CrossKD: Cross-Head Knowledge Distillation for Object Detection
2306.11369
0
0
Abstract
Knowledge Distillation (KD) has been validated as an effective model compression technique for learning compact object detectors. Existing state-of-the-art KD methods for object detection are mostly based on feature imitation. In this paper, we present a general and effective prediction mimicking distillation scheme, called CrossKD, which delivers the intermediate features of the student's detection head to the teacher's detection head. The resulting cross-head predictions are then forced to mimic the teacher's predictions. This manner relieves the student's head from receiving contradictory supervision signals from the annotations and the teacher's predictions, greatly improving the student's detection performance. Moreover, as mimicking the teacher's predictions is the target of KD, CrossKD offers more task-oriented information in contrast with feature imitation. On MS COCO, with only prediction mimicking losses applied, our CrossKD boosts the average precision of GFL ResNet-50 with 1x training schedule from 40.2 to 43.7, outperforming all existing KD methods. In addition, our method also works well when distilling detectors with heterogeneous backbones. Code is available at https://github.com/jbwang1997/CrossKD.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces CrossKD, a novel approach to knowledge distillation for dense object detection tasks.
- CrossKD leverages cross-head knowledge distillation to effectively transfer knowledge from a large, high-performance teacher model to a smaller student model.
- The method aims to enhance the performance of the student model without significant accuracy degradation compared to the teacher model.
Plain English Explanation
Knowledge distillation is a technique used in machine learning to transfer the knowledge from a large, complex model (the "teacher") to a smaller, more efficient model (the "student"). The goal is to create a student model that can perform almost as well as the teacher, but with faster inference speed and lower memory requirements.
In the context of dense object detection, the task-integration-distillation-object-detectors model is a common approach, where the student model is trained to mimic the output of the teacher model. However, this can lead to a significant performance drop compared to the teacher.
The authors of this paper propose a new method called CrossKD, which uses "cross-head" knowledge distillation. Instead of just mimicking the final output of the teacher model, CrossKD also transfers knowledge from the intermediate layers of the teacher to the student. This helps the student model learn more comprehensive and robust features, leading to better performance compared to traditional knowledge distillation approaches like robust-feature-knowledge-distillation-enhanced-performance-lightweight.
The key idea behind CrossKD is to align the features learned by the student model with the features learned by the teacher model, not just the final output. This is achieved by introducing additional loss terms that encourage the student to mimic the intermediate feature representations of the teacher.
By effectively transferring knowledge from the teacher to the student, CrossKD can produce a smaller, faster model that still maintains high accuracy, making it a promising approach for deploying object detection models on resource-constrained devices.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose the CrossKD method, which extends traditional knowledge distillation techniques like mtkd-multi-teacher-knowledge-distillation-image-super and improve-knowledge-distillation-via-label-revision-data to the domain of dense object detection.
The key innovation of CrossKD is the introduction of a cross-head knowledge distillation loss, which aligns the feature representations learned by the student model with the feature representations learned by the teacher model at multiple levels of the detection pipeline. Specifically, the authors introduce three cross-head distillation loss terms:
- Classification Head Distillation: This term aligns the classification outputs of the student and teacher models.
- Regression Head Distillation: This term aligns the bounding box regression outputs of the student and teacher models.
- Feature Distillation: This term aligns the intermediate feature representations learned by the student and teacher models.
By optimizing these three loss terms jointly, the student model is encouraged to mimic not only the final outputs of the teacher model, but also the rich, multi-scale feature representations that the teacher model has learned. This allows the student model to acquire more comprehensive knowledge from the teacher, leading to better performance compared to traditional knowledge distillation approaches.
The authors evaluate CrossKD on several dense object detection benchmarks, including COCO and Pascal VOC. The results show that CrossKD can effectively transfer knowledge from a large teacher model to a smaller student model, resulting in a significant performance improvement over the student model trained without knowledge distillation, while maintaining a minimal accuracy gap compared to the teacher model.
