Entropy Law: The Story Behind Data Compression and LLM Performance

Read original: arXiv:2407.06645 - Published 7/12/2024 by Mingjia Yin, Chuhan Wu, Yufei Wang, Hao Wang, Wei Guo, Yasheng Wang, Yong Liu, Ruiming Tang, Defu Lian, Enhong Chen
Total Score

0

Entropy Law: The Story Behind Data Compression and LLM Performance

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

• This paper explores the fundamental principles governing data compression and their implications for the performance of large language models (LLMs). • It draws connections between the entropy law, which underpins data compression, and the scalability and generalization capabilities of LLMs. • The research provides insights into the role of information theory in understanding the limits and potential of current AI systems.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses the deep connection between the fundamental laws of information theory, particularly the entropy law, and the performance of large language models (LLMs). The entropy law explains why data can be compressed - it states that the more information is contained in a message, the more it can be compressed.

The researchers show that this same principle applies to the way LLMs learn and generalize. Just as data can be compressed without losing its essential information, LLMs can extract the most important patterns and concepts from large datasets and apply them to new contexts. The paper argues that the compression capabilities of LLMs, as measured by how well they can predict unseen data, are fundamentally limited by the entropy of the underlying data.

This means that no matter how large or complex an LLM becomes, its performance will be constrained by the inherent complexity and predictability of the training data. The researchers demonstrate this principle through experiments that show a direct correlation between the compressibility of a dataset and the performance of LLMs trained on that data.

The insights from this research have important implications for the development of more efficient and capable AI systems. By understanding the fundamental limits imposed by information theory, researchers can focus on techniques to improve the quality and relevance of training data, rather than solely relying on scaling up model size and compute power.

Technical Explanation

The paper establishes a deep connection between the entropy law, which underpins data compression, and the performance of large language models (LLMs). The entropy law states that the more information is contained in a message, the more it can be compressed without losing its essential content.

The researchers demonstrate that this same principle applies to the way LLMs learn and generalize. They show that the compression capabilities of LLMs, as measured by how well they can predict unseen data, are fundamentally limited by the entropy of the underlying training data. This means that no matter how large or complex an LLM becomes, its performance will be constrained by the inherent complexity and predictability of the data it is trained on.

To support this claim, the paper presents a series of experiments that explore the relationship between dataset compressibility and LLM performance. The researchers use the GZIP compression algorithm as a proxy for measuring the entropy of various datasets and then train LLMs on these datasets to assess their predictive capabilities.

The results show a clear correlation between dataset compressibility and LLM performance, suggesting that the entropy law is a fundamental constraint on the scalability and generalization capabilities of current AI systems. Furthermore, the researchers develop techniques to measure the importance of individual training samples and use this information to selectively prune the training data, thereby improving the efficiency of the learning process.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling and rigorous exploration of the connections between information theory and the performance of large language models. By linking the entropy law to the inherent limits of LLM scalability and generalization, the researchers provide a valuable theoretical framework for understanding the capabilities and constraints of current AI systems.

One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses primarily on the GZIP compression algorithm as a proxy for measuring dataset entropy. While GZIP is a widely used and well-understood compression method, it may not capture all the nuances of information content in complex natural language data. Future research could explore the use of more advanced compression techniques or information-theoretic measures to further refine the analysis.

Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific architectural choices and training strategies that may influence an LLM's ability to extract and leverage the most important patterns and concepts from a given dataset. Exploring the interplay between information-theoretic principles and model design could provide additional insights into the development of more efficient and capable AI systems.

Conclusion

This paper makes a significant contribution to our understanding of the fundamental constraints and potential of large language models. By drawing a direct connection between the entropy law, which underpins data compression, and the performance of LLMs, the researchers provide a theoretically grounded framework for reasoning about the scalability and generalization capabilities of current AI systems.

The insights from this work have important implications for the future of AI development. By recognizing the inherent limits imposed by information theory, researchers can focus on techniques to improve the quality and relevance of training data, rather than solely relying on scaling up model size and compute power. This could lead to the creation of more efficient and capable AI systems that can better harness the power of available information and better serve the needs of society.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Entropy Law: The Story Behind Data Compression and LLM Performance
Total Score

0

Entropy Law: The Story Behind Data Compression and LLM Performance

Mingjia Yin, Chuhan Wu, Yufei Wang, Hao Wang, Wei Guo, Yasheng Wang, Yong Liu, Ruiming Tang, Defu Lian, Enhong Chen

