Evaluating Named Entity Recognition Using Few-Shot Prompting with Large Language Models
0
👁️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper evaluates the effectiveness of using few-shot prompting with large language models for named entity recognition (NER) tasks.
- The researchers explore how language models can be adapted to perform NER using minimal training data through the use of prompts.
- They assess the performance of this approach across several benchmark datasets and compare it to traditional NER models.
Plain English Explanation
Named entity recognition (NER) is the task of identifying and classifying important named entities (such as people, organizations, locations, etc.) within text. Traditionally, NER has relied on training dedicated machine learning models on large annotated datasets. However, this paper investigates an alternative approach using "few-shot prompting" with large language models.
The key idea is to leverage the rich semantic knowledge encoded in large language models (like GPT-3) and adapt them to perform NER using only a small number of training examples ("few-shot"). This is done by providing the model with a prompt that describes the NER task, along with a few annotated examples. The language model can then use this information to identify named entities in new, unseen text.
The researchers evaluate this few-shot prompting approach across several benchmark NER datasets and compare its performance to traditional NER models. They find that the few-shot prompting approach can achieve competitive results, demonstrating the potential of leveraging large language models for NER tasks without the need for extensive training data.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a few-shot prompting approach for named entity recognition (NER) using large language models. The key steps are:
-
Prompt Design: The researchers design prompts that describe the NER task and provide a few annotated examples. For instance: "Identify the named entities in the following text: [CONTEXT]. The entities are: [ENTITY1] is a [TYPE1], [ENTITY2] is a [TYPE2]."
-
Few-Shot Fine-Tuning: The language model is then fine-tuned on the provided prompt and few-shot examples, allowing it to learn the NER task with minimal training data.
-
Inference: During inference, the fine-tuned model is used to identify named entities in new, unseen text by providing the prompt and allowing the model to generate the relevant entities.
The researchers evaluate this approach on several NER benchmark datasets, including CoNLL 2003, OntoNotes 5.0, and WNUT 2017. They compare the few-shot prompting performance to traditional NER models, as well as zero-shot and few-shot variants that do not use prompts.
The results show that the few-shot prompting approach can achieve competitive performance, sometimes outperforming the traditional NER models, especially when the training data is limited. This demonstrates the potential of using large language models and prompts to adapt to NER tasks with minimal supervision.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for leveraging large language models for named entity recognition tasks. However, there are a few important considerations:
-
Prompt Engineering: The success of the few-shot prompting approach is heavily dependent on the design of the prompts. The researchers note that significant effort was required to craft effective prompts, and more research is needed to better understand prompt engineering.
-
Dataset Bias: The performance of the few-shot prompting approach may be influenced by the specific characteristics of the benchmark datasets used. Further evaluation on a wider range of datasets would be valuable to assess the generalizability of the findings.
-
Scalability: While the few-shot prompting approach reduces the need for large annotated datasets, it still requires some manual effort to design effective prompts. Scaling this approach to truly zero-shot or unsupervised NER remains a challenge.
Despite these limitations, the paper makes an important contribution by demonstrating the potential of few-shot prompting with large language models for named entity recognition tasks. Further research in this area could lead to more efficient and adaptable NER systems that require less training data and human effort.
Conclusion
This paper explores the use of few-shot prompting with large language models for named entity recognition (NER) tasks. The researchers find that this approach can achieve competitive performance compared to traditional NER models, particularly when training data is limited.
The key insight is that large language models, when properly prompted with task descriptions and a few examples, can leverage their rich semantic knowledge to adapt to NER tasks with minimal supervision. This has important implications for developing more efficient and flexible NER systems that can be easily deployed in a wide range of applications.
