Detecting Multimodal Situations with Insufficient Context and Abstaining from Baseless Predictions
0
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses how contextual information can help understand the reasoning behind visual-language tasks.
- It explores three scenarios where context provides insights that are not directly evident from the image alone.
- The findings suggest that considering contextual cues is important for improving performance on image-language reasoning tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The research paper looks at how additional information beyond just an image can help us better understand what's happening in a visual-language task. It describes three different situations where the context around an image gives us more clues about the right interpretation, even if that context isn't directly shown in the image itself.
For example, in the first scenario, the context indicates the person is likely injured, which explains why they are in a certain position, even though the injury itself isn't visible. In the second scenario, the context mentions a corpse that isn't shown in the image, which helps explain the woman's fearful reaction. And in the third scenario, the context about the person being drunk provides important insight into their stumbling behavior.
The key point is that considering this broader contextual information, and not just relying on the image alone, can lead to better reasoning and performance on tasks that involve both visual and language components. [This relates to research on how <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/unk-vqa-dataset-probe-into-abstention-ability">visual-language models can struggle with out-of-context information</a> and the need to better characterize their abstention behavior.]
Technical Explanation
The paper explores how contextual information can provide additional cues to improve understanding in an image-language reasoning task. It presents three distinct scenarios that demonstrate how context can help resolve ambiguities or provide insights not directly evident from the image alone.
In the first scenario, the context of a fighting scene suggests the person is down due to an injury, even though the nature of the injury is not visible in the image. The second scenario involves a context that mentions a corpse, which is not shown in the image but helps explain the woman's fearful reaction. The third scenario uses contextual cues about the person being drunk to make their stumbling behavior more plausible.
These examples illustrate how incorporating relevant contextual information, beyond just the visual content, can enhance the ability to correctly interpret and reason about the depicted situations. This relates to research on interpreting out-of-context information in neural networks and the risks of large multimodal models "hijacking" context in unintended ways.
The findings suggest that designing image-language systems to effectively leverage contextual cues could lead to improved performance on reasoning tasks that require integrating visual and textual information. This aligns with work on how VLLMs can provide better context for emotion understanding.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling demonstration of how contextual information can enhance understanding in visual-language reasoning tasks. However, it is limited to a few specific scenarios and does not explore the broader challenges of effectively incorporating context in these systems.
One potential concern is the reliance on human-annotated context, which may not always be available or accurately capture the nuances of real-world situations. Developing approaches to automatically extract and leverage relevant contextual cues from diverse sources could be an important next step.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential pitfalls of over-relying on context, such as the risk of introducing biases or making incorrect inferences. Further research is needed to understand the appropriate balance between visual and contextual information, and how to design systems that can robustly handle contextual ambiguity or inconsistencies.
Conclusion
This research highlights the importance of considering contextual information beyond just the visual content when trying to reason about and understand complex visual-language scenarios. The three illustrative examples demonstrate how relevant contextual cues can provide valuable insights that are not directly evident from the image alone, suggesting that incorporating such context is crucial for improving the performance of image-language reasoning systems.
While the paper is limited in scope, it underscores the need for continued exploration of how to effectively leverage contextual information in multimodal AI models. Addressing the challenges of automatically extracting and integrating relevant context, while mitigating the risks of over-reliance or biased inferences, will be important areas for future research in this domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
0
Detecting Multimodal Situations with Insufficient Context and Abstaining from Baseless Predictions
Junzhang Liu, Zhecan Wang, Hammad Ayyubi, Haoxuan You, Chris Thomas, Rui Sun, Shih-Fu Chang, Kai-Wei Chang
Despite the widespread adoption of Vision-Language Understanding (VLU) benchmarks such as VQA v2, OKVQA, A-OKVQA, GQA, VCR, SWAG, and VisualCOMET, our analysis reveals a pervasive issue affecting their integrity: these benchmarks contain samples where answers rely on assumptions unsupported by the provided context. Training models on such data foster biased learning and hallucinations as models tend to make similar unwarranted assumptions. To address this issue, we collect contextual data for each sample whenever available and train a context selection module to facilitate evidence-based model predictions. Strong improvements across multiple benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. Further, we develop a general-purpose Context-AwaRe Abstention (CARA) detector to identify samples lacking sufficient context and enhance model accuracy by abstaining from responding if the required context is absent. CARA exhibits generalization to new benchmarks it wasn't trained on, underscoring its utility for future VLU benchmarks in detecting or cleaning samples with inadequate context. Finally, we curate a Context Ambiguity and Sufficiency Evaluation (CASE) set to benchmark the performance of insufficient context detectors. Overall, our work represents a significant advancement in ensuring that vision-language models generate trustworthy and evidence-based outputs in complex real-world scenarios.