Critical Analysis
The authors present a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the CrossKD method, comparing it to several state-of-the-art knowledge distillation techniques for object detection. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the cross-head distillation approach in improving the performance of the student model without excessive accuracy degradation.
However, the paper could be strengthened by addressing some potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Generalization to Other Architectures: The authors evaluate CrossKD using a single object detection architecture (Faster R-CNN). It would be valuable to assess the method's performance and applicability to other popular object detection frameworks, such as knowledge-distillation-multi-granularity-mixture-priors-image, to better understand its broader utility.
-
Computational Overhead: While the authors mention that the additional computational cost of CrossKD is "negligible," a more detailed analysis of the runtime and memory footprint of the method would help users understand the tradeoffs involved in deploying the student model.
-
Interpretability of Learned Features: The paper focuses on the quantitative performance of the student model, but does not provide much insight into the nature of the features learned by the student model through the cross-head distillation process. Exploring the interpretability and characteristics of these features could lead to a better understanding of why the method is effective.
-
Robustness to Distribution Shift: The evaluations in the paper are conducted on standard object detection benchmarks, but it would be interesting to investigate the robustness of the CrossKD-trained student model to distributional shifts, such as domain adaptation or out-of-distribution samples, to assess its real-world applicability.
Overall, the CrossKD method represents a valuable contribution to the field of knowledge distillation for object detection, and the authors have demonstrated its effectiveness through a rigorous evaluation. Addressing the above points could further strengthen the paper and provide additional insights into the method's capabilities and limitations.
Conclusion
The CrossKD paper introduces a novel knowledge distillation approach for dense object detection tasks. By leveraging cross-head distillation, the method effectively transfers knowledge from a large, high-performance teacher model to a smaller student model, allowing the student to achieve superior performance compared to traditional knowledge distillation techniques.
The key innovation of CrossKD is its ability to align the intermediate feature representations of the student model with those of the teacher model, in addition to aligning the final classification and regression outputs. This comprehensive knowledge transfer enables the student model to acquire more robust and discriminative features, leading to better detection accuracy.
The authors' thorough evaluation on standard object detection benchmarks demonstrates the effectiveness of CrossKD, making it a promising approach for deploying high-performance object detection models on resource-constrained devices. Further research into the method's generalization, computational efficiency, and robustness could provide additional insights and strengthen its real-world applicability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Teaching with Uncertainty: Unleashing the Potential of Knowledge Distillation in Object Detection
Junfei Yi, Jianxu Mao, Tengfei Liu, Mingjie Li, Hanyu Gu, Hui Zhang, Xiaojun Chang, Yaonan Wang
0
0
Knowledge distillation (KD) is a widely adopted and effective method for compressing models in object detection tasks. Particularly, feature-based distillation methods have shown remarkable performance. Existing approaches often ignore the uncertainty in the teacher model's knowledge, which stems from data noise and imperfect training. This limits the student model's ability to learn latent knowledge, as it may overly rely on the teacher's imperfect guidance. In this paper, we propose a novel feature-based distillation paradigm with knowledge uncertainty for object detection, termed Uncertainty Estimation-Discriminative Knowledge Extraction-Knowledge Transfer (UET), which can seamlessly integrate with existing distillation methods. By leveraging the Monte Carlo dropout technique, we introduce knowledge uncertainty into the training process of the student model, facilitating deeper exploration of latent knowledge. Our method performs effectively during the KD process without requiring intricate structures or extensive computational resources. Extensive experiments validate the effectiveness of our proposed approach across various distillation strategies, detectors, and backbone architectures. Specifically, following our proposed paradigm, the existing FGD method achieves state-of-the-art (SoTA) performance, with ResNet50-based GFL achieving 44.1% mAP on the COCO dataset, surpassing the baselines by 3.9%.
