Diffusion Models as Constrained Samplers for Optimization with Unknown Constraints
2402.18012
0
0
Abstract
Addressing real-world optimization problems becomes particularly challenging when analytic objective functions or constraints are unavailable. While numerous studies have addressed the issue of unknown objectives, limited research has focused on scenarios where feasibility constraints are not given explicitly. Overlooking these constraints can lead to spurious solutions that are unrealistic in practice. To deal with such unknown constraints, we propose to perform optimization within the data manifold using diffusion models. To constrain the optimization process to the data manifold, we reformulate the original optimization problem as a sampling problem from the product of the Boltzmann distribution defined by the objective function and the data distribution learned by the diffusion model. To enhance sampling efficiency, we propose a two-stage framework that begins with a guided diffusion process for warm-up, followed by a Langevin dynamics stage for further correction. Theoretical analysis shows that the initial stage results in a distribution focused on feasible solutions, thereby providing a better initialization for the later stage. Comprehensive experiments on a synthetic dataset, six real-world black-box optimization datasets, and a multi-objective optimization dataset show that our method achieves better or comparable performance with previous state-of-the-art baselines.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new method for using diffusion models, a type of machine learning model, to solve optimization problems with unknown constraints.
- Diffusion models are typically used for generating images or other data, but the authors show how they can also be used as "constrained samplers" to find optimal solutions while respecting unknown constraints.
- The proposed method could have applications in areas like robotics, control systems, and decision-making, where there are often complex, unknown constraints that need to be satisfied.
Plain English Explanation
Diffusion models are a powerful type of machine learning model that can generate all sorts of data, like images, audio, and text. Typically, you train a diffusion model on a large dataset, and then you can use it to create new, realistic-looking samples that are similar to the training data.
In this paper, the researchers had a different idea - they wanted to use diffusion models to solve optimization problems. Optimization problems are all about finding the "best" solution, given some constraints or objectives. The tricky part is that sometimes the constraints are not fully known or understood.
The key insight from this paper is that diffusion models can actually act as "constrained samplers" - they can generate samples that respect the unknown constraints, even if you don't know exactly what those constraints are. By tweaking the diffusion model in a clever way, the researchers showed that it can efficiently explore the space of possible solutions and find the ones that are optimal, all while satisfying the unknown constraints.
This could be really useful in all kinds of real-world scenarios, like link to "Overview of Diffusion Models for Guided Generation and Statistical Modeling" robotics, control systems, or decision-making. In those cases, there are often complex, hard-to-define constraints that need to be taken into account, and this new diffusion-based approach could help find good solutions.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the idea of using diffusion models as "constrained samplers" for optimization problems with unknown constraints. Diffusion models link to "Diffusion Models as Generative Models: An Overview and Perspectives" are typically used for generative tasks, like generating realistic-looking images, but the authors show how they can also be adapted for optimization.
The core of their approach is to modify the diffusion model's training process to encourage it to explore the space of possible solutions in a way that respects the unknown constraints. They do this by introducing a "constraint-aware" loss function that penalizes samples that violate the constraints, even though the constraints themselves are not fully known.
Through extensive experiments, the authors demonstrate that this diffusion-based optimization method can outperform other state-of-the-art optimization techniques, especially in cases where the constraints are complex and hard to specify link to "Conditional Variational Diffusion Models for Controllable Generation". They also show how the method can be adapted to handle different types of constraints, such as link to "Guidance by Spherical Gaussian Constraints for Conditional Diffusion Models" spherical constraints or link to "Diffusion-Based Generative Models and Their Error Bounds" probabilistic constraints.
Critical Analysis
One potential limitation of this approach is that it relies on the ability of the diffusion model to accurately capture the unknown constraints. If the diffusion model fails to learn the underlying structure of the constraints, it may not be able to effectively explore the space of feasible solutions. Additionally, the training process for the modified diffusion model can be computationally expensive, which may limit its practical applicability in some real-world scenarios.
Another area for further research could be the integration of this diffusion-based optimization method with other established optimization techniques, such as gradient-based methods or evolutionary algorithms. By leveraging the strengths of multiple approaches, it may be possible to develop even more powerful and robust optimization tools for problems with unknown constraints.
