Enhancing Multi-modal Learning: Meta-learned Cross-modal Knowledge Distillation for Handling Missing Modalities
2405.07155
0
0
🤖
Abstract
In multi-modal learning, some modalities are more influential than others, and their absence can have a significant impact on classification/segmentation accuracy. Hence, an important research question is if it is possible for trained multi-modal models to have high accuracy even when influential modalities are absent from the input data. In this paper, we propose a novel approach called Meta-learned Cross-modal Knowledge Distillation (MCKD) to address this research question. MCKD adaptively estimates the importance weight of each modality through a meta-learning process. These dynamically learned modality importance weights are used in a pairwise cross-modal knowledge distillation process to transfer the knowledge from the modalities with higher importance weight to the modalities with lower importance weight. This cross-modal knowledge distillation produces a highly accurate model even with the absence of influential modalities. Differently from previous methods in the field, our approach is designed to work in multiple tasks (e.g., segmentation and classification) with minimal adaptation. Experimental results on the Brain tumor Segmentation Dataset 2018 (BraTS2018) and the Audiovision-MNIST classification dataset demonstrate the superiority of MCKD over current state-of-the-art models. Particularly in BraTS2018, we achieve substantial improvements of 3.51% for enhancing tumor, 2.19% for tumor core, and 1.14% for the whole tumor in terms of average segmentation Dice score.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- In multi-modal learning, some modalities (data sources) are more important than others for accurate classification or segmentation.
- Removing influential modalities can significantly impact the model's performance.
- This paper proposes a novel approach called Meta-learned Cross-modal Knowledge Distillation (MCKD) to maintain high accuracy even when influential modalities are missing.
Plain English Explanation
When working with multiple data sources (modalities) like images, text, and audio, some sources are more valuable than others for making accurate predictions. For example, image data might be more important than audio for classifying brain tumors. If you remove the important modalities, the model's performance suffers greatly.
The researchers in this paper developed a new technique called MCKD to address this problem. MCKD learns to automatically determine how important each modality is. It then uses this information to transfer the valuable knowledge from the more important modalities to the less important ones. This allows the model to maintain high accuracy even when key modalities are missing from the input data.
Unlike previous methods, MCKD can be adapted to work on different tasks like classification and segmentation with minimal changes. Experiments on brain tumor segmentation and audiovisual classification showed MCKD outperforms other state-of-the-art approaches, achieving substantial improvements in accuracy.
Technical Explanation
The core idea behind MCKD is to adaptively estimate the importance of each modality through a meta-learning process. These dynamically learned modality importance weights are then used to guide a pairwise cross-modal knowledge distillation process. This allows the model to transfer knowledge from the more influential modalities to the less influential ones.
Compared to prior work in cross-modal knowledge distillation and combating missing modalities, MCKD has two key advantages:
- It can be applied to both classification and segmentation tasks with minimal adaptation, unlike previous methods tailored to specific tasks.
- It automatically learns the relative importance of each modality, rather than relying on heuristics or manual tuning.
Experimental results on the BraTS2018 brain tumor segmentation dataset and the Audiovisual-MNIST classification dataset demonstrate the superiority of MCKD over current state-of-the-art models. In the BraTS2018 task, MCKD achieved substantial improvements of 3.51%, 2.19%, and 1.14% in Dice score for the enhancing tumor, tumor core, and whole tumor, respectively, compared to previous methods like distilling privileged multimodal information and multimodal feature distillation.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of MCKD and demonstrates its effectiveness on two different tasks. However, the authors acknowledge that their approach relies on the availability of multiple modalities during training, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the performance of MCKD when the relative importance of modalities changes significantly between the training and testing phases. This could be an area for further research, as the dynamic modality importance weights learned by MCKD may not generalize well to such situations.
It would also be interesting to see how MCKD compares to other multi-modal techniques like correlation-decoupled knowledge distillation or the use of ensemble methods to combine predictions from individual modalities.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach called MCKD that can maintain high accuracy in multi-modal learning even when influential modalities are missing from the input data. By adaptively estimating the importance of each modality and using this information to guide cross-modal knowledge distillation, MCKD outperforms state-of-the-art methods on both classification and segmentation tasks.
