Decision Focused Causal Learning for Direct Counterfactual Marketing Optimization

Read original: arXiv:2407.13664 - Published 7/19/2024 by Hao Zhou, Rongxiao Huang, Shaoming Li, Guibin Jiang, Jiaqi Zheng, Bing Cheng, Wei Lin
Total Score

0

Decision Focused Causal Learning for Direct Counterfactual Marketing Optimization

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents a new approach for optimizing marketing decisions using causal learning and decision-focused models.
  • The key idea is to learn causal models that directly optimize for marketing decisions, rather than just predicting outcomes.
  • The authors demonstrate this approach on a real-world e-commerce dataset, showing it can outperform traditional methods.

Plain English Explanation

When companies run marketing campaigns, they want to know how effective those campaigns will be. The paper "Decision Focused Causal Learning for Direct Counterfactual Marketing Optimization" introduces a new way to model the causal effects of marketing on customer behavior.

Rather than just trying to predict outcomes, the authors' approach directly optimizes the marketing decisions. This means the model is trained to recommend the best marketing actions, rather than just forecasting results. The authors show this "decision-focused" causal learning can outperform traditional methods on a real-world e-commerce dataset.

The key insight is that standard machine learning models are often optimized for prediction accuracy, but that doesn't necessarily translate to making the best decisions. By explicitly modeling the causal relationships and optimizing the decisions, the authors' approach can lead to more effective marketing campaigns.

This work builds on recent advances in causal inference and decision-focused modeling. The authors demonstrate how these ideas can be applied to a practical marketing optimization problem, showing the potential impact on real-world business challenges.

Technical Explanation

The core of the authors' approach is a framework they call "Decision Focused Causal Learning" (DFCL). This involves learning causal models that directly optimize the marketing decisions, rather than just predicting outcomes.

Specifically, the authors formulate the marketing optimization problem as a counterfactual decision-making task. They learn a causal model that can predict the outcomes of different marketing interventions, and then use this model to find the optimal set of marketing actions.

This is in contrast to a more standard approach of first learning a predictive model, and then using that model to optimize the decisions in a separate step. By integrating the causal modeling and decision optimization, the DFCL approach can lead to better marketing strategies.

The authors demonstrate their DFCL framework on a real-world e-commerce dataset, comparing it to various baselines. They show that DFCL outperforms these other methods in terms of the actual marketing outcomes achieved.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge several limitations of their work. First, the causal model they use relies on the assumption of unconfounded treatment assignment, which may not always hold in practice.

Additionally, the authors only evaluate their approach on a single dataset, so further validation on other marketing optimization problems would be valuable. The generalizability of the DFCL framework could be explored in future research.

It's also worth noting that the authors' approach, like many causal inference methods, requires access to detailed observational data on past marketing campaigns and their outcomes. Collecting such data may be challenging for some organizations.

Overall, this paper presents a promising new direction for marketing optimization by directly incorporating causal reasoning into the decision-making process. The authors' DFCL framework offers an interesting alternative to standard predictive modeling approaches, with the potential for more effective marketing strategies.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel "Decision Focused Causal Learning" approach for optimizing marketing decisions. By learning causal models that directly optimize the marketing actions, rather than just predicting outcomes, the authors demonstrate improved performance on a real-world e-commerce dataset.

The key innovation is the integration of causal reasoning and decision-making, which allows the model to recommend marketing strategies that are more closely aligned with the desired business objectives. This work builds on recent advancements in causal inference and decision-focused modeling, highlighting the potential impact of these techniques on practical applications.

While the authors acknowledge some limitations, this research offers an interesting new direction for marketing optimization that could lead to more effective, data-driven campaign strategies. As organizations continue to grapple with the complexities of modern marketing, tools like DFCL may become increasingly valuable for driving business success.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Decision Focused Causal Learning for Direct Counterfactual Marketing Optimization
Total Score

0

Decision Focused Causal Learning for Direct Counterfactual Marketing Optimization

Hao Zhou, Rongxiao Huang, Shaoming Li, Guibin Jiang, Jiaqi Zheng, Bing Cheng, Wei Lin

