Domain Shift Analysis in Chest Radiographs Classification in a Veterans Healthcare Administration Population
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper analyzes domain shift in the classification of chest radiographs in a Veterans Healthcare Administration population.
- Domain shift refers to the mismatch between the training data and the real-world data, which can degrade model performance.
- The study examines the impact of this domain shift and explores strategies to mitigate its effects.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models are often trained on datasets that may not fully represent the real-world data they will encounter. This mismatch, known as domain shift, can cause the model's performance to degrade when deployed in a different setting.
In this study, the researchers investigate the domain shift that occurs when using machine learning models to classify chest radiographs in a Veterans Healthcare Administration (VA) population. Chest radiographs are commonly used to diagnose and monitor various lung conditions, and the VA population may have unique characteristics that differ from the training data.
The researchers aim to understand the extent of this domain shift and explore strategies to mitigate the impact of annotation shift on the model's performance. By identifying and addressing the domain shift, the researchers hope to develop more robust and reliable chest radiograph classification models for the VA population.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by introducing the concept of domain shift, which refers to the mismatch between the distribution of the training data and the real-world data the model will encounter. This can occur due to differences in patient demographics, imaging protocols, or other factors.
To investigate the domain shift in the VA population, the researchers trained a deep learning model on a large, publicly available chest radiograph dataset and then evaluated its performance on a VA-specific dataset. They compared the model's performance on the VA dataset to its performance on the original training data, quantifying the extent of the domain shift.
The researchers also explored strategies to achieve fairness across domains, such as fine-tuning the model on the VA dataset or using domain adaptation techniques. These approaches aim to reduce the impact of domain shift and improve the model's performance in the VA setting.
The study provides insights into the challenges of deploying machine learning models in diverse healthcare settings and the importance of understanding and mitigating domain shift. The findings can inform the development of more localization-enabled deep learning models that are robust to variations in patient populations and imaging data.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the domain shift in chest radiograph classification for the VA population. However, the study does not explore the underlying reasons for the observed domain shift, such as differences in patient demographics, imaging protocols, or disease prevalence. Understanding these factors could lead to more targeted strategies for mitigating the domain shift.
Additionally, the study only evaluates the domain shift on a single VA dataset, and it's unclear how generalizable the findings are to other VA or non-VA healthcare settings. Further research could investigate the domain shift in a more diverse set of real-world healthcare environments.
Conclusion
This study highlights the importance of understanding and addressing domain shift when deploying machine learning models in healthcare settings. The researchers demonstrate the presence of a significant domain shift between a publicly available chest radiograph dataset and a VA-specific dataset, and they explore strategies to mitigate its impact.
The findings of this work can inform the development of more robust and reliable chest radiograph classification models for diverse patient populations, ultimately contributing to improved healthcare outcomes. By addressing domain shift, researchers and clinicians can work towards developing AI systems that are truly effective and equitable in real-world healthcare settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Domain Shift Analysis in Chest Radiographs Classification in a Veterans Healthcare Administration Population
Mayanka Chandrashekar, Ian Goethert, Md Inzamam Ul Haque, Benjamin McMahon, Sayera Dhaubhadel, Kathryn Knight, Joseph Erdos, Donna Reagan, Caroline Taylor, Peter Kuzmak, John Michael Gaziano, Eileen McAllister, Lauren Costa, Yuk-Lam Ho, Kelly Cho, Suzanne Tamang, Samah Fodeh-Jarad, Olga S. Ovchinnikova, Amy C. Justice, Jacob Hinkle, Ioana Danciu
Objectives: This study aims to assess the impact of domain shift on chest X-ray classification accuracy and to analyze the influence of ground truth label quality and demographic factors such as age group, sex, and study year. Materials and Methods: We used a DenseNet121 model pretrained MIMIC-CXR dataset for deep learning-based multilabel classification using ground truth labels from radiology reports extracted using the CheXpert and CheXbert Labeler. We compared the performance of the 14 chest X-ray labels on the MIMIC-CXR and Veterans Healthcare Administration chest X-ray dataset (VA-CXR). The VA-CXR dataset comprises over 259k chest X-ray images spanning between the years 2010 and 2022. Results: The validation of ground truth and the assessment of multi-label classification performance across various NLP extraction tools revealed that the VA-CXR dataset exhibited lower disagreement rates than the MIMIC-CXR datasets. Additionally, there were notable differences in AUC scores between models utilizing CheXpert and CheXbert. When evaluating multi-label classification performance across different datasets, minimal domain shift was observed in unseen datasets, except for the label Enlarged Cardiomediastinum. The study year's subgroup analyses exhibited the most significant variations in multi-label classification model performance. These findings underscore the importance of considering domain shifts in chest X-ray classification tasks, particularly concerning study years. Conclusion: Our study reveals the significant impact of domain shift and demographic factors on chest X-ray classification, emphasizing the need for improved transfer learning and equitable model development. Addressing these challenges is crucial for advancing medical imaging and enhancing patient care.
