Discretizing Continuous Action Space with Unimodal Probability Distributions for On-Policy Reinforcement Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Reinforcement learning with continuous action spaces can be challenging
- This paper proposes a method to discretize continuous action spaces using unimodal probability distributions
- The approach aims to enable more efficient on-policy learning compared to previous discretization techniques
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a common challenge in reinforcement learning (RL) - dealing with continuous action spaces. In many real-world problems, the actions an agent can take exist on a continuous scale, rather than being discrete choices. This makes the learning process more complex, as the agent must learn to select the optimal action from an infinite number of possibilities.
The researchers propose a novel way to discretize the continuous action space using unimodal probability distributions, such as the Poisson distribution. By modeling the action space with these types of distributions, the agent can learn to select actions that have a high probability of being optimal, rather than having to precisely identify the single best action.
The key advantage of this approach is that it allows for more efficient on-policy learning, where the agent learns directly from the actions it takes, rather than relying on a separate policy exploration mechanism. This can lead to faster convergence and better overall performance in continuous control tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a method for discretizing continuous action spaces using unimodal probability distributions, with the goal of enabling more efficient on-policy reinforcement learning.
The core idea is to model the continuous action space as a set of discrete actions, where each discrete action is associated with a unimodal probability distribution (such as a Poisson distribution) over the original continuous range. During training, the agent learns to select the discrete action with the highest expected reward, rather than trying to precisely identify the optimal continuous action.
The authors demonstrate this approach on several continuous control tasks, comparing it to both discrete action spaces and previous continuous action discretization methods. Their results show that the proposed technique can lead to improved sample efficiency and overall performance, particularly in on-policy learning scenarios.
A key theoretical insight is that unimodal distributions allow the agent to focus exploration on the most promising regions of the action space, without requiring precise identification of the optimal action. This stands in contrast to previous discretization methods that treated each discrete action as equally likely.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to dealing with continuous action spaces in reinforcement learning, and the experimental results suggest it can be an effective technique. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Sensitivity to Distribution Choice: The performance of the method may be sensitive to the choice of unimodal distribution used to model the action space. The authors focus primarily on the Poisson distribution, but other options (e.g., Gaussian, Gamma) could potentially yield different results.
-
Scalability to High-Dimensional Spaces: The paper only evaluates the method on relatively low-dimensional continuous control tasks. Applying it to problems with very high-dimensional action spaces may introduce additional challenges that are not addressed here.
-
Comparison to State-of-the-Art Continuous RL: While the method outperforms some previous discretization approaches, it would be valuable to compare it more directly to the latest continuous reinforcement learning techniques, such as those using parameterized action spaces or diffusion policies.
-
Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides some theoretical insights, but more formal analysis of the method's convergence properties and sample complexity could help strengthen the claims about its efficiency.
Overall, the proposed discretization technique seems promising and could be a useful tool in the reinforcement learning practitioner's toolkit. However, further research is needed to fully understand its strengths, weaknesses, and appropriate applications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach to discretizing continuous action spaces for reinforcement learning, using unimodal probability distributions. The key idea is to model the continuous action space as a set of discrete actions, where each discrete action is associated with a unimodal distribution over the original continuous range.
The experimental results demonstrate that this method can lead to improved sample efficiency and overall performance, particularly in on-policy learning scenarios. The theoretical insights suggest that unimodal distributions allow the agent to focus exploration on the most promising regions of the action space, without requiring precise identification of the optimal action.
While the paper presents a compelling approach, there are still some open questions and areas for further research, such as the sensitivity to distribution choice, scalability to high-dimensional spaces, and comparison to state-of-the-art continuous reinforcement learning techniques. Nevertheless, this work represents an interesting contribution to the field of reinforcement learning, with the potential to enable more efficient learning in a variety of real-world applications with continuous action spaces.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Discretizing Continuous Action Space with Unimodal Probability Distributions for On-Policy Reinforcement Learning
Yuanyang Zhu, Zhi Wang, Yuanheng Zhu, Chunlin Chen, Dongbin Zhao
For on-policy reinforcement learning, discretizing action space for continuous control can easily express multiple modes and is straightforward to optimize. However, without considering the inherent ordering between the discrete atomic actions, the explosion in the number of discrete actions can possess undesired properties and induce a higher variance for the policy gradient estimator. In this paper, we introduce a straightforward architecture that addresses this issue by constraining the discrete policy to be unimodal using Poisson probability distributions. This unimodal architecture can better leverage the continuity in the underlying continuous action space using explicit unimodal probability distributions. We conduct extensive experiments to show that the discrete policy with the unimodal probability distribution provides significantly faster convergence and higher performance for on-policy reinforcement learning algorithms in challenging control tasks, especially in highly complex tasks such as Humanoid. We provide theoretical analysis on the variance of the policy gradient estimator, which suggests that our attentively designed unimodal discrete policy can retain a lower variance and yield a stable learning process.
