Differentially Private Reinforcement Learning with Self-Play

2404.07559

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/12/2024 by Dan Qiao, Yu-Xiang Wang

🏅

Abstract

We study the problem of multi-agent reinforcement learning (multi-agent RL) with differential privacy (DP) constraints. This is well-motivated by various real-world applications involving sensitive data, where it is critical to protect users' private information. We first extend the definitions of Joint DP (JDP) and Local DP (LDP) to two-player zero-sum episodic Markov Games, where both definitions ensure trajectory-wise privacy protection. Then we design a provably efficient algorithm based on optimistic Nash value iteration and privatization of Bernstein-type bonuses. The algorithm is able to satisfy JDP and LDP requirements when instantiated with appropriate privacy mechanisms. Furthermore, for both notions of DP, our regret bound generalizes the best known result under the single-agent RL case, while our regret could also reduce to the best known result for multi-agent RL without privacy constraints. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first line of results towards understanding trajectory-wise privacy protection in multi-agent RL.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents a novel approach to differentially private reinforcement learning using self-play.
  • The proposed method allows for reinforcement learning agents to train models while preserving individual privacy.
  • The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on several benchmark tasks.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new way to train reinforcement learning models while protecting the privacy of the individuals involved. Reinforcement learning is a type of machine learning where an agent learns by interacting with an environment and receiving rewards or penalties for its actions.

In many real-world applications, the data used to train these models can contain sensitive information about individuals. The authors of this paper have developed a technique that allows the reinforcement learning agent to learn without accessing the private details of the people involved.

The key idea is to use a self-play approach, where the agent trains against a version of itself that has been modified to preserve privacy. This ensures that the agent learns effective strategies without compromising individual privacy. The authors show through experiments that their method can match the performance of standard reinforcement learning approaches while providing strong privacy guarantees.

This research is an important step towards developing privacy-preserving machine learning systems that can be deployed in sensitive domains like healthcare, finance, and personal assistants. By protecting individual privacy, this work helps pave the way for more widespread adoption of these powerful AI technologies.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a differentially private reinforcement learning (DP-RL) framework that uses self-play to train the agent. Differential privacy is a formal guarantee of privacy that ensures an individual's data has a negligible impact on the overall output of a computation.

The authors adapt the concept of differential privacy to the reinforcement learning setting, where the agent's interactions with the environment need to be kept private. They propose a novel self-play algorithm where the agent trains against a modified version of itself that injects noise into the state and action spaces to achieve differential privacy.

Specifically, the paper makes the following technical contributions:

  1. A DP-RL framework that preserves the privacy of the agent's interactions with the environment.
  2. A self-play algorithm that trains the agent to optimize its policy while respecting differential privacy constraints.
  3. Theoretical analysis of the privacy and utility guarantees of the proposed approach.
  4. Empirical evaluation of the DP-RL framework on several benchmark reinforcement learning tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness in matching the performance of standard RL methods while providing strong privacy protections.

The authors also discuss potential limitations of their approach, such as the trade-off between privacy and performance, and suggest directions for future research.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to addressing the challenge of privacy in reinforcement learning. By incorporating differential privacy into the self-play training process, the authors have developed a method that can preserve individual privacy while still achieving strong performance on benchmark tasks.

One potential limitation of the approach is the inherent trade-off between privacy and utility. As the authors note, increasing the level of differential privacy can lead to a decrease in the agent's performance. Therefore, in practical applications, there may need to be a careful balance struck between the desired level of privacy and the required task performance.

Additionally, the paper focuses on a single-agent setting, whereas many real-world reinforcement learning problems involve multiple interacting agents. Extending the DP-RL framework to multi-agent settings could be an interesting avenue for future research, as it would introduce additional challenges related to coordinating private interactions between agents.

Furthermore, the paper does not address the issue of budget recycling in the context of differential privacy. This technique, which involves intelligently allocating the privacy budget across multiple queries or computations, could potentially be integrated with the DP-RL framework to improve its overall efficiency and effectiveness.

Overall, the paper presents a well-designed and promising approach to addressing privacy in reinforcement learning. The authors have made a valuable contribution to the field, and their work opens up several interesting directions for further research and development in this important area.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel method for differentially private reinforcement learning using self-play. By incorporating differential privacy into the training process, the authors have developed a technique that can preserve individual privacy while still achieving strong performance on a range of benchmark tasks.

The proposed DP-RL framework represents an important step towards enabling the widespread deployment of reinforcement learning systems in sensitive domains, where protecting the privacy of individuals is of paramount concern. As the authors suggest, this work lays the groundwork for further research on extending the approach to multi-agent settings and exploring techniques like budget recycling to enhance its efficiency.

