Causal Discovery via Conditional Independence Testing with Proxy Variables

Overview

• Identifying causal connections is crucial in many scenarios, but the presence of unobserved variables can introduce bias in common causal discovery methods.
• Existing methods have attempted to address this issue using proxy variables, but these were limited to categorical variables or relied on strong parametric assumptions.
• This paper proposes a novel hypothesis-testing procedure that can effectively examine the existence of causal relationships over continuous variables without any parametric constraint.

Plain English Explanation

Understanding the difference between correlation and causation is important in many situations. However, when there are factors that we can't observe, like hidden underlying variables, this can skew the results of common methods used to identify causal relationships.

Some existing approaches have tried to address this by using proxy variables to adjust for the bias caused by these unobserved factors. But these methods were either limited to working with categorical data or required making strong assumptions about the statistical models involved.

In this paper, the researchers present a new hypothesis-testing approach that can determine whether a causal relationship exists, even for continuous variables, without needing to make any specific assumptions about the underlying statistics. Their method is based on dividing the data into discrete categories, which under certain conditions, allows them to set up a linear equation where the coefficients are identifiable under the assumption of no causal relationship.

Using this, they develop a statistical test that can effectively detect the presence or absence of a causal link. The researchers show that their procedure works well through tests on both simulated and real-world data.

Technical Explanation

The paper addresses the challenge of distinguishing causal connections from mere correlations in the presence of unobserved latent confounding variables. Constraint-based causal discovery methods that rely on conditional independence testing can suffer from bias introduced by such latent confounders.

To mitigate this issue, prior work has proposed using proxy variables to adjust for the unobserved variables. However, these methods were limited to categorical variables or required strong parametric assumptions for identification.

The novel contribution of this paper is a hypothesis-testing procedure that can effectively examine the existence of causal relationships over continuous variables without any parametric constraints. The key idea is to leverage discretization, which under certain completeness conditions, can asymptotically establish a linear equation with identifiable coefficients under the causal null hypothesis.

Building on this, the authors introduce a test statistic and prove its desirable asymptotic properties in terms of level and power. They validate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on both synthetic and real-world data.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling solution to the challenge of causal discovery in the presence of latent confounders. By avoiding parametric assumptions, the proposed discretization-based method is more widely applicable than previous approaches that relied on strong modeling constraints.

However, the authors acknowledge that the completeness conditions required for their asymptotic results may be difficult to verify in practice. Additionally, the discretization process itself could introduce some information loss, potentially limiting the method's sensitivity in certain scenarios.

It would also be valuable to explore the performance of this approach compared to other causal discovery techniques, such as those leveraging causal representation learning or alternative proxy variable formulations. Further investigation into the robustness of the method to violations of the underlying assumptions would also help establish its practical applicability.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel hypothesis-testing procedure that can effectively identify causal relationships over continuous variables, even in the presence of unobserved confounding factors. By avoiding parametric constraints and using a discretization-based approach, the method offers a more flexible solution compared to previous work.

The validation on both synthetic and real-world data demonstrates the potential of this technique to advance causal discovery in a wide range of applications. While the approach has some theoretical limitations, it represents an important step forward in addressing a critical challenge in the field of causal inference.