Exact Gauss-Newton Optimization for Training Deep Neural Networks

2405.14402

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 5/24/2024 by Mikalai Korbit, Adeyemi D. Adeoye, Alberto Bemporad, Mario Zanon

🛠️

Abstract

We present EGN, a stochastic second-order optimization algorithm that combines the generalized Gauss-Newton (GN) Hessian approximation with low-rank linear algebra to compute the descent direction. Leveraging the Duncan-Guttman matrix identity, the parameter update is obtained by factorizing a matrix which has the size of the mini-batch. This is particularly advantageous for large-scale machine learning problems where the dimension of the neural network parameter vector is several orders of magnitude larger than the batch size. Additionally, we show how improvements such as line search, adaptive regularization, and momentum can be seamlessly added to EGN to further accelerate the algorithm. Moreover, under mild assumptions, we prove that our algorithm converges to an $epsilon$-stationary point at a linear rate. Finally, our numerical experiments demonstrate that EGN consistently exceeds, or at most matches the generalization performance of well-tuned SGD, Adam, and SGN optimizers across various supervised and reinforcement learning tasks.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Presents a new stochastic optimization algorithm called EGN that combines the generalized Gauss-Newton (GN) Hessian approximation with low-rank linear algebra
  • Leverages the Duncan-Guttman matrix identity to compute the parameter updates efficiently, even for large-scale machine learning problems
  • Demonstrates that EGN can be further improved with techniques like line search, adaptive regularization, and momentum
  • Proves that EGN converges to an ε-stationary point at a linear rate under mild assumptions
  • Shows that EGN outperforms or matches the performance of popular optimizers like SGD, Adam, and SGN across various supervised and reinforcement learning tasks

Plain English Explanation

EGN is a new optimization algorithm that aims to solve large-scale machine learning problems more efficiently. Optimization is a crucial step in training machine learning models, as it finds the best set of model parameters to minimize the error on the training data.

EGN works by using a special way to estimate the curvature of the optimization landscape, called the generalized Gauss-Newton (GN) Hessian approximation. This allows EGN to compute the update direction for the model parameters more effectively than traditional methods, especially when the number of parameters is much larger than the size of the data batch being processed.

The key innovation in EGN is how it leverages a mathematical identity called the Duncan-Guttman matrix identity to compute the parameter updates. This makes the updates more efficient, as the computations only involve matrices the size of the data batch, rather than the full parameter vector.

EGN can be further enhanced with techniques like line search, adaptive regularization, and momentum, which help to accelerate the optimization process even more.

The researchers also prove that under reasonable assumptions, EGN is guaranteed to converge to a high-quality solution (an ε-stationary point) at a fast, linear rate. This provides theoretical guarantees about the performance of the algorithm.

Finally, the paper shows that EGN outperforms or matches the performance of popular optimization methods like stochastic gradient descent (SGD), Adam, and SGN across a variety of machine learning tasks, including both supervised learning and reinforcement learning problems.

Technical Explanation

The key technical innovation in EGN is the way it computes the descent direction for the optimization. EGN uses the generalized Gauss-Newton (GN) Hessian approximation, which provides a good estimate of the curvature of the optimization landscape.

To efficiently compute the parameter updates using the GN Hessian, EGN leverages the Duncan-Guttman matrix identity. This allows the updates to be calculated using matrices of size equal to the data batch size, rather than the full parameter vector size. This is particularly advantageous for large-scale machine learning problems, where the number of parameters is much larger than the batch size.

The paper also shows how EGN can be enhanced with line search, adaptive regularization, and momentum techniques to further accelerate the optimization process.

Under mild assumptions, the researchers prove that EGN converges to an ε-stationary point at a linear rate. This means that the algorithm is guaranteed to find a high-quality solution efficiently, providing theoretical guarantees about its performance.

The experimental results demonstrate that EGN consistently outperforms or matches the generalization performance of well-tuned SGD, Adam, and SGN optimizers across a variety of supervised and reinforcement learning tasks.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough theoretical analysis of the EGN algorithm, including proofs of its convergence properties. However, the assumptions required for these theoretical guarantees may not always hold in practice, and the paper does not explore the robustness of EGN to violations of these assumptions.

Additionally, while EGN shows promising results on the evaluated tasks, the paper does not investigate the algorithm's performance on a wider range of machine learning problems, such as training large language models or solving complex optimization problems in other domains.

[The paper also does not compare EGN to more recent optimization methods, such as structure-guided Gauss-Newton or min-max optimization techniques, which may offer additional performance improvements in certain settings.](https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/structure-guided-gauss-newton-method-shallow-relu) Further research would be needed to fully understand EGN's strengths and limitations compared to the state-of-the-art.

Conclusion

EGN is a promising new optimization algorithm that combines the generalized Gauss-Newton Hessian approximation with efficient low-rank linear algebra to solve large-scale machine learning problems. The algorithm's theoretical guarantees and empirical performance across various tasks suggest that it could be a valuable tool for training complex models more effectively.