Marketing optimization plays an important role to enhance user engagement in online Internet platforms. Existing studies usually formulate this problem as a budget allocation problem and solve it by utilizing two fully decoupled stages, i.e., machine learning (ML) and operation research (OR). However, the learning objective in ML does not take account of the downstream optimization task in OR, which causes that the prediction accuracy in ML may be not positively related to the decision quality. Decision Focused Learning (DFL) integrates ML and OR into an end-to-end framework, which takes the objective of the downstream task as the decision loss function and guarantees the consistency of the optimization direction between ML and OR. However, deploying DFL in marketing is non-trivial due to multiple technological challenges. Firstly, the budget allocation problem in marketing is a 0-1 integer stochastic programming problem and the budget is uncertain and fluctuates a lot in real-world settings, which is beyond the general problem background in DFL. Secondly, the counterfactual in marketing causes that the decision loss cannot be directly computed and the optimal solution can never be obtained, both of which disable the common gradient-estimation approaches in DFL. Thirdly, the OR solver is called frequently to compute the decision loss during model training in DFL, which produces huge computational cost and cannot support large-scale training data. In this paper, we propose a decision focused causal learning framework (DFCL) for direct counterfactual marketing optimization, which overcomes the above technological challenges. Both offline experiments and online A/B testing demonstrate the effectiveness of DFCL over the state-of-the-art methods. Currently, DFCL has been deployed in several marketing scenarios in Meituan, one of the largest online food delivery platform in the world.

Read more

7/19/2024

🗣️

Total Score

0

Decision-Focused Learning: Foundations, State of the Art, Benchmark and Future Opportunities

Jayanta Mandi, James Kotary, Senne Berden, Maxime Mulamba, Victor Bucarey, Tias Guns, Ferdinando Fioretto

Decision-focused learning (DFL) is an emerging paradigm that integrates machine learning (ML) and constrained optimization to enhance decision quality by training ML models in an end-to-end system. This approach shows significant potential to revolutionize combinatorial decision-making in real-world applications that operate under uncertainty, where estimating unknown parameters within decision models is a major challenge. This paper presents a comprehensive review of DFL, providing an in-depth analysis of both gradient-based and gradient-free techniques used to combine ML and constrained optimization. It evaluates the strengths and limitations of these techniques and includes an extensive empirical evaluation of eleven methods across seven problems. The survey also offers insights into recent advancements and future research directions in DFL. Code and benchmark: https://github.com/PredOpt/predopt-benchmarks

Read more

9/5/2024

Decision-Focused Learning to Predict Action Costs for Planning
Total Score

0

Decision-Focused Learning to Predict Action Costs for Planning

Jayanta Mandi, Marco Foschini, Daniel Holler, Sylvie Thiebaux, Jorg Hoffmann, Tias Guns

In many automated planning applications, action costs can be hard to specify. An example is the time needed to travel through a certain road segment, which depends on many factors, such as the current weather conditions. A natural way to address this issue is to learn to predict these parameters based on input features (e.g., weather forecasts) and use the predicted action costs in automated planning afterward. Decision-Focused Learning (DFL) has been successful in learning to predict the parameters of combinatorial optimization problems in a way that optimizes solution quality rather than prediction quality. This approach yields better results than treating prediction and optimization as separate tasks. In this paper, we investigate for the first time the challenges of implementing DFL for automated planning in order to learn to predict the action costs. There are two main challenges to overcome: (1) planning systems are called during gradient descent learning, to solve planning problems with negative action costs, which are not supported in planning. We propose novel methods for gradient computation to avoid this issue. (2) DFL requires repeated planner calls during training, which can limit the scalability of the method. We experiment with different methods approximating the optimal plan as well as an easy-to-implement caching mechanism to speed up the learning process. As the first work that addresses DFL for automated planning, we demonstrate that the proposed gradient computation consistently yields significantly better plans than predictions aimed at minimizing prediction error; and that caching can temper the computation requirements.

Read more

8/27/2024

Score Function Gradient Estimation to Widen the Applicability of Decision-Focused Learning
Total Score

0

Score Function Gradient Estimation to Widen the Applicability of Decision-Focused Learning

Mattia Silvestri, Senne Berden, Jayanta Mandi, Ali .Irfan Mahmutou{g}ullar{i}, Brandon Amos, Tias Guns, Michele Lombardi

Many real-world optimization problems contain parameters that are unknown before deployment time, either due to stochasticity or to lack of information (e.g., demand or travel times in delivery problems). A common strategy in such cases is to estimate said parameters via machine learning (ML) models trained to minimize the prediction error, which however is not necessarily aligned with the downstream task-level error. The decision-focused learning (DFL) paradigm overcomes this limitation by training to directly minimize a task loss, e.g. regret. Since the latter has non-informative gradients for combinatorial problems, state-of-the-art DFL methods introduce surrogates and approximations that enable training. But these methods exploit specific assumptions about the problem structures (e.g., convex or linear problems, unknown parameters only in the objective function). We propose an alternative method that makes no such assumptions, it combines stochastic smoothing with score function gradient estimation which works on any task loss. This opens up the use of DFL methods to nonlinear objectives, uncertain parameters in the problem constraints, and even two-stage stochastic optimization. Experiments show that it typically requires more epochs, but that it is on par with specialized methods and performs especially well for the difficult case of problems with uncertainty in the constraints, in terms of solution quality, scalability, or both.

Read more

6/18/2024