EcoRank: Budget-Constrained Text Re-ranking Using Large Language Models

Read original: arXiv:2402.10866 - Published 5/29/2024 by Muhammad Shihab Rashid, Jannat Ara Meem, Yue Dong, Vagelis Hristidis

💬

Overview

Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in text re-ranking, a process that involves queries and candidate passages.
However, the cost of this process can be high due to API charges based on the number of input and output tokens.
The paper proposes methods to maximize re-ranking performance while staying within a given budget, by optimizing prompt choices, LLM APIs, and budget allocation.

Plain English Explanation

Large language models (LLMs) are powerful AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text. These models have been very successful at the task of text re-ranking. This means they can take a query (like a question) and a set of candidate passages (pieces of text), and then rank the passages in order of how well they match the query.

However, the process of using LLMs for text re-ranking can be quite expensive. This is because LLMs are accessed through API services, and each time you use the LLM, you have to pay a fee based on the number of words (or "tokens") in the input and output. So the more you use the LLM, the more it costs.

The researchers in this paper wanted to find a way to get the most out of text re-ranking with LLMs, while staying within a certain budget. They explored different strategies for choosing the best prompts (the instructions given to the LLM) and the best LLM APIs to use, in order to maximize the re-ranking performance while minimizing the cost.

Their most efficient method, called EcoRank, uses a two-step approach to jointly optimize the budget allocation across different prompt strategies and LLM APIs. This allows them to get the best re-ranking results possible without going over their budget.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a suite of budget-constrained methods for performing text re-ranking using a set of LLM APIs. The key elements of their approach include:

Prompt Strategies: The researchers explored three main types of prompting strategies for text re-ranking: pointwise, listwise, and pairwise. Each of these strategies has different tradeoffs in terms of performance and cost.
Budget Optimization: The researchers developed methods to navigate the vast search spaces of prompt choices, LLM APIs, and budget splits, in order to maximize re-ranking performance within a given budget.
EcoRank: The most efficient method proposed is called EcoRank, which is a two-layered pipeline that jointly optimizes decisions regarding budget allocation across prompt strategies and LLM APIs.

The researchers evaluated their methods on four popular question-answering and passage re-ranking datasets. Their results show that EcoRank outperforms other budget-aware supervised and unsupervised baselines, demonstrating the effectiveness of their approach.

Critical Analysis

The paper addresses an important practical concern in the use of LLMs for text re-ranking - the high cost associated with API charges. By proposing methods to optimize performance within a given budget, the researchers make LLM-based text re-ranking more accessible and feasible for real-world applications.

However, the paper does not explore the potential limitations or drawbacks of the EcoRank method. For example, it's unclear how well the approach would scale to larger or more complex datasets, or how sensitive the performance is to changes in the budget constraint.

Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the tradeoffs between the different prompting strategies (pointwise, listwise, pairwise) in terms of their cost-benefit characteristics. A deeper analysis of these tradeoffs could help practitioners make more informed choices when deploying LLM-based text re-ranking systems.

Overall, the research presented in this paper is a valuable contribution to the field of LLM-powered text re-ranking, and the proposed EcoRank method offers a promising approach for optimizing performance within budget constraints. However, further exploration of the method's limitations and tradeoffs could strengthen the research and provide a more comprehensive understanding for potential users.

Conclusion

This paper addresses the challenge of making large language model-based text re-ranking more cost-effective by proposing a suite of budget-constrained methods. The researchers' most efficient approach, called EcoRank, jointly optimizes decisions regarding budget allocation across different prompt strategies and LLM APIs.

