Exact and Approximate Conformal Inference for Multi-Output Regression
2210.17405
0
0
🤯
Abstract
It is common in machine learning to estimate a response $y$ given covariate information $x$. However, these predictions alone do not quantify any uncertainty associated with said predictions. One way to overcome this deficiency is with conformal inference methods, which construct a set containing the unobserved response $y$ with a prescribed probability. Unfortunately, even with a one-dimensional response, conformal inference is computationally expensive despite recent encouraging advances. In this paper, we explore multi-output regression, delivering exact derivations of conformal inference $p$-values when the predictive model can be described as a linear function of $y$. Additionally, we propose texttt{unionCP} and a multivariate extension of texttt{rootCP} as efficient ways of approximating the conformal prediction region for a wide array of multi-output predictors, both linear and nonlinear, while preserving computational advantages. We also provide both theoretical and empirical evidence of the effectiveness of these methods using both real-world and simulated data.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Machine learning is commonly used to predict a response variable
ygiven covariate informationx - However, these predictions do not quantify the uncertainty associated with the predictions
- Conformal inference methods can construct a set containing the unobserved response
ywith a prescribed probability - Even for one-dimensional responses, conformal inference can be computationally expensive
- This paper explores multi-output regression and efficient ways to approximate conformal prediction regions for both linear and nonlinear multi-output predictors
Plain English Explanation
In machine learning, we often try to predict a value y based on some input information x. For example, we might try to predict someone's income based on their age, education level, and other factors. However, these predictions alone don't tell us how certain we are about the predicted value.
Conformal inference methods can help with this by providing a range of possible values for y that contains the true value with a specified probability. This is useful because it gives us a sense of how reliable our predictions are.
Unfortunately, conformal inference can be computationally expensive, especially when we're trying to predict multiple values at once (e.g., predicting someone's income, education level, and job title all at the same time). This paper explores more efficient ways to do conformal inference for these multi-output prediction problems.
The key ideas are:
- Deriving exact formulas for the conformal inference "p-values" (a way of measuring how likely the true value is to be in the predicted range) when the predictive model is a linear function of
y. - Proposing two new methods, called
unionCPandrootCP, that can efficiently approximate the conformal prediction region for a wide range of multi-output predictors, both linear and nonlinear.
The paper provides both theoretical and empirical evidence to show that these new methods are effective, using both real-world and simulated data. This could make conformal inference much more practical for multi-output prediction problems in machine learning.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the problem of multi-output regression, where the goal is to predict a vector of response variables y given covariate information x. The authors explore ways to construct conformal prediction regions for these multi-output problems, which provide a set containing the unobserved response y with a prescribed probability.
The authors first derive exact formulas for the conformal inference p-values when the predictive model can be described as a linear function of y. This is an important special case, as linear models are widely used in practice.
To handle more general multi-output predictors, both linear and nonlinear, the authors propose two efficient approximation methods:
- unionCP: This method constructs the conformal prediction region by taking the union of the individual conformal prediction intervals for each output variable.
- rootCP: This is a multivariate extension of the "root" conformal prediction approach, which provides tighter prediction regions than unionCP.
The paper provides both theoretical and empirical evidence to demonstrate the effectiveness of these new methods. The theoretical analysis shows that the methods preserve important properties like validity and efficiency. The empirical evaluation, using both real-world and simulated data, confirms that the methods can accurately quantify uncertainty in multi-output prediction tasks while being computationally efficient.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes valuable contributions to the field of conformal inference for multi-output regression problems. The derivation of exact p-value formulas for the linear case and the proposal of the unionCP and rootCP methods are significant advancements that could make conformal inference more practical for a wider range of applications.
That said, the paper does not address some potential limitations and areas for further research:
- Scalability: While the proposed methods are more efficient than previous approaches, they may still struggle with very high-dimensional output spaces. Further research on scalable conformal inference methods would be useful.
- Nonlinear predictors: The paper focuses on both linear and nonlinear multi-output predictors, but the theoretical analysis is more complete for the linear case. Extending the theoretical guarantees to more general nonlinear predictors could further strengthen the contributions.
- Real-world applicability: The empirical evaluation uses both simulated and real-world datasets, but more extensive testing on a broader range of real-world problems would help demonstrate the practical utility of the proposed methods.
Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in the field of conformal inference for multi-output regression. The new methods and insights provided could pave the way for more widespread adoption of these powerful uncertainty quantification techniques in machine learning.