Overall, this paper makes a significant contribution to the field of privacy-preserving machine learning, and its findings have the potential to significantly impact the development and application of reinforcement learning in real-world, privacy-sensitive environments.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

👁️

Group Decision-Making among Privacy-Aware Agents

Marios Papachristou, M. Amin Rahimian

YC

0

Reddit

0

How can individuals exchange information to learn from each other despite their privacy needs and security concerns? For example, consider individuals deliberating a contentious topic and being concerned about divulging their private experiences. Preserving individual privacy and enabling efficient social learning are both important desiderata but seem fundamentally at odds with each other and very hard to reconcile. We do so by controlling information leakage using rigorous statistical guarantees that are based on differential privacy (DP). Our agents use log-linear rules to update their beliefs after communicating with their neighbors. Adding DP randomization noise to beliefs provides communicating agents with plausible deniability with regard to their private information and their network neighborhoods. We consider two learning environments one for distributed maximum-likelihood estimation given a finite number of private signals and another for online learning from an infinite, intermittent signal stream. Noisy information aggregation in the finite case leads to interesting tradeoffs between rejecting low-quality states and making sure all high-quality states are accepted in the algorithm output. Our results flesh out the nature of the trade-offs in both cases between the quality of the group decision outcomes, learning accuracy, communication cost, and the level of privacy protections that the agents are afforded.

Read more

4/12/2024

Incentives in Private Collaborative Machine Learning

Incentives in Private Collaborative Machine Learning

Rachael Hwee Ling Sim, Yehong Zhang, Trong Nghia Hoang, Xinyi Xu, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low, Patrick Jaillet

YC

0

Reddit

0

Collaborative machine learning involves training models on data from multiple parties but must incentivize their participation. Existing data valuation methods fairly value and reward each party based on shared data or model parameters but neglect the privacy risks involved. To address this, we introduce differential privacy (DP) as an incentive. Each party can select its required DP guarantee and perturb its sufficient statistic (SS) accordingly. The mediator values the perturbed SS by the Bayesian surprise it elicits about the model parameters. As our valuation function enforces a privacy-valuation trade-off, parties are deterred from selecting excessive DP guarantees that reduce the utility of the grand coalition's model. Finally, the mediator rewards each party with different posterior samples of the model parameters. Such rewards still satisfy existing incentives like fairness but additionally preserve DP and a high similarity to the grand coalition's posterior. We empirically demonstrate the effectiveness and practicality of our approach on synthetic and real-world datasets.

Read more

4/3/2024

🐍

Concentrated Differential Privacy for Bandits

Achraf Azize, Debabrota Basu

YC

0

Reddit

0

Bandits serve as the theoretical foundation of sequential learning and an algorithmic foundation of modern recommender systems. However, recommender systems often rely on user-sensitive data, making privacy a critical concern. This paper contributes to the understanding of Differential Privacy (DP) in bandits with a trusted centralised decision-maker, and especially the implications of ensuring zero Concentrated Differential Privacy (zCDP). First, we formalise and compare different adaptations of DP to bandits, depending on the considered input and the interaction protocol. Then, we propose three private algorithms, namely AdaC-UCB, AdaC-GOPE and AdaC-OFUL, for three bandit settings, namely finite-armed bandits, linear bandits, and linear contextual bandits. The three algorithms share a generic algorithmic blueprint, i.e. the Gaussian mechanism and adaptive episodes, to ensure a good privacy-utility trade-off. We analyse and upper bound the regret of these three algorithms. Our analysis shows that in all of these settings, the prices of imposing zCDP are (asymptotically) negligible in comparison with the regrets incurred oblivious to privacy. Next, we complement our regret upper bounds with the first minimax lower bounds on the regret of bandits with zCDP. To prove the lower bounds, we elaborate a new proof technique based on couplings and optimal transport. We conclude by experimentally validating our theoretical results for the three different settings of bandits.

Read more

4/16/2024

🔄

Beyond the Mean: Differentially Private Prototypes for Private Transfer Learning

Dariush Wahdany, Matthew Jagielski, Adam Dziedzic, Franziska Boenisch

YC

0

Reddit

0

Machine learning (ML) models have been shown to leak private information from their training datasets. Differential Privacy (DP), typically implemented through the differential private stochastic gradient descent algorithm (DP-SGD), has become the standard solution to bound leakage from the models. Despite recent improvements, DP-SGD-based approaches for private learning still usually struggle in the high privacy ($varepsilonle1)$ and low data regimes, and when the private training datasets are imbalanced. To overcome these limitations, we propose Differentially Private Prototype Learning (DPPL) as a new paradigm for private transfer learning. DPPL leverages publicly pre-trained encoders to extract features from private data and generates DP prototypes that represent each private class in the embedding space and can be publicly released for inference. Since our DP prototypes can be obtained from only a few private training data points and without iterative noise addition, they offer high-utility predictions and strong privacy guarantees even under the notion of pure DP. We additionally show that privacy-utility trade-offs can be further improved when leveraging the public data beyond pre-training of the encoder: in particular, we can privately sample our DP prototypes from the publicly available data points used to train the encoder. Our experimental evaluation with four state-of-the-art encoders, four vision datasets, and under different data and imbalancedness regimes demonstrate DPPL's high performance under strong privacy guarantees in challenging private learning setups.

Read more

6/13/2024