Enhancing Uncertainty Communication in Time Series Predictions: Insights and Recommendations

Read original: arXiv:2408.12365 - Published 8/23/2024 by Apoorva Karagappa, Pawandeep Kaur Betz, Jonas Gilg, Moritz Zeumer, Andreas Gerndt, Bernhard Preim
Total Score

0

Enhancing Uncertainty Communication in Time Series Predictions: Insights and Recommendations

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores how to enhance the communication of uncertainty in time series predictions.
  • The authors provide insights and recommendations to improve the presentation of uncertainty information in forecasting models.
  • The goal is to help users better understand and interpret the inherent uncertainty in time series predictions.

Plain English Explanation

Forecasting the future is challenging, as there is always some uncertainty involved. This paper looks at ways to better communicate that uncertainty to the people using the forecasts. The authors give suggestions on how to present uncertainty information in a clearer and more meaningful way.

For example, they discuss using visualization techniques to show the range of possible outcomes, rather than just a single predicted value. This can help users understand the reliability of the forecast and make more informed decisions.

The paper also explores how aleatoric uncertainty (uncertainty due to inherent randomness in the data) can be better identified and communicated. Providing this context can give users a more complete picture of the limitations of the forecasting model.

Overall, the goal is to empower users to interpret time series predictions more effectively by giving them a better sense of the inherent uncertainty involved. This can lead to more informed decision-making and a deeper understanding of the limitations of forecasting models.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by discussing the motivation for enhancing uncertainty communication in time series predictions. The authors note that while forecasting models have become increasingly sophisticated, the presentation of uncertainty information often lags behind. This can lead to overconfidence in predictions and poor decision-making.

The authors then review related work on communicating uncertainty, including the use of visualization techniques and probabilistic forecasting methods. They identify key challenges, such as the difficulty of translating statistical concepts into intuitive representations.

The core of the paper focuses on providing specific recommendations for enhancing uncertainty communication. This includes the use of interactive visualizations, multilayered uncertainty representations, and clear communication of the limitations and assumptions of the forecasting model.

The authors also discuss the importance of considering the end-user's needs and decision-making context when designing uncertainty communication strategies. They emphasize the need for user testing and iterative refinement to ensure the uncertainty information is effectively conveyed.

Critical Analysis

The paper offers a thoughtful and well-researched approach to addressing a crucial challenge in time series forecasting. The authors provide a comprehensive review of the relevant literature and present a coherent set of recommendations grounded in empirical evidence.

One potential limitation is that the recommendations may not be equally applicable across all domains and decision-making contexts. The authors acknowledge this and encourage further research to investigate the nuances of uncertainty communication in specific use cases.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the technical details of the proposed uncertainty communication techniques. While this choice makes the content more accessible to a general audience, it leaves some unanswered questions about the practical implementation and evaluation of the recommendations.

Overall, the paper makes a strong case for the importance of enhancing uncertainty communication in time series predictions. The insights and recommendations provided serve as a valuable starting point for researchers and practitioners interested in improving the interpretability and trustworthiness of forecasting models.

Conclusion

This paper offers a timely and important contribution to the field of time series forecasting. By focusing on the communication of uncertainty, the authors highlight a critical aspect of forecasting that is often overlooked or underemphasized.

The proposed recommendations provide a roadmap for developing more transparent and user-friendly forecasting systems. Implementing these strategies can lead to better-informed decision-making, reduced overconfidence, and a greater appreciation for the inherent limitations of predictive models.

As the authors note, further research is needed to refine and validate the proposed approaches across diverse domains and user groups. Nevertheless, this paper serves as a valuable resource for anyone interested in enhancing the interpretability and trustworthiness of time series predictions.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Enhancing Uncertainty Communication in Time Series Predictions: Insights and Recommendations
Total Score

0

Enhancing Uncertainty Communication in Time Series Predictions: Insights and Recommendations

Apoorva Karagappa, Pawandeep Kaur Betz, Jonas Gilg, Moritz Zeumer, Andreas Gerndt, Bernhard Preim

As the world increasingly relies on mathematical models for forecasts in different areas, effective communication of uncertainty in time series predictions is important for informed decision making. This study explores how users estimate probabilistic uncertainty in time series predictions under different variants of line charts depicting uncertainty. It examines the role of individual characteristics and the influence of user-reported metrics on uncertainty estimations. By addressing these aspects, this paper aims to enhance the understanding of uncertainty visualization and for improving communication in time series forecast visualizations and the design of prediction data dashboards.As the world increasingly relies on mathematical models for forecasts in different areas, effective communication of uncertainty in time series predictions is important for informed decision making. This study explores how users estimate probabilistic uncertainty in time series predictions under different variants of line charts depicting uncertainty. It examines the role of individual characteristics and the influence of user-reported metrics on uncertainty estimations. By addressing these aspects, this paper aims to enhance the understanding of uncertainty visualization and for improving communication in time series forecast visualizations and the design of prediction data dashboards.