Data is the cornerstone of large language models (LLMs), but not all data is useful for model learning. Carefully selected data can better elicit the capabilities of LLMs with much less computational overhead. Most methods concentrate on evaluating the quality of individual samples in data selection, while the combinatorial effects among samples are neglected. Even if each sample is of perfect quality, their combinations may be suboptimal in teaching LLMs due to their intrinsic homogeneity or contradiction. In this paper, we aim to uncover the underlying relationships between LLM performance and data selection. Inspired by the information compression nature of LLMs, we uncover an ``entropy law'' that connects LLM performance with data compression ratio and first-epoch training loss, which reflect the information redundancy of a dataset and the mastery of inherent knowledge encoded in this dataset, respectively. Through both theoretical deduction and empirical evaluation, we find that model performance is negatively correlated to the compression ratio of training data, which usually yields a lower training loss. Based on the findings of the entropy law, we propose a quite efficient and universal data selection method named textbf{ZIP} for training LLMs, which aim to prioritize data subsets exhibiting a low compression ratio. Based on a multi-stage algorithm that selects diverse data in a greedy manner, we can obtain a good data subset with satisfactory diversity. Extensive experiments have been conducted to validate the entropy law and the superiority of ZIP across different LLM backbones and alignment stages. We also present an interesting application of entropy law that can detect potential performance risks at the beginning of model training.

Read more

7/12/2024

🏷️

Total Score

0

Ranking LLMs by compression

Peijia Guo, Ziguang Li, Haibo Hu, Chao Huang, Ming Li, Rui Zhang

We conceptualize the process of understanding as information compression, and propose a method for ranking large language models (LLMs) based on lossless data compression. We demonstrate the equivalence of compression length under arithmetic coding with cumulative negative log probabilities when using a large language model as a prior, that is, the pre-training phase of the model is essentially the process of learning the optimal coding length. At the same time, the evaluation metric compression ratio can be obtained without actual compression, which greatly saves overhead. In this paper, we use five large language models as priors for compression, then compare their performance on challenging natural language processing tasks, including sentence completion, question answering, and coreference resolution. Experimental results show that compression ratio and model performance are positively correlated, so it can be used as a general metric to evaluate large language models.

Read more

6/21/2024

Understanding is Compression
Total Score

0

Understanding is Compression

Ziguang Li, Chao Huang, Xuliang Wang, Haibo Hu, Cole Wyeth, Dongbo Bu, Quan Yu, Wen Gao, Xingwu Liu, Ming Li

Modern data compression methods are slowly reaching their limits after 80 years of research, millions of papers, and wide range of applications. Yet, the extravagant 6G communication speed requirement raises a major open question for revolutionary new ideas of data compression. We have previously shown all understanding or learning are compression, under reasonable assumptions. Large language models (LLMs) understand data better than ever before. Can they help us to compress data? The LLMs may be seen to approximate the uncomputable Solomonoff induction. Therefore, under this new uncomputable paradigm, we present LMCompress. LMCompress shatters all previous lossless compression algorithms, doubling the lossless compression ratios of JPEG-XL for images, FLAC for audios, and H.264 for videos, and quadrupling the compression ratio of bz2 for texts. The better a large model understands the data, the better LMCompress compresses.

Read more

8/22/2024

Compression Represents Intelligence Linearly
Total Score

0

Compression Represents Intelligence Linearly

Yuzhen Huang, Jinghan Zhang, Zifei Shan, Junxian He

There is a belief that learning to compress well will lead to intelligence. Recently, language modeling has been shown to be equivalent to compression, which offers a compelling rationale for the success of large language models (LLMs): the development of more advanced language models is essentially enhancing compression which facilitates intelligence. Despite such appealing discussions, little empirical evidence is present for the interplay between compression and intelligence. In this work, we examine their relationship in the context of LLMs, treating LLMs as data compressors. Given the abstract concept of intelligence, we adopt the average downstream benchmark scores as a surrogate, specifically targeting intelligence related to knowledge and commonsense, coding, and mathematical reasoning. Across 12 benchmarks, our study brings together 31 public LLMs that originate from diverse organizations. Remarkably, we find that LLMs' intelligence -- reflected by average benchmark scores -- almost linearly correlates with their ability to compress external text corpora. These results provide concrete evidence supporting the belief that superior compression indicates greater intelligence. Furthermore, our findings suggest that compression efficiency, as an unsupervised metric derived from raw text corpora, serves as a reliable evaluation measure that is linearly associated with the model capabilities. We open-source our compression datasets as well as our data collection pipelines to facilitate future researchers to assess compression properly.

Read more

8/20/2024