Distilling Instruction-following Abilities of Large Language Models with Task-aware Curriculum Planning

Read original: arXiv:2405.13448 - Published 5/24/2024 by Yuanhao Yue, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Peng Wang

💬

Overview

This paper introduces Task-Aware Curriculum Planning for Instruction Refinement (TAPIR), a multi-round distillation framework that addresses the challenges of aligning pre-trained large language models (LLMs) with open-domain instructions and human-preferred responses.
The key innovations of TAPIR include balancing task distributions and dynamically adjusting the difficulty levels during the distillation process, which aims to systematically enhance the capabilities of smaller student LLMs.
The paper rigorously evaluates TAPIR using two widely recognized benchmarks, AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench, and demonstrates that student LLMs trained with TAPIR can outperform larger instruction-tuned models and strong distillation baselines, particularly on complex tasks like logical reasoning and code generation.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on the process of "instruction tuning", which is the method of aligning large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT with open-ended instructions and human-preferred responses. While previous studies have explored autonomous ways to extract and annotate instructions from powerful LLMs, they often overlooked the impact of the training dataset's task distribution and the varying difficulty of the instructions.

This oversight can lead to imbalanced knowledge capabilities and poor performance in small student LLMs. To address this challenge, the researchers introduce TAPIR, a multi-step distillation framework that uses an "oracle" LLM to select instructions that are difficult for the student model to follow. TAPIR also ensures a balanced distribution of task types during the distillation process and gradually increases the difficulty level, helping the student model progressively enhance its capabilities.

The researchers rigorously tested TAPIR using two well-known benchmarks, AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench. The results showed that student LLMs trained with TAPIR, using less data, outperformed larger instruction-tuned models and other strong distillation methods, especially on complex tasks like logical reasoning and code generation.

Technical Explanation

The key elements of the TAPIR framework are:

Balanced Task Distribution: TAPIR aims to distill instructions with a balanced distribution of task types, avoiding the imbalance that can lead to poor generalization in small student LLMs.
Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment: TAPIR utilizes an "oracle" LLM to identify instructions that are difficult for the student model to follow. By progressively increasing the difficulty level, TAPIR systematically enhances the student model's capabilities.
Multi-round Distillation: TAPIR employs a multi-round distillation process, where the student model is trained on increasingly challenging instructions, guided by the oracle LLM.

The researchers rigorously evaluated TAPIR using two well-established benchmarks:

AlpacaEval 2.0: A comprehensive evaluation suite for instruction-following language models.
MT-Bench: A benchmark for evaluating the performance of models on a diverse range of tasks, including logical reasoning and code generation.

The results demonstrate that student LLMs trained with TAPIR outperform larger instruction-tuned models and strong distillation baselines, particularly on complex tasks. This improvement is attributed to TAPIR's ability to systematically enhance the student model's capabilities through balanced task distributions and dynamic difficulty adjustment.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to address the challenges of instruction tuning for small student LLMs. However, some potential areas for further research include:

Generalization to Diverse Instruction Domains: While the paper showcases TAPIR's effectiveness on the evaluated benchmarks, it would be valuable to explore its performance on a wider range of instruction domains, including more specialized or technical tasks.
Computational Efficiency: The multi-round distillation process in TAPIR may have increased computational requirements compared to single-stage distillation approaches. Exploring ways to optimize the efficiency of the framework could further enhance its practical applicability.
Robustness and Alignment: The paper focuses on improving the capabilities of student LLMs, but it would be valuable to also assess the robustness and alignment of the models with human preferences and values, especially for safety-critical applications.

Conclusion

The TAPIR framework introduced in this paper represents a significant advancement in the field of instruction tuning for pre-trained LLMs. By addressing the challenges of task distribution and dynamic difficulty, TAPIR enables smaller student models to outperform larger instruction-tuned models, particularly on complex tasks. This research paves the way for more efficient and effective methods of aligning language models with human-preferred responses, which could have far-reaching implications for the development of advanced AI systems that can better assist and collaborate with humans.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

💬

Distilling Instruction-following Abilities of Large Language Models with Task-aware Curriculum Planning