However, the paper leaves some open questions about the algorithm's robustness and broader applicability that warrant further investigation. As the field of optimization continues to evolve, EGN's contributions may inspire new research directions and inspire the development of even more efficient and versatile optimization methods for machine learning.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

🧠

Regularized Gauss-Newton for Optimizing Overparameterized Neural Networks

Adeyemi D. Adeoye, Philipp Christian Petersen, Alberto Bemporad

YC

0

Reddit

0

The generalized Gauss-Newton (GGN) optimization method incorporates curvature estimates into its solution steps, and provides a good approximation to the Newton method for large-scale optimization problems. GGN has been found particularly interesting for practical training of deep neural networks, not only for its impressive convergence speed, but also for its close relation with neural tangent kernel regression, which is central to recent studies that aim to understand the optimization and generalization properties of neural networks. This work studies a GGN method for optimizing a two-layer neural network with explicit regularization. In particular, we consider a class of generalized self-concordant (GSC) functions that provide smooth approximations to commonly-used penalty terms in the objective function of the optimization problem. This approach provides an adaptive learning rate selection technique that requires little to no tuning for optimal performance. We study the convergence of the two-layer neural network, considered to be overparameterized, in the optimization loop of the resulting GGN method for a given scaling of the network parameters. Our numerical experiments highlight specific aspects of GSC regularization that help to improve generalization of the optimized neural network. The code to reproduce the experimental results is available at https://github.com/adeyemiadeoye/ggn-score-nn.

Read more

4/24/2024

A Structure-Guided Gauss-Newton Method for Shallow ReLU Neural Network

A Structure-Guided Gauss-Newton Method for Shallow ReLU Neural Network

Zhiqiang Cai, Tong Ding, Min Liu, Xinyu Liu, Jianlin Xia

YC

0

Reddit

0

In this paper, we propose a structure-guided Gauss-Newton (SgGN) method for solving least squares problems using a shallow ReLU neural network. The method effectively takes advantage of both the least squares structure and the neural network structure of the objective function. By categorizing the weights and biases of the hidden and output layers of the network as nonlinear and linear parameters, respectively, the method iterates back and forth between the nonlinear and linear parameters. The nonlinear parameters are updated by a damped Gauss-Newton method and the linear ones are updated by a linear solver. Moreover, at the Gauss-Newton step, a special form of the Gauss-Newton matrix is derived for the shallow ReLU neural network and is used for efficient iterations. It is shown that the corresponding mass and Gauss-Newton matrices in the respective linear and nonlinear steps are symmetric and positive definite under reasonable assumptions. Thus, the SgGN method naturally produces an effective search direction without the need of additional techniques like shifting in the Levenberg-Marquardt method to achieve invertibility of the Gauss-Newton matrix. The convergence and accuracy of the method are demonstrated numerically for several challenging function approximation problems, especially those with discontinuities or sharp transition layers that pose significant challenges for commonly used training algorithms in machine learning.

Read more

4/11/2024

Inverse-Free Fast Natural Gradient Descent Method for Deep Learning

Inverse-Free Fast Natural Gradient Descent Method for Deep Learning

Xinwei Ou, Ce Zhu, Xiaolin Huang, Yipeng Liu

YC

0

Reddit

0

Second-order optimization techniques have the potential to achieve faster convergence rates compared to first-order methods through the incorporation of second-order derivatives or statistics. However, their utilization in deep learning is limited due to their computational inefficiency. Various approaches have been proposed to address this issue, primarily centered on minimizing the size of the matrix to be inverted. Nevertheless, the necessity of performing the inverse operation iteratively persists. In this work, we present a fast natural gradient descent (FNGD) method that only requires inversion during the first epoch. Specifically, it is revealed that natural gradient descent (NGD) is essentially a weighted sum of per-sample gradients. Our novel approach further proposes to share these weighted coefficients across epochs without affecting empirical performance. Consequently, FNGD exhibits similarities to the average sum in first-order methods, leading to the computational complexity of FNGD being comparable to that of first-order methods. Extensive experiments on image classification and machine translation tasks demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed FNGD. For training ResNet-18 on CIFAR-100, FNGD can achieve a speedup of 2.07$times$ compared with KFAC. For training Transformer on Multi30K, FNGD outperforms AdamW by 24 BLEU score while requiring almost the same training time.

Read more

4/30/2024

🧠

Stochastic Newton Proximal Extragradient Method

Ruichen Jiang, Micha{l} Derezi'nski, Aryan Mokhtari

YC

0

Reddit

0

Stochastic second-order methods achieve fast local convergence in strongly convex optimization by using noisy Hessian estimates to precondition the gradient. However, these methods typically reach superlinear convergence only when the stochastic Hessian noise diminishes, increasing per-iteration costs over time. Recent work in [arXiv:2204.09266] addressed this with a Hessian averaging scheme that achieves superlinear convergence without higher per-iteration costs. Nonetheless, the method has slow global convergence, requiring up to $tilde{O}(kappa^2)$ iterations to reach the superlinear rate of $tilde{O}((1/t)^{t/2})$, where $kappa$ is the problem's condition number. In this paper, we propose a novel stochastic Newton proximal extragradient method that improves these bounds, achieving a faster global linear rate and reaching the same fast superlinear rate in $tilde{O}(kappa)$ iterations. We accomplish this by extending the Hybrid Proximal Extragradient (HPE) framework, achieving fast global and local convergence rates for strongly convex functions with access to a noisy Hessian oracle.

Read more

6/4/2024