Read more8/2/2024
👁️
0
Discrete Policy: Learning Disentangled Action Space for Multi-Task Robotic Manipulation
Kun Wu, Yichen Zhu, Jinming Li, Junjie Wen, Ning Liu, Zhiyuan Xu, Qinru Qiu, Jian Tang
Learning visuomotor policy for multi-task robotic manipulation has been a long-standing challenge for the robotics community. The difficulty lies in the diversity of action space: typically, a goal can be accomplished in multiple ways, resulting in a multimodal action distribution for a single task. The complexity of action distribution escalates as the number of tasks increases. In this work, we propose textbf{Discrete Policy}, a robot learning method for training universal agents capable of multi-task manipulation skills. Discrete Policy employs vector quantization to map action sequences into a discrete latent space, facilitating the learning of task-specific codes. These codes are then reconstructed into the action space conditioned on observations and language instruction. We evaluate our method on both simulation and multiple real-world embodiments, including both single-arm and bimanual robot settings. We demonstrate that our proposed Discrete Policy outperforms a well-established Diffusion Policy baseline and many state-of-the-art approaches, including ACT, Octo, and OpenVLA. For example, in a real-world multi-task training setting with five tasks, Discrete Policy achieves an average success rate that is 26% higher than Diffusion Policy and 15% higher than OpenVLA. As the number of tasks increases to 12, the performance gap between Discrete Policy and Diffusion Policy widens to 32.5%, further showcasing the advantages of our approach. Our work empirically demonstrates that learning multi-task policies within the latent space is a vital step toward achieving general-purpose agents.
Read more9/30/2024
🏅
0
On the Geometry of Reinforcement Learning in Continuous State and Action Spaces
Saket Tiwari, Omer Gottesman, George Konidaris
Advances in reinforcement learning have led to its successful application in complex tasks with continuous state and action spaces. Despite these advances in practice, most theoretical work pertains to finite state and action spaces. We propose building a theoretical understanding of continuous state and action spaces by employing a geometric lens. Central to our work is the idea that the transition dynamics induce a low dimensional manifold of reachable states embedded in the high-dimensional nominal state space. We prove that, under certain conditions, the dimensionality of this manifold is at most the dimensionality of the action space plus one. This is the first result of its kind, linking the geometry of the state space to the dimensionality of the action space. We empirically corroborate this upper bound for four MuJoCo environments. We further demonstrate the applicability of our result by learning a policy in this low dimensional representation. To do so we introduce an algorithm that learns a mapping to a low dimensional representation, as a narrow hidden layer of a deep neural network, in tandem with the policy using DDPG. Our experiments show that a policy learnt this way perform on par or better for four MuJoCo control suite tasks.
Read more8/13/2024
0
Randomized algorithms and PAC bounds for inverse reinforcement learning in continuous spaces
Angeliki Kamoutsi, Peter Schmitt-Forster, Tobias Sutter, Volkan Cevher, John Lygeros
This work studies discrete-time discounted Markov decision processes with continuous state and action spaces and addresses the inverse problem of inferring a cost function from observed optimal behavior. We first consider the case in which we have access to the entire expert policy and characterize the set of solutions to the inverse problem by using occupation measures, linear duality, and complementary slackness conditions. To avoid trivial solutions and ill-posedness, we introduce a natural linear normalization constraint. This results in an infinite-dimensional linear feasibility problem, prompting a thorough analysis of its properties. Next, we use linear function approximators and adopt a randomized approach, namely the scenario approach and related probabilistic feasibility guarantees, to derive epsilon-optimal solutions for the inverse problem. We further discuss the sample complexity for a desired approximation accuracy. Finally, we deal with the more realistic case where we only have access to a finite set of expert demonstrations and a generative model and provide bounds on the error made when working with samples.
Read more5/27/2024