Yuanhao Yue, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Peng Wang

The process of instruction tuning aligns pre-trained large language models (LLMs) with open-domain instructions and human-preferred responses. While several studies have explored autonomous approaches to distilling and annotating instructions from more powerful proprietary LLMs, such as ChatGPT, they often neglect the impact of task distributions and the varying difficulty of instructions of the training sets. This oversight can lead to imbalanced knowledge capabilities and poor generalization powers of small student LLMs. To address this challenge, we introduce Task-Aware Curriculum Planning for Instruction Refinement (TAPIR), a multi-round distillation framework with balanced task distributions and dynamic difficulty adjustment. This approach utilizes an oracle LLM to select instructions that are difficult for a student LLM to follow and distill instructions with balanced task distributions. By incorporating curriculum planning, our approach systematically escalates the difficulty levels, progressively enhancing the student LLM's capabilities. We rigorously evaluate TAPIR using two widely recognized benchmarks, including AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench. The empirical results demonstrate that the student LLMs, trained with our method and less training data, outperform larger instruction-tuned models and strong distillation baselines. The improvement is particularly notable in complex tasks, such as logical reasoning and code generation.

5/24/2024

🎯

Tailoring Instructions to Student's Learning Levels Boosts Knowledge Distillation

Yuxin Ren, Zihan Zhong, Xingjian Shi, Yi Zhu, Chun Yuan, Mu Li

It has been commonly observed that a teacher model with superior performance does not necessarily result in a stronger student, highlighting a discrepancy between current teacher training practices and effective knowledge transfer. In order to enhance the guidance of the teacher training process, we introduce the concept of distillation influence to determine the impact of distillation from each training sample on the student's generalization ability. In this paper, we propose Learning Good Teacher Matters (LGTM), an efficient training technique for incorporating distillation influence into the teacher's learning process. By prioritizing samples that are likely to enhance the student's generalization ability, our LGTM outperforms 10 common knowledge distillation baselines on 6 text classification tasks in the GLUE benchmark.

5/16/2024

Using Advanced LLMs to Enhance Smaller LLMs: An Interpretable Knowledge Distillation Approach

Tong Wang, K. Sudhir, Dat Hong

Advanced Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 or LlaMa 3 provide superior performance in complex human-like interactions. But they are costly, or too large for edge devices such as smartphones and harder to self-host, leading to security and privacy concerns. This paper introduces a novel interpretable knowledge distillation approach to enhance the performance of smaller, more economical LLMs that firms can self-host. We study this problem in the context of building a customer service agent aimed at achieving high customer satisfaction through goal-oriented dialogues. Unlike traditional knowledge distillation, where the student model learns directly from the teacher model's responses via fine-tuning, our interpretable strategy teaching approach involves the teacher providing strategies to improve the student's performance in various scenarios. This method alternates between a scenario generation step and a strategies for improvement step, creating a customized library of scenarios and optimized strategies for automated prompting. The method requires only black-box access to both student and teacher models; hence it can be used without manipulating model parameters. In our customer service application, the method improves performance, and the learned strategies are transferable to other LLMs and scenarios beyond the training set. The method's interpretabilty helps safeguard against potential harms through human audit.

8/15/2024

Teaching-Assistant-in-the-Loop: Improving Knowledge Distillation from Imperfect Teacher Models in Low-Budget Scenarios

Yuhang Zhou, Wei Ai

There is increasing interest in distilling task-specific knowledge from large language models (LLM) to smaller student models. Nonetheless, LLM distillation presents a dual challenge: 1) there is a high cost associated with querying the teacher LLM, such as GPT-4, for gathering an ample number of demonstrations; 2) the teacher LLM might provide imperfect outputs with a negative impact on the student's learning process. To enhance sample efficiency within resource-constrained, imperfect teacher scenarios, we propose a three-component framework leveraging three signal types. The first signal is the student's self-consistency (consistency of student multiple outputs), which is a proxy of the student's confidence. Specifically, we introduce a ``teaching assistant'' (TA) model to assess the uncertainty of both the student's and the teacher's outputs via confidence scoring, which serves as another two signals for student training. Furthermore, we propose a two-stage training schema to first warm up the student with a small proportion of data to better utilize student's signal. Experiments have shown the superiority of our proposed framework for four complex reasoning tasks. On average, our proposed two-stage framework brings a relative improvement of up to 20.79% compared to fine-tuning without any signals across datasets.

6/11/2024