Read more8/1/2024
0
The Impact of Scanner Domain Shift on Deep Learning Performance in Medical Imaging: an Experimental Study
Gregory Szumel, Brian Guo, Darui Lu, Rongze Gui, Tingyu Wang, Nicholas Konz, Maciej A. Mazurowski
Purpose: Medical images acquired using different scanners and protocols can differ substantially in their appearance. This phenomenon, scanner domain shift, can result in a drop in the performance of deep neural networks which are trained on data acquired by one scanner and tested on another. This significant practical issue is well-acknowledged, however, no systematic study of the issue is available across different modalities and diagnostic tasks. Materials and Methods: In this paper, we present a broad experimental study evaluating the impact of scanner domain shift on convolutional neural network performance for different automated diagnostic tasks. We evaluate this phenomenon in common radiological modalities, including X-ray, CT, and MRI. Results: We find that network performance on data from a different scanner is almost always worse than on same-scanner data, and we quantify the degree of performance drop across different datasets. Notably, we find that this drop is most severe for MRI, moderate for X-ray, and quite small for CT, on average, which we attribute to the standardized nature of CT acquisition systems which is not present in MRI or X-ray. We also study how injecting varying amounts of target domain data into the training set, as well as adding noise to the training data, helps with generalization. Conclusion: Our results provide extensive experimental evidence and quantification of the extent of performance drop caused by scanner domain shift in deep learning across different modalities, with the goal of guiding the future development of robust deep learning models for medical image analysis.
Read more9/9/2024
0
New!A Systematic Review of Generalization Research in Medical Image Classification
Sarah Matta, Mathieu Lamard, Philippe Zhang, Alexandre Le Guilcher, Laurent Borderie, B'eatrice Cochener, Gwenol'e Quellec
Numerous Deep Learning (DL) classification models have been developed for a large spectrum of medical image analysis applications, which promises to reshape various facets of medical practice. Despite early advances in DL model validation and implementation, which encourage healthcare institutions to adopt them, a fundamental questions remain: how can these models effectively handle domain shift? This question is crucial to limit DL models performance degradation. Medical data are dynamic and prone to domain shift, due to multiple factors. Two main shift types can occur over time: 1) covariate shift mainly arising due to updates to medical equipment and 2) concept shift caused by inter-grader variability. To mitigate the problem of domain shift, existing surveys mainly focus on domain adaptation techniques, with an emphasis on covariate shift. More generally, no work has reviewed the state-of-the-art solutions while focusing on the shift types. This paper aims to explore existing domain generalization methods for DL-based classification models through a systematic review of literature. It proposes a taxonomy based on the shift type they aim to solve. Papers were searched and gathered on Scopus till 10 April 2023, and after the eligibility screening and quality evaluation, 77 articles were identified. Exclusion criteria included: lack of methodological novelty (e.g., reviews, benchmarks), experiments conducted on a single mono-center dataset, or articles not written in English. The results of this paper show that learning based methods are emerging, for both shift types. Finally, we discuss future challenges, including the need for improved evaluation protocols and benchmarks, and envisioned future developments to achieve robust, generalized models for medical image classification.
Read more9/18/2024
🤿
0
MS-Twins: Multi-Scale Deep Self-Attention Networks for Medical Image Segmentation
Jing Xu
Although transformer is preferred in natural language processing, some studies has only been applied to the field of medical imaging in recent years. For its long-term dependency, the transformer is expected to contribute to unconventional convolution neural net conquer their inherent spatial induction bias. The lately suggested transformer-based segmentation method only uses the transformer as an auxiliary module to help encode the global context into a convolutional representation. How to optimally integrate self-attention with convolution has not been investigated in depth. To solve the problem, this paper proposes MS-Twins (Multi-Scale Twins), which is a powerful segmentation model on account of the bond of self-attention and convolution. MS-Twins can better capture semantic and fine-grained information by combining different scales and cascading features. Compared with the existing network structure, MS-Twins has made progress on the previous method based on the transformer of two in common use data sets, Synapse and ACDC. In particular, the performance of MS-Twins on Synapse is 8% higher than SwinUNet. Even compared with nnUNet, the best entirely convoluted medical image segmentation network, the performance of MS-Twins on Synapse and ACDC still has a bit advantage.
Read more9/17/2024