Elucidating the Design Space of Dataset Condensation
2404.13733
0
0
Abstract
Dataset condensation, a concept within data-centric learning, efficiently transfers critical attributes from an original dataset to a synthetic version, maintaining both diversity and realism. This approach significantly improves model training efficiency and is adaptable across multiple application areas. Previous methods in dataset condensation have faced challenges: some incur high computational costs which limit scalability to larger datasets (e.g., MTT, DREAM, and TESLA), while others are restricted to less optimal design spaces, which could hinder potential improvements, especially in smaller datasets (e.g., SRe2L, G-VBSM, and RDED). To address these limitations, we propose a comprehensive design framework that includes specific, effective strategies like implementing soft category-aware matching and adjusting the learning rate schedule. These strategies are grounded in empirical evidence and theoretical backing. Our resulting approach, Elucidate Dataset Condensation (EDC), establishes a benchmark for both small and large-scale dataset condensation. In our testing, EDC achieves state-of-the-art accuracy, reaching 48.6% on ImageNet-1k with a ResNet-18 model at an IPC of 10, which corresponds to a compression ratio of 0.78%. This performance exceeds those of SRe2L, G-VBSM, and RDED by margins of 27.3%, 17.2%, and 6.6%, respectively.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the design space of dataset condensation, a technique that aims to create small synthetic datasets that can effectively train machine learning models.
- The authors identify key design choices and empirically evaluate their impact on the performance of condensed datasets.
- The paper provides insights that can guide the development of more effective dataset condensation methods.
Plain English Explanation
Dataset condensation is a technique that tries to take a large, existing dataset and create a much smaller synthetic dataset that can still train machine learning models effectively. This is useful because smaller datasets are faster and cheaper to work with, but we don't want to lose the performance of the original, larger dataset.
The authors of this paper looked at the different "design choices" - the various knobs and options - that go into creating these condensed datasets. They ran experiments to see how each of these design choices affected the final performance of the condensed dataset. This allowed them to identify the most important factors and provide guidance on how to create better condensed datasets in the future.
Some of the key design choices they explored include link to "Multisize Dataset Condensation" the size of the condensed dataset, how to initialize the synthetic data points, and link to "Self-Supervised Dataset Distillation for Good Compression" whether to use self-supervised learning techniques. Their findings can help researchers and engineers develop more powerful and efficient dataset condensation methods.
Technical Explanation
The paper examines the key design choices involved in dataset condensation, a technique that compresses a large dataset into a much smaller synthetic dataset while preserving the performance of machine learning models trained on the original data.
The authors systematically evaluate the impact of various design choices, including:
- link to "Data Upcycling via Knowledge Distillation for Image Super-Resolution" the size of the condensed dataset
- the initialization method for the synthetic data points
- link to "Large-Scale Dataset Pruning via Dynamic Uncertainty" whether to use self-supervised learning
Through extensive experiments, the authors identify the most important factors and provide insights that can guide the development of more effective dataset condensation methods. For example, they find that initializing the synthetic data using a generative model pre-trained on the original dataset can lead to significant performance gains.
The paper also explores the tradeoffs involved in dataset condensation, such as the balance between the size of the condensed dataset and its performance. These insights can help researchers and practitioners make informed design choices when applying dataset condensation to their machine learning problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the design space for dataset condensation, which is a valuable contribution to the field. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research:
- The experiments are primarily conducted on image classification tasks, so the findings may not generalize to other domains such as natural language processing or reinforcement learning.
- The paper does not explore the impact of dataset condensation on model robustness or generalization, which are also important considerations.
- The authors suggest that further research is needed to understand the theoretical underpinnings of dataset condensation and how it relates to other data efficiency techniques, such as link to "Data-Free Knowledge Distillation for Fine-Grained Visual Recognition" knowledge distillation.
