Distilling Privileged Multimodal Information for Expression Recognition using Optimal Transport

Overview

• Deep learning models have achieved remarkable performance in controlled laboratory settings for multimodal expression recognition, but struggle in real-world "in the wild" scenarios.
• This is mainly due to the unavailability and quality of modalities (e.g., audio, video, text) used for training these models.
• In practice, only a subset of the training-time modalities may be available at test time.
• Learning with privileged information enables models to exploit additional modalities that are only available during training.
• State-of-the-art knowledge distillation (KD) methods have been proposed to distill information from multiple teacher models (each trained on a modality) to a common student model.
• However, these privileged KD methods typically utilize point-to-point matching and lack an explicit mechanism to capture the structural information in the teacher representation space.

Plain English Explanation

Deep learning models have become very good at recognizing human expressions, like emotions or pain levels, when they are trained and tested in controlled lab environments. This is because these models can learn to combine and use information from multiple sources, like audio, video, and text, to make their predictions.

However, these models struggle when used in the real world, where the available information (modalities) may be different from what they were trained on. For example, maybe the video is missing, or the audio quality is poor. This makes it harder for the models to make accurate predictions.

To address this, researchers have explored "learning with privileged information." This means the model has access to extra information during training that may not be available during actual use. For example, the model might be trained using high-quality audio, video, and text, but then only have access to lower-quality video and text at test time.

State-of-the-art knowledge distillation (KD) methods have been developed to help these models learn from the privileged information. The idea is to have multiple "teacher" models, each trained on a different modality, and then distill their knowledge into a single "student" model.

However, these KD methods have a limitation - they focus on matching the outputs of the teacher models, but don't explicitly capture the underlying structure and relationships between the different modalities. This structural information could be very useful for the student model to learn.

Technical Explanation

The researchers in this paper propose a new knowledge distillation method called PKDOT (Privileged Knowledge Distillation with Optimal Transport) that explicitly captures the structural information in the teacher representation space.

They evaluate their method on two challenging multimodal problems:

1. Pain estimation on the Biovid dataset (an ordinal classification task)
2. Arousal-valence prediction on the Affwild2 dataset (a regression task)

The results show that PKDOT can outperform other state-of-the-art privileged KD methods on these tasks. The researchers also find that PKDOT is "modality- and model-agnostic," meaning it can work well with different types of modalities and model architectures.

The key innovation of PKDOT is that it uses optimal transport to align the representations of the teacher models, rather than just matching the outputs. This allows the student model to learn the underlying structure and relationships between the modalities, which is crucial for performance in real-world scenarios where not all modalities may be available.

Critical Analysis

The researchers do a good job of motivating the problem and highlighting the limitations of existing privileged KD methods. The proposed PKDOT approach seems promising, and the results on the two benchmark datasets are compelling.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research:

• The experiments are still conducted in controlled lab settings, and it's unclear how well the method would generalize to truly unconstrained "in the wild" scenarios.
• The paper does not discuss the computational overhead or training time of PKDOT compared to other KD methods, which could be an important practical consideration.
• The paper focuses on two specific multimodal tasks, and it would be helpful to see evaluations on a wider range of problems to better understand the general applicability of the approach.

Additionally, while the correlation-decoupled knowledge distillation and adaptive affinity-based generalization methods are mentioned in the overview, it's not clear how they relate to or could potentially complement the PKDOT approach.

Overall, this is a promising piece of research that advances the state-of-the-art in multimodal learning with privileged information. However, there are still opportunities to further explore the limitations and potential extensions of the PKDOT method.

Conclusion

The paper proposes a novel knowledge distillation method called PKDOT that can effectively leverage privileged information (additional modalities available only during training) to improve the performance of multimodal expression recognition models in real-world scenarios.

The key innovation of PKDOT is its use of optimal transport to capture the structural relationships between modalities in the teacher representation space, rather than just matching the output predictions. This allows the student model to learn a more robust and generalized representation that can better handle missing or lower-quality modalities at test time.

The experimental results on pain estimation and arousal-valence prediction tasks demonstrate the superiority of PKDOT over other state-of-the-art privileged KD methods. The modality- and model-agnostic nature of PKDOT also suggests it could be a versatile and widely applicable technique for multimodal learning.

Overall, this research represents an important step forward in addressing the challenges of multimodal learning in real-world conditions, and the PKDOT method could have significant implications for a wide range of applications, from healthcare to human-computer interaction.