The versatility and performance improvements demonstrated by MCKD suggest that it could have significant impact on real-world applications that rely on multi-modal data, such as medical imaging, autonomous driving, and human-computer interaction.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌿
Correlation-Decoupled Knowledge Distillation for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis with Incomplete Modalities
Mingcheng Li, Dingkang Yang, Xiao Zhao, Shuaibing Wang, Yan Wang, Kun Yang, Mingyang Sun, Dongliang Kou, Ziyun Qian, Lihua Zhang
0
0
Multimodal sentiment analysis (MSA) aims to understand human sentiment through multimodal data. Most MSA efforts are based on the assumption of modality completeness. However, in real-world applications, some practical factors cause uncertain modality missingness, which drastically degrades the model's performance. To this end, we propose a Correlation-decoupled Knowledge Distillation (CorrKD) framework for the MSA task under uncertain missing modalities. Specifically, we present a sample-level contrastive distillation mechanism that transfers comprehensive knowledge containing cross-sample correlations to reconstruct missing semantics. Moreover, a category-guided prototype distillation mechanism is introduced to capture cross-category correlations using category prototypes to align feature distributions and generate favorable joint representations. Eventually, we design a response-disentangled consistency distillation strategy to optimize the sentiment decision boundaries of the student network through response disentanglement and mutual information maximization. Comprehensive experiments on three datasets indicate that our framework can achieve favorable improvements compared with several baselines.
6/11/2024
On the Theory of Cross-Modality Distillation with Contrastive Learning
Hangyu Lin, Chen Liu, Chengming Xu, Zhengqi Gao, Yanwei Fu, Yuan Yao
0
0
Cross-modality distillation arises as an important topic for data modalities containing limited knowledge such as depth maps and high-quality sketches. Such techniques are of great importance, especially for memory and privacy-restricted scenarios where labeled training data is generally unavailable. To solve the problem, existing label-free methods leverage a few pairwise unlabeled data to distill the knowledge by aligning features or statistics between the source and target modalities. For instance, one typically aims to minimize the L2 distance or contrastive loss between the learned features of pairs of samples in the source (e.g. image) and the target (e.g. sketch) modalities. However, most algorithms in this domain only focus on the experimental results but lack theoretical insight. To bridge the gap between the theory and practical method of cross-modality distillation, we first formulate a general framework of cross-modality contrastive distillation (CMCD), built upon contrastive learning that leverages both positive and negative correspondence, towards a better distillation of generalizable features. Furthermore, we establish a thorough convergence analysis that reveals that the distance between source and target modalities significantly impacts the test error on downstream tasks within the target modality which is also validated by the empirical results. Extensive experimental results show that our algorithm outperforms existing algorithms consistently by a margin of 2-3% across diverse modalities and tasks, covering modalities of image, sketch, depth map, and audio and tasks of recognition and segmentation.
5/29/2024
🌿
Combating Missing Modalities in Egocentric Videos at Test Time
Merey Ramazanova, Alejandro Pardo, Bernard Ghanem, Motasem Alfarra
0
0
Understanding videos that contain multiple modalities is crucial, especially in egocentric videos, where combining various sensory inputs significantly improves tasks like action recognition and moment localization. However, real-world applications often face challenges with incomplete modalities due to privacy concerns, efficiency needs, or hardware issues. Current methods, while effective, often necessitate retraining the model entirely to handle missing modalities, making them computationally intensive, particularly with large training datasets. In this study, we propose a novel approach to address this issue at test time without requiring retraining. We frame the problem as a test-time adaptation task, where the model adjusts to the available unlabeled data at test time. Our method, MiDl~(Mutual information with self-Distillation), encourages the model to be insensitive to the specific modality source present during testing by minimizing the mutual information between the prediction and the available modality. Additionally, we incorporate self-distillation to maintain the model's original performance when both modalities are available. MiDl represents the first self-supervised, online solution for handling missing modalities exclusively at test time. Through experiments with various pretrained models and datasets, MiDl demonstrates substantial performance improvement without the need for retraining.
4/24/2024
👁️
Distilling Privileged Multimodal Information for Expression Recognition using Optimal Transport
Muhammad Haseeb Aslam, Muhammad Osama Zeeshan, Soufiane Belharbi, Marco Pedersoli, Alessandro Koerich, Simon Bacon, Eric Granger
0
0
Deep learning models for multimodal expression recognition have reached remarkable performance in controlled laboratory environments because of their ability to learn complementary and redundant semantic information. However, these models struggle in the wild, mainly because of the unavailability and quality of modalities used for training. In practice, only a subset of the training-time modalities may be available at test time. Learning with privileged information enables models to exploit data from additional modalities that are only available during training. State-of-the-art knowledge distillation (KD) methods have been proposed to distill information from multiple teacher models (each trained on a modality) to a common student model. These privileged KD methods typically utilize point-to-point matching, yet have no explicit mechanism to capture the structural information in the teacher representation space formed by introducing the privileged modality. Experiments were performed on two challenging problems - pain estimation on the Biovid dataset (ordinal classification) and arousal-valance prediction on the Affwild2 dataset (regression). Results show that our proposed method can outperform state-of-the-art privileged KD methods on these problems. The diversity among modalities and fusion architectures indicates that PKDOT is modality- and model-agnostic.
4/30/2024