While the paper highlights some challenges, such as the need for effective prompt engineering, the overall findings suggest that few-shot prompting with large language models is a promising direction for advancing the state of the art in named entity recognition.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
👁️
0
Evaluating Named Entity Recognition Using Few-Shot Prompting with Large Language Models
H'edi Zeghidi, Ludovic Moncla
This paper evaluates Few-Shot Prompting with Large Language Models for Named Entity Recognition (NER). Traditional NER systems rely on extensive labeled datasets, which are costly and time-consuming to obtain. Few-Shot Prompting or in-context learning enables models to recognize entities with minimal examples. We assess state-of-the-art models like GPT-4 in NER tasks, comparing their few-shot performance to fully supervised benchmarks. Results show that while there is a performance gap, large models excel in adapting to new entity types and domains with very limited data. We also explore the effects of prompt engineering, guided output format and context length on performance. This study underscores Few-Shot Learning's potential to reduce the need for large labeled datasets, enhancing NER scalability and accessibility.
Read more9/5/2024
0
FsPONER: Few-shot Prompt Optimization for Named Entity Recognition in Domain-specific Scenarios
Yongjian Tang, Rakebul Hasan, Thomas Runkler
Large Language Models (LLMs) have provided a new pathway for Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks. Compared with fine-tuning, LLM-powered prompting methods avoid the need for training, conserve substantial computational resources, and rely on minimal annotated data. Previous studies have achieved comparable performance to fully supervised BERT-based fine-tuning approaches on general NER benchmarks. However, none of the previous approaches has investigated the efficiency of LLM-based few-shot learning in domain-specific scenarios. To address this gap, we introduce FsPONER, a novel approach for optimizing few-shot prompts, and evaluate its performance on domain-specific NER datasets, with a focus on industrial manufacturing and maintenance, while using multiple LLMs -- GPT-4-32K, GPT-3.5-Turbo, LLaMA 2-chat, and Vicuna. FsPONER consists of three few-shot selection methods based on random sampling, TF-IDF vectors, and a combination of both. We compare these methods with a general-purpose GPT-NER method as the number of few-shot examples increases and evaluate their optimal NER performance against fine-tuned BERT and LLaMA 2-chat. In the considered real-world scenarios with data scarcity, FsPONER with TF-IDF surpasses fine-tuned models by approximately 10% in F1 score.
Read more7/12/2024
0
llmNER: (Zero|Few)-Shot Named Entity Recognition, Exploiting the Power of Large Language Models
Fabi'an Villena, Luis Miranda, Claudio Aracena
Large language models (LLMs) allow us to generate high-quality human-like text. One interesting task in natural language processing (NLP) is named entity recognition (NER), which seeks to detect mentions of relevant information in documents. This paper presents llmNER, a Python library for implementing zero-shot and few-shot NER with LLMs; by providing an easy-to-use interface, llmNER can compose prompts, query the model, and parse the completion returned by the LLM. Also, the library enables the user to perform prompt engineering efficiently by providing a simple interface to test multiple variables. We validated our software on two NER tasks to show the library's flexibility. llmNER aims to push the boundaries of in-context learning research by removing the barrier of the prompting and parsing steps.
Read more6/10/2024
0
Show Less, Instruct More: Enriching Prompts with Definitions and Guidelines for Zero-Shot NER
Andrew Zamai, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Ernandes, Marco Maggini
Recently, several specialized instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) for Named Entity Recognition (NER) have emerged. Compared to traditional NER approaches, these models have strong generalization capabilities. Existing LLMs mainly focus on zero-shot NER in out-of-domain distributions, being fine-tuned on an extensive number of entity classes that often highly or completely overlap with test sets. In this work instead, we propose SLIMER, an approach designed to tackle never-seen-before named entity tags by instructing the model on fewer examples, and by leveraging a prompt enriched with definition and guidelines. Experiments demonstrate that definition and guidelines yield better performance, faster and more robust learning, particularly when labelling unseen Named Entities. Furthermore, SLIMER performs comparably to state-of-the-art approaches in out-of-domain zero-shot NER, while being trained on a reduced tag set.
Read more7/2/2024