Read more5/28/2024
📶
0
ConTextual: Evaluating Context-Sensitive Text-Rich Visual Reasoning in Large Multimodal Models
Rohan Wadhawan, Hritik Bansal, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng
Many real-world tasks require an agent to reason jointly over text and visual objects, (e.g., navigating in public spaces), which we refer to as context-sensitive text-rich visual reasoning. Specifically, these tasks require an understanding of the context in which the text interacts with visual elements within an image. However, there is a lack of existing datasets to benchmark the state-of-the-art multimodal models' capability on context-sensitive text-rich visual reasoning. In this paper, we introduce ConTextual, a novel dataset featuring human-crafted instructions that require context-sensitive reasoning for text-rich images. We conduct experiments to assess the performance of 14 foundation models (GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro-Vision, LLaVA-Next) and establish a human performance baseline. Further, we perform human evaluations of the model responses and observe a significant performance gap of 30.8% between GPT-4V (the current best-performing Large Multimodal Model) and human performance. Our fine-grained analysis reveals that GPT-4V encounters difficulties interpreting time-related data and infographics. However, it demonstrates proficiency in comprehending abstract visual contexts such as memes and quotes. Finally, our qualitative analysis uncovers various factors contributing to poor performance including lack of precise visual perception and hallucinations. Our dataset, code, and leaderboard can be found on the project page https://con-textual.github.io/
Read more7/17/2024
🤔
0
ContextVLM: Zero-Shot and Few-Shot Context Understanding for Autonomous Driving using Vision Language Models
Shounak Sural, Naren, Ragunathan Rajkumar
In recent years, there has been a notable increase in the development of autonomous vehicle (AV) technologies aimed at improving safety in transportation systems. While AVs have been deployed in the real-world to some extent, a full-scale deployment requires AVs to robustly navigate through challenges like heavy rain, snow, low lighting, construction zones and GPS signal loss in tunnels. To be able to handle these specific challenges, an AV must reliably recognize the physical attributes of the environment in which it operates. In this paper, we define context recognition as the task of accurately identifying environmental attributes for an AV to appropriately deal with them. Specifically, we define 24 environmental contexts capturing a variety of weather, lighting, traffic and road conditions that an AV must be aware of. Motivated by the need to recognize environmental contexts, we create a context recognition dataset called DrivingContexts with more than 1.6 million context-query pairs relevant for an AV. Since traditional supervised computer vision approaches do not scale well to a variety of contexts, we propose a framework called ContextVLM that uses vision-language models to detect contexts using zero- and few-shot approaches. ContextVLM is capable of reliably detecting relevant driving contexts with an accuracy of more than 95% on our dataset, while running in real-time on a 4GB Nvidia GeForce GTX 1050 Ti GPU on an AV with a latency of 10.5 ms per query.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Losing Visual Needles in Image Haystacks: Vision Language Models are Easily Distracted in Short and Long Contexts
Aditya Sharma, Michael Saxon, William Yang Wang
We present LoCoVQA, a dynamic benchmark generator for evaluating long-context extractive reasoning in vision language models (VLMs). LoCoVQA augments test examples for mathematical reasoning, VQA, and character recognition tasks with increasingly long visual contexts composed of both in-distribution and out-of-distribution distractor images. Across these tasks, a diverse set of VLMs rapidly lose performance as the visual context length grows, often exhibiting a striking logarithmic decay trend. This test assesses how well VLMs can ignore irrelevant information when answering queries -- a task that is quite easy for language models (LMs) in the text domain -- demonstrating that current state-of-the-art VLMs lack this essential capability for many long-context applications.
Read more7/4/2024