markov Assumption under time-delayed causally related process in nonstationary setting and showed that under mild conditions, the independent latent components can be recovered from their nonlinear mixture up to a permutation and a component-wise transformation, without the observation of auxiliary variables. We then introduce NCTRL, a principled estimation framework, to reconstruct time-delayed latent causal variables and identify their relations from measured sequential data only. Empirical evaluations demonstrated the reliable identification of time-delayed latent causal influences, with our methodology substantially outperforming existing baselines that fail to exploit the nonstationarity adequately and then, consequently, cannot distinguish distribution shifts.
Read more8/2/2024