Conclusion
This paper explores efficient ways to perform conformal inference for multi-output regression problems, where the goal is to predict a vector of response variables y given covariate information x. The authors derive exact formulas for conformal inference p-values in the linear case and propose two new approximation methods, unionCP and rootCP, that can handle a wide range of both linear and nonlinear multi-output predictors.
The theoretical and empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of these new methods, which could make conformal inference much more practical for real-world multi-output prediction tasks. This is an important contribution, as quantifying uncertainty in machine learning predictions is crucial for many applications.
While the paper does not address all potential limitations, it represents a significant advancement in the field of conformal inference and opens up avenues for further research and development in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Conformal Prediction via Regression-as-Classification
Etash Guha, Shlok Natarajan, Thomas Mollenhoff, Mohammad Emtiyaz Khan, Eugene Ndiaye
0
0
Conformal prediction (CP) for regression can be challenging, especially when the output distribution is heteroscedastic, multimodal, or skewed. Some of the issues can be addressed by estimating a distribution over the output, but in reality, such approaches can be sensitive to estimation error and yield unstable intervals.~Here, we circumvent the challenges by converting regression to a classification problem and then use CP for classification to obtain CP sets for regression.~To preserve the ordering of the continuous-output space, we design a new loss function and make necessary modifications to the CP classification techniques.~Empirical results on many benchmarks shows that this simple approach gives surprisingly good results on many practical problems.
4/15/2024
Conformal prediction for multi-dimensional time series by ellipsoidal sets
Chen Xu, Hanyang Jiang, Yao Xie
0
0
Conformal prediction (CP) has been a popular method for uncertainty quantification because it is distribution-free, model-agnostic, and theoretically sound. For forecasting problems in supervised learning, most CP methods focus on building prediction intervals for univariate responses. In this work, we develop a sequential CP method called $texttt{MultiDimSPCI}$ that builds prediction $textit{regions}$ for a multivariate response, especially in the context of multivariate time series, which are not exchangeable. Theoretically, we estimate $textit{finite-sample}$ high-probability bounds on the conditional coverage gap. Empirically, we demonstrate that $texttt{MultiDimSPCI}$ maintains valid coverage on a wide range of multivariate time series while producing smaller prediction regions than CP and non-CP baselines.
5/24/2024
🔮
An Information Theoretic Perspective on Conformal Prediction
Alvaro H. C. Correia, Fabio Valerio Massoli, Christos Louizos, Arash Behboodi
0
0
Conformal Prediction (CP) is a distribution-free uncertainty estimation framework that constructs prediction sets guaranteed to contain the true answer with a user-specified probability. Intuitively, the size of the prediction set encodes a general notion of uncertainty, with larger sets associated with higher degrees of uncertainty. In this work, we leverage information theory to connect conformal prediction to other notions of uncertainty. More precisely, we prove three different ways to upper bound the intrinsic uncertainty, as described by the conditional entropy of the target variable given the inputs, by combining CP with information theoretical inequalities. Moreover, we demonstrate two direct and useful applications of such connection between conformal prediction and information theory: (i) more principled and effective conformal training objectives that generalize previous approaches and enable end-to-end training of machine learning models from scratch, and (ii) a natural mechanism to incorporate side information into conformal prediction. We empirically validate both applications in centralized and federated learning settings, showing our theoretical results translate to lower inefficiency (average prediction set size) for popular CP methods.
6/27/2024
Large language model validity via enhanced conformal prediction methods
John J. Cherian, Isaac Gibbs, Emmanuel J. Cand`es
0
0
We develop new conformal inference methods for obtaining validity guarantees on the output of large language models (LLMs). Prior work in conformal language modeling identifies a subset of the text that satisfies a high-probability guarantee of correctness. These methods work by filtering claims from the LLM's original response if a scoring function evaluated on the claim fails to exceed a threshold calibrated via split conformal prediction. Existing methods in this area suffer from two deficiencies. First, the guarantee stated is not conditionally valid. The trustworthiness of the filtering step may vary based on the topic of the response. Second, because the scoring function is imperfect, the filtering step can remove many valuable and accurate claims. We address both of these challenges via two new conformal methods. First, we generalize the conditional conformal procedure of Gibbs et al. (2023) in order to adaptively issue weaker guarantees when they are required to preserve the utility of the output. Second, we show how to systematically improve the quality of the scoring function via a novel algorithm for differentiating through the conditional conformal procedure. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach on both synthetic and real-world datasets.
6/17/2024