Additionally, while the paper provides a thorough empirical evaluation, it would be interesting to see the authors explore the computational and memory requirements of the various design choices, as this can be a practical concern for real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper significantly advances the understanding of dataset condensation by systematically exploring the design space and identifying the key factors that influence the performance of condensed datasets. The insights provided can guide researchers and practitioners in developing more effective and efficient dataset condensation methods, which have the potential to greatly reduce the computational and data requirements of machine learning models. The authors have laid the groundwork for further research in this important area of machine learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Multisize Dataset Condensation
Yang He, Lingao Xiao, Joey Tianyi Zhou, Ivor Tsang
0
0
While dataset condensation effectively enhances training efficiency, its application in on-device scenarios brings unique challenges. 1) Due to the fluctuating computational resources of these devices, there's a demand for a flexible dataset size that diverges from a predefined size. 2) The limited computational power on devices often prevents additional condensation operations. These two challenges connect to the subset degradation problem in traditional dataset condensation: a subset from a larger condensed dataset is often unrepresentative compared to directly condensing the whole dataset to that smaller size. In this paper, we propose Multisize Dataset Condensation (MDC) by compressing N condensation processes into a single condensation process to obtain datasets with multiple sizes. Specifically, we introduce an adaptive subset loss on top of the basic condensation loss to mitigate the subset degradation problem. Our MDC method offers several benefits: 1) No additional condensation process is required; 2) reduced storage requirement by reusing condensed images. Experiments validate our findings on networks including ConvNet, ResNet and DenseNet, and datasets including SVHN, CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100 and ImageNet. For example, we achieved 5.22%-6.40% average accuracy gains on condensing CIFAR-10 to ten images per class. Code is available at: https://github.com/he-y/Multisize-Dataset-Condensation.
4/16/2024
Calibrated Dataset Condensation for Faster Hyperparameter Search
Mucong Ding, Yuancheng Xu, Tahseen Rabbani, Xiaoyu Liu, Brian Gravelle, Teresa Ranadive, Tai-Ching Tuan, Furong Huang
0
0
Dataset condensation can be used to reduce the computational cost of training multiple models on a large dataset by condensing the training dataset into a small synthetic set. State-of-the-art approaches rely on matching the model gradients between the real and synthetic data. However, there is no theoretical guarantee of the generalizability of the condensed data: data condensation often generalizes poorly across hyperparameters/architectures in practice. This paper considers a different condensation objective specifically geared toward hyperparameter search. We aim to generate a synthetic validation dataset so that the validation-performance rankings of the models, with different hyperparameters, on the condensed and original datasets are comparable. We propose a novel hyperparameter-calibrated dataset condensation (HCDC) algorithm, which obtains the synthetic validation dataset by matching the hyperparameter gradients computed via implicit differentiation and efficient inverse Hessian approximation. Experiments demonstrate that the proposed framework effectively maintains the validation-performance rankings of models and speeds up hyperparameter/architecture search for tasks on both images and graphs.
5/29/2024
Ameliorate Spurious Correlations in Dataset Condensation
Justin Cui, Ruochen Wang, Yuanhao Xiong, Cho-Jui Hsieh
0
0
Dataset Condensation has emerged as a technique for compressing large datasets into smaller synthetic counterparts, facilitating downstream training tasks. In this paper, we study the impact of bias inside the original dataset on the performance of dataset condensation. With a comprehensive empirical evaluation on canonical datasets with color, corruption and background biases, we found that color and background biases in the original dataset will be amplified through the condensation process, resulting in a notable decline in the performance of models trained on the condensed dataset, while corruption bias is suppressed through the condensation process. To reduce bias amplification in dataset condensation, we introduce a simple yet highly effective approach based on a sample reweighting scheme utilizing kernel density estimation. Empirical results on multiple real-world and synthetic datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method. Notably, on CMNIST with 5% bias-conflict ratio and IPC 50, our method achieves 91.5% test accuracy compared to 23.8% from vanilla DM, boosting the performance by 67.7%, whereas applying state-of-the-art debiasing method on the same dataset only achieves 53.7% accuracy. Our findings highlight the importance of addressing biases in dataset condensation and provide a promising avenue to address bias amplification in the process.
6/12/2024
Koopcon: A new approach towards smarter and less complex learning
Vahid Jebraeeli, Bo Jiang, Derya Cansever, Hamid Krim
0
0
In the era of big data, the sheer volume and complexity of datasets pose significant challenges in machine learning, particularly in image processing tasks. This paper introduces an innovative Autoencoder-based Dataset Condensation Model backed by Koopman operator theory that effectively packs large datasets into compact, information-rich representations. Inspired by the predictive coding mechanisms of the human brain, our model leverages a novel approach to encode and reconstruct data, maintaining essential features and label distributions. The condensation process utilizes an autoencoder neural network architecture, coupled with Optimal Transport theory and Wasserstein distance, to minimize the distributional discrepancies between the original and synthesized datasets. We present a two-stage implementation strategy: first, condensing the large dataset into a smaller synthesized subset; second, evaluating the synthesized data by training a classifier and comparing its performance with a classifier trained on an equivalent subset of the original data. Our experimental results demonstrate that the classifiers trained on condensed data exhibit comparable performance to those trained on the original datasets, thus affirming the efficacy of our condensation model. This work not only contributes to the reduction of computational resources but also paves the way for efficient data handling in constrained environments, marking a significant step forward in data-efficient machine learning.
5/24/2024