The experimental results demonstrate that EcoRank outperforms other budget-aware baselines, indicating that it is a promising solution for deploying high-performing text re-ranking systems while staying within a given budget. This work has important implications for making LLM-powered applications more accessible and feasible, particularly in domains where cost is a significant concern.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

💬

EcoRank: Budget-Constrained Text Re-ranking Using Large Language Models

Muhammad Shihab Rashid, Jannat Ara Meem, Yue Dong, Vagelis Hristidis

Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance in text re-ranking. This process includes queries and candidate passages in the prompts, utilizing pointwise, listwise, and pairwise prompting strategies. A limitation of these ranking strategies with LLMs is their cost: the process can become expensive due to API charges, which are based on the number of input and output tokens. We study how to maximize the re-ranking performance given a budget, by navigating the vast search spaces of prompt choices, LLM APIs, and budget splits. We propose a suite of budget-constrained methods to perform text re-ranking using a set of LLM APIs. Our most efficient method, called EcoRank, is a two-layered pipeline that jointly optimizes decisions regarding budget allocation across prompt strategies and LLM APIs. Our experimental results on four popular QA and passage reranking datasets show that EcoRank outperforms other budget-aware supervised and unsupervised baselines.

5/29/2024

TourRank: Utilizing Large Language Models for Documents Ranking with a Tournament-Inspired Strategy

Yiqun Chen, Qi Liu, Yi Zhang, Weiwei Sun, Daiting Shi, Jiaxin Mao, Dawei Yin

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly employed in zero-shot documents ranking, yielding commendable results. However, several significant challenges still persist in LLMs for ranking: (1) LLMs are constrained by limited input length, precluding them from processing a large number of documents simultaneously; (2) The output document sequence is influenced by the input order of documents, resulting in inconsistent ranking outcomes; (3) Achieving a balance between cost and ranking performance is quite challenging. To tackle these issues, we introduce a novel documents ranking method called TourRank, which is inspired by the tournament mechanism. This approach alleviates the impact of LLM's limited input length through intelligent grouping, while the tournament-like points system ensures robust ranking, mitigating the influence of the document input sequence. We test TourRank with different LLMs on the TREC DL datasets and the BEIR benchmark. Experimental results show that TourRank achieves state-of-the-art performance at a reasonable cost.

6/18/2024

Towards More Relevant Product Search Ranking Via Large Language Models: An Empirical Study

Qi Liu, Atul Singh, Jingbo Liu, Cun Mu, Zheng Yan

Training Learning-to-Rank models for e-commerce product search ranking can be challenging due to the lack of a gold standard of ranking relevance. In this paper, we decompose ranking relevance into content-based and engagement-based aspects, and we propose to leverage Large Language Models (LLMs) for both label and feature generation in model training, primarily aiming to improve the model's predictive capability for content-based relevance. Additionally, we introduce different sigmoid transformations on the LLM outputs to polarize relevance scores in labeling, enhancing the model's ability to balance content-based and engagement-based relevances and thus prioritize highly relevant items overall. Comprehensive online tests and offline evaluations are also conducted for the proposed design. Our work sheds light on advanced strategies for integrating LLMs into e-commerce product search ranking model training, offering a pathway to more effective and balanced models with improved ranking relevance.

9/27/2024

A Two-Stage Adaptation of Large Language Models for Text Ranking

Longhui Zhang, Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Pengjun Xie, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang

Text ranking is a critical task in information retrieval. Recent advances in pre-trained language models (PLMs), especially large language models (LLMs), present new opportunities for applying them to text ranking. While supervised fine-tuning (SFT) with ranking data has been widely explored to better align PLMs with text ranking goals, previous studies have focused primarily on encoder-only and encoder-decoder PLMs. Research on leveraging decoder-only LLMs for text ranking remains scarce. An exception to this is RankLLaMA, which uses direct SFT to explore LLaMA's potential for text ranking. In this work, we propose a two-stage progressive paradigm to better adapt LLMs to text ranking. First, we conduct continual pre-training (CPT) of LLMs on a large weakly-supervised corpus. Second, we perform SFT, and propose an improved optimization strategy building upon RankLLaMA. Our experimental results on multiple benchmarks show that our approach outperforms previous methods in both in-domain and out-domain scenarios.

6/4/2024