Read more

8/23/2024

From Delays to Densities: Exploring Data Uncertainty through Speech, Text, and Visualization
Total Score

0

From Delays to Densities: Exploring Data Uncertainty through Speech, Text, and Visualization

Chase Stokes, Chelsea Sanker, Bridget Cogley, Vidya Setlur

Understanding and communicating data uncertainty is crucial for making informed decisions in sectors like finance and healthcare. Previous work has explored how to express uncertainty in various modes. For example, uncertainty can be expressed visually with quantile dot plots or linguistically with hedge words and prosody. Our research aims to systematically explore how variations within each mode contribute to communicating uncertainty to the user; this allows us to better understand each mode's affordances and limitations. We completed an exploration of the uncertainty design space based on pilot studies and ran two crowdsourced experiments examining how speech, text, and visualization modes and variants within them impact decision-making with uncertain data. Visualization and text were most effective for rational decision-making, though text resulted in lower confidence. Speech garnered the highest trust despite sometimes leading to risky decisions. Results from these studies indicate meaningful trade-offs among modes of information and encourage exploration of multimodal data representations.

Read more

4/15/2024

Voicing Uncertainty: How Speech, Text, and Visualizations Influence Decisions with Data Uncertainty
Total Score

0

Voicing Uncertainty: How Speech, Text, and Visualizations Influence Decisions with Data Uncertainty

Chase Stokes, Chelsea Sanker, Bridget Cogley, Vidya Setlur

Understanding and communicating data uncertainty is crucial for informed decision-making across various domains, including finance, healthcare, and public policy. This study investigates the impact of gender and acoustic variables on decision-making, confidence, and trust through a crowdsourced experiment. We compared visualization-only representations of uncertainty to text-forward and speech-forward bimodal representations, including multiple synthetic voices across gender. Speech-forward representations led to an increase in risky decisions, and text-forward representations led to lower confidence. Contrary to prior work, speech-forward forecasts did not receive higher ratings of trust. Higher normalized pitch led to a slight increase in decision confidence, but other voice characteristics had minimal impact on decisions and trust. An exploratory analysis of accented speech showed consistent results with the main experiment and additionally indicated lower trust ratings for information presented in Indian and Kenyan accents. The results underscore the importance of considering acoustic and contextual factors in presentation of data uncertainty.

Read more

8/19/2024

Identifying Drivers of Predictive Aleatoric Uncertainty
Total Score

0

Identifying Drivers of Predictive Aleatoric Uncertainty

Pascal Iversen, Simon Witzke, Katharina Baum, Bernhard Y. Renard

Explainability and uncertainty quantification are two pillars of trustable artificial intelligence. However, the reasoning behind uncertainty estimates is generally left unexplained. Identifying the drivers of uncertainty complements explanations of point predictions in recognizing model limitations and enhances trust in decisions and their communication. So far, explanations of uncertainties have been rarely studied. The few exceptions rely on Bayesian neural networks or technically intricate approaches, such as auxiliary generative models, thereby hindering their broad adoption. We present a simple approach to explain predictive aleatoric uncertainties. We estimate uncertainty as predictive variance by adapting a neural network with a Gaussian output distribution. Subsequently, we apply out-of-the-box explainers to the model's variance output. This approach can explain uncertainty influences more reliably than literature baselines, which we evaluate in a synthetic setting with a known data-generating process. We further adapt multiple metrics from conventional XAI research to uncertainty explanations. We quantify our findings with a nuanced benchmark analysis that includes real-world datasets. Finally, we apply our approach to an age regression model and discover reasonable sources of uncertainty. Overall, we explain uncertainty estimates with little modifications to the model architecture and demonstrate that our approach competes effectively with more intricate methods.

Read more

5/31/2024