Cross-lingual Argument Mining in the Medical Domain

Overview

• Artificial Intelligence (AI) is playing an increasingly important role in the medical domain, as clinicians rely on massive amounts of unstructured textual data to make decisions.
• Argument Mining (AM) can help structure this textual data by identifying the argumentative components and classifying the relationships between them.
• However, most AM research has focused on the English language, leaving other languages like Spanish understudied.
• This paper investigates strategies to perform AM on medical texts in Spanish, where no annotated data is available.

Plain English Explanation

The medical field is using more and more AI technology as doctors have to deal with huge amounts of unstructured text data when making decisions. Argument Mining (AM) is a way to organize this textual data by identifying the key arguments and how they are connected.

But most of the work on AM has only looked at the English language. This paper examines different approaches to doing AM on medical texts in Spanish, since there isn't any labeled Spanish data available to train on.

The researchers found that automatically translating English data and using it to label Spanish data (called "data-transfer") works well to generate Spanish annotations without needing expensive manual labeling. Surprisingly, this data-transfer approach outperformed using multilingual language models (called "model-transfer"), which went against previous findings for other text tasks.

The automatically generated Spanish data can also be used to improve the original English AM system, providing a way to easily boost performance on the English side as well. Overall, this paper demonstrates an effective way to adapt Argument Mining to a new language like Spanish without starting from scratch.

Technical Explanation

The paper explores different strategies for performing Argument Mining (AM) on medical texts in Spanish, a language that lacks annotated data for this task. The key approaches investigated are:

1. Data-Transfer: Automatically translating English AM data to Spanish and projecting the annotations. This creates Spanish data without manual labeling.

2. Model-Transfer: Leveraging the cross-lingual transfer capabilities of multilingual pre-trained language models to perform AM in Spanish.

Contrary to previous findings for other sequence labeling tasks, the experiments showed that the data-transfer approach outperformed the model-transfer methods. The automatically generated Spanish data was also used to improve results on the original English AM task, providing a form of data augmentation.

The paper makes several technical contributions:

• It demonstrates the effectiveness of data-transfer for generating annotated data in a low-resource language like Spanish.
• It shows that data-transfer can outperform model-transfer approaches, challenging previous conclusions about the superiority of cross-lingual transfer learning.
• It provides a fully automated data augmentation strategy by using the generated Spanish data to improve English AM performance.

The technical details include the datasets used, the specific AM architectures, and the quantitative results comparing the different methods. The paper provides a strong empirical foundation for adapting AM to new languages through data-centric approaches.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a thorough and well-designed study on adapting Argument Mining to the Spanish language. The key strengths are the rigorous experimental setup, the surprising finding about data-transfer outperforming model-transfer, and the demonstration of using the generated Spanish data to improve the original English system.

However, the paper also acknowledges some limitations:

• The study is focused only on the medical domain, so the findings may not generalize to other genres of Spanish text.
• The automatically translated and projected annotations may contain errors, which could impact the performance of the resulting Spanish AM system.
• The paper does not explore other data augmentation techniques beyond using the generated Spanish data, such as using large language models for data de-formalization.

Additionally, some areas for further research include:

• Investigating the robustness of the data-transfer approach by evaluating on a wider range of target languages and domains.
• Exploring ways to further improve the quality of the automatically generated annotations, such as by leveraging multilingual benchmarking of large language models or comprehensive studies of language models for clinical/biomedical text.
• Comparing the proposed data augmentation strategy to other techniques for enhancing neural models with external knowledge.

Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of Argument Mining by demonstrating an effective approach for adapting the task to a new language, with potential implications for other low-resource natural language processing applications.

Conclusion

This paper investigates strategies for performing Argument Mining (AM) on medical texts in Spanish, a language that lacks annotated data for this task. The key findings are:

• Automatically translating English AM data to Spanish and projecting the annotations (data-transfer) is an effective way to generate Spanish AM data without manual labeling.
• Surprisingly, the data-transfer approach outperformed methods based on the cross-lingual transfer capabilities of multilingual language models (model-transfer).
• The automatically generated Spanish data can also be used to improve results on the original English AM task, providing a fully automated data augmentation strategy.

These findings challenge previous conclusions about the superiority of model-transfer for sequence labeling tasks and demonstrate the power of data-centric approaches for adapting natural language processing technologies to new languages and domains. The paper provides a strong foundation for further research on Argument Mining and other low-resource language applications.