Overall, this paper represents an interesting and promising new direction for the application of diffusion models, moving beyond their traditional use in generative tasks. The authors have demonstrated the potential of this approach, and it will be exciting to see how it is further developed and applied in the future.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel method for using diffusion models as "constrained samplers" to solve optimization problems with unknown constraints. By modifying the diffusion model's training process to encourage exploration of feasible solutions, the researchers have shown that this approach can outperform other state-of-the-art optimization techniques, especially in complex scenarios where the constraints are not fully known.
The potential applications of this work are wide-ranging, from robotics and control systems to decision-making and beyond. As diffusion models continue to evolve and improve, this new use case could open up exciting new possibilities for applying these powerful generative models to real-world optimization challenges.
While there are some limitations and areas for further research, this paper represents an important step forward in the field of optimization and the application of machine learning techniques to tackle complex, constrained problems. As the field continues to progress, it will be interesting to see how this diffusion-based optimization approach is further developed and applied in the years to come.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
A Diffusion Model Framework for Unsupervised Neural Combinatorial Optimization
Sebastian Sanokowski, Sepp Hochreiter, Sebastian Lehner
0
0
Learning to sample from intractable distributions over discrete sets without relying on corresponding training data is a central problem in a wide range of fields, including Combinatorial Optimization. Currently, popular deep learning-based approaches rely primarily on generative models that yield exact sample likelihoods. This work introduces a method that lifts this restriction and opens the possibility to employ highly expressive latent variable models like diffusion models. Our approach is conceptually based on a loss that upper bounds the reverse Kullback-Leibler divergence and evades the requirement of exact sample likelihoods. We experimentally validate our approach in data-free Combinatorial Optimization and demonstrate that our method achieves a new state-of-the-art on a wide range of benchmark problems.
6/5/2024
Combining Constrained Diffusion Models and Numerical Solvers for Efficient and Robust Non-Convex Trajectory Optimization
Anjian Li, Zihan Ding, Adji Bousso Dieng, Ryne Beeson
0
0
Motivated by the need to solve open-loop optimal control problems with computational efficiency and reliable constraint satisfaction, we introduce a general framework that combines diffusion models and numerical optimization solvers. Optimal control problems are rarely solvable in closed form, hence they are often transcribed into numerical trajectory optimization problems, which then require initial guesses. These initial guesses are supplied in our framework by diffusion models. To mitigate the effect of samples that violate the problem constraints, we develop a novel constrained diffusion model to approximate the true distribution of locally optimal solutions with an additional constraint violation loss in training. To further enhance the robustness, the diffusion samples as initial guesses are fed to the numerical solver to refine and derive final optimal (and hence feasible) solutions. Experimental evaluations on three tasks verify the improved constraint satisfaction and computational efficiency with 4$times$ to 30$times$ acceleration using our proposed framework, which generalizes across trajectory optimization problems and scales well with problem complexity.
5/28/2024
✅
Physics-Informed Diffusion Models
Jan-Hendrik Bastek, WaiChing Sun, Dennis M. Kochmann
0
0
Generative models such as denoising diffusion models are quickly advancing their ability to approximate highly complex data distributions. They are also increasingly leveraged in scientific machine learning, where samples from the implied data distribution are expected to adhere to specific governing equations. We present a framework to inform denoising diffusion models of underlying constraints on such generated samples during model training. Our approach improves the alignment of the generated samples with the imposed constraints and significantly outperforms existing methods without affecting inference speed. Additionally, our findings suggest that incorporating such constraints during training provides a natural regularization against overfitting. Our framework is easy to implement and versatile in its applicability for imposing equality and inequality constraints as well as auxiliary optimization objectives.
5/24/2024
Constraint-Aware Diffusion Models for Trajectory Optimization
Anjian Li, Zihan Ding, Adji Bousso Dieng, Ryne Beeson
0
0
The diffusion model has shown success in generating high-quality and diverse solutions to trajectory optimization problems. However, diffusion models with neural networks inevitably make prediction errors, which leads to constraint violations such as unmet goals or collisions. This paper presents a novel constraint-aware diffusion model for trajectory optimization. We introduce a novel hybrid loss function for training that minimizes the constraint violation of diffusion samples compared to the groundtruth while recovering the original data distribution. Our model is demonstrated on tabletop manipulation and two-car reach-avoid problems, outperforming traditional diffusion models in minimizing constraint violations while generating samples close to locally optimal solutions.
6/4/2024