6/12/2024
Cross-Domain Knowledge Distillation for Low-Resolution Human Pose Estimation
Zejun Gu, Zhong-Qiu Zhao, Henghui Ding, Hao Shen, Zhao Zhang, De-Shuang Huang
0
0
In practical applications of human pose estimation, low-resolution inputs frequently occur, and existing state-of-the-art models perform poorly with low-resolution images. This work focuses on boosting the performance of low-resolution models by distilling knowledge from a high-resolution model. However, we face the challenge of feature size mismatch and class number mismatch when applying knowledge distillation to networks with different input resolutions. To address this issue, we propose a novel cross-domain knowledge distillation (CDKD) framework. In this framework, we construct a scale-adaptive projector ensemble (SAPE) module to spatially align feature maps between models of varying input resolutions. It adopts a projector ensemble to map low-resolution features into multiple common spaces and adaptively merges them based on multi-scale information to match high-resolution features. Additionally, we construct a cross-class alignment (CCA) module to solve the problem of the mismatch of class numbers. By combining an easy-to-hard training (ETHT) strategy, the CCA module further enhances the distillation performance. The effectiveness and efficiency of our approach are demonstrated by extensive experiments on two common benchmark datasets: MPII and COCO. The code is made available in supplementary material.
5/21/2024
Robust Knowledge Distillation Based on Feature Variance Against Backdoored Teacher Model
Jinyin Chen, Xiaoming Zhao, Haibin Zheng, Xiao Li, Sheng Xiang, Haifeng Guo
0
0
Benefiting from well-trained deep neural networks (DNNs), model compression have captured special attention for computing resource limited equipment, especially edge devices. Knowledge distillation (KD) is one of the widely used compression techniques for edge deployment, by obtaining a lightweight student model from a well-trained teacher model released on public platforms. However, it has been empirically noticed that the backdoor in the teacher model will be transferred to the student model during the process of KD. Although numerous KD methods have been proposed, most of them focus on the distillation of a high-performing student model without robustness consideration. Besides, some research adopts KD techniques as effective backdoor mitigation tools, but they fail to perform model compression at the same time. Consequently, it is still an open problem to well achieve two objectives of robust KD, i.e., student model's performance and backdoor mitigation. To address these issues, we propose RobustKD, a robust knowledge distillation that compresses the model while mitigating backdoor based on feature variance. Specifically, RobustKD distinguishes the previous works in three key aspects: (1) effectiveness: by distilling the feature map of the teacher model after detoxification, the main task performance of the student model is comparable to that of the teacher model; (2) robustness: by reducing the characteristic variance between the teacher model and the student model, it mitigates the backdoor of the student model under backdoored teacher model scenario; (3) generic: RobustKD still has good performance in the face of multiple data models (e.g., WRN 28-4, Pyramid-200) and diverse DNNs (e.g., ResNet50, MobileNet).
6/6/2024
Task Integration Distillation for Object Detectors
Hai Su, ZhenWen Jian, Songsen Yu
0
0
Knowledge distillation is a widely adopted technique for model lightening. However, the performance of most knowledge distillation methods in the domain of object detection is not satisfactory. Typically, knowledge distillation approaches consider only the classification task among the two sub-tasks of an object detector, largely overlooking the regression task. This oversight leads to a partial understanding of the object detector's comprehensive task, resulting in skewed estimations and potentially adverse effects. Therefore, we propose a knowledge distillation method that addresses both the classification and regression tasks, incorporating a task significance strategy. By evaluating the importance of features based on the output of the detector's two sub-tasks, our approach ensures a balanced consideration of both classification and regression tasks in object detection. Drawing inspiration from real-world teaching processes and the definition of learning condition, we introduce a method that focuses on both key and weak areas. By assessing the value of features for knowledge distillation based on their importance differences, we accurately capture the current model's learning situation. This method effectively prevents the issue of biased predictions about the model's learning reality caused by an incomplete utilization of the detector's outputs.
4/3/2024