DAPR: A Benchmark on Document-Aware Passage Retrieval

Overview

• The paper focuses on the task of Document-Aware Passage Retrieval (DAPR), where the goal is to find relevant passages within long documents like Wikipedia articles or research papers.
• The authors find that current state-of-the-art passage retrieval models struggle with this task, as 53.5% of their errors are due to a lack of understanding of the document context.
• To address this, the authors create a new benchmark for DAPR and experiment with extending existing passage retrieval models with document context information.

Plain English Explanation

When searching for information, people often want to find a specific section or passage within a long document, like a Wikipedia article or research paper. This paper explores a new task called Document-Aware Passage Retrieval (DAPR) to address this need.

The authors found that existing passage retrieval models, which are designed to work well on short texts, struggle with long documents. Over half of the errors made by these models are due to a lack of understanding of the full document context.

To better support this type of search, the authors created a new benchmark dataset for DAPR, drawing from a variety of document sources. They then tested ways to improve passage retrieval by incorporating document-level information, such as prepending the document title to the passage or using a hybrid approach that combines passage-level and document-level scoring.

The results show that while the hybrid approach performs best overall, it struggles on the most challenging queries that truly require understanding the document context. The contextualized passage representations, on the other hand, are better able to handle these difficult cases, though they don't perform as strongly overall.

By establishing this new benchmark and experimenting with different approaches, the authors hope to spur further research into building more effective retrieval systems for finding relevant passages within long documents.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes the task of Document-Aware Passage Retrieval (DAPR), where the goal is to find relevant passages within long documents like Wikipedia articles or research papers, rather than just ranking short texts.

Through an analysis of the errors made by state-of-the-art passage retrieval models, the authors find that over 53.5% of the errors are due to a lack of understanding of the document context. This motivates them to create a new benchmark for DAPR, drawing from multiple datasets across different domains.

To address the document context challenge, the authors experiment with two approaches:

1. Hybrid retrieval, which combines passage-level and document-level scoring using BM25.
2. Contextualized passage representations, where they prepend the document title to the passage to inform the passage representation with document context.

The results show that the hybrid approach performs the strongest on the overall benchmark, which contains a mixture of easy and hard queries. However, it completely fails on the hard queries that specifically require document-context understanding.

In contrast, the contextualized passage representations achieve good improvement on these hard queries, but perform rather poorly overall compared to the hybrid approach. The authors suggest that further research is needed to develop retrieval systems that can effectively leverage document-level information.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a valuable contribution by defining the new task of Document-Aware Passage Retrieval (DAPR) and creating a corresponding benchmark dataset. This addresses an important real-world need, as users often want to find relevant information within long, complex documents.

The authors' analysis of the errors made by existing passage retrieval models is insightful, highlighting the limitations of these systems when it comes to understanding document context. Their experiments with hybrid retrieval and contextualized passage representations provide a solid starting point for addressing this challenge.

However, the results also reveal the difficulty of the DAPR task. While the hybrid approach performs best overall, its complete failure on the hard queries suggests that more sophisticated techniques are needed to truly leverage document-level information. The contextualized representations, while better suited for the hard cases, still underperform compared to the hybrid method.

Further research could explore more advanced ways of incorporating document context, such as through the use of hierarchical or multi-level retrieval models. Additionally, the benchmark dataset could be expanded to include a wider range of document types and query difficulties to better assess the capabilities of different retrieval approaches.

Overall, this paper lays important groundwork for the DAPR task and highlights the need for continued innovation in document-level information retrieval.

Conclusion

This paper introduces the new task of Document-Aware Passage Retrieval (DAPR), where the goal is to find relevant passages within long documents like Wikipedia articles or research papers. The authors find that existing passage retrieval models struggle with this task due to a lack of understanding of document context.

To address this, the authors create a new benchmark dataset for DAPR and experiment with extending these models by incorporating document-level information. While a hybrid approach that combines passage-level and document-level scoring performs best overall, it fails on the most challenging queries that require deep comprehension of the document context.

Contextualized passage representations, which prepend the document title to the passage, show promise for handling these difficult cases, but overall performance is still relatively poor. The authors argue that further research is needed to develop more effective retrieval systems for the DAPR task, which has important real-world applications.

By establishing this new benchmark and exploring different approaches, this paper lays the groundwork for future advancements in document-level information retrieval.