An experimental evaluation of Deep Reinforcement Learning algorithms for HVAC control
2401.05737
0
0
🤿
Abstract
Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) systems are a major driver of energy consumption in commercial and residential buildings. Recent studies have shown that Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) algorithms can outperform traditional reactive controllers. However, DRL-based solutions are generally designed for ad hoc setups and lack standardization for comparison. To fill this gap, this paper provides a critical and reproducible evaluation, in terms of comfort and energy consumption, of several state-of-the-art DRL algorithms for HVAC control. The study examines the controllers' robustness, adaptability, and trade-off between optimization goals by using the Sinergym framework. The results obtained confirm the potential of DRL algorithms, such as SAC and TD3, in complex scenarios and reveal several challenges related to generalization and incremental learning.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper focuses on improving the energy efficiency of Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) systems, which are major consumers of energy in buildings.
- The researchers evaluate the performance of several state-of-the-art Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) algorithms for HVAC control, using a standardized framework called Sinergym.
- The goal is to compare the comfort and energy savings of these DRL-based controllers to traditional reactive controllers.
Plain English Explanation
HVAC systems are a significant source of energy use in both commercial and residential buildings. Recent studies have shown that DRL algorithms can outperform traditional control methods in managing HVAC systems more efficiently. However, these DRL-based solutions are often designed for specific setups and lack a standardized way to compare them.
This paper aims to address this gap by providing a rigorous and reproducible evaluation of several state-of-the-art DRL algorithms for HVAC control. The researchers use the Sinergym framework to assess the controllers' ability to maintain comfort while also reducing energy consumption. They look at how well the controllers adapt to different scenarios and the trade-offs between optimizing for comfort and energy savings.
Technical Explanation
The researchers use the Sinergym framework to create a standardized testbed for evaluating DRL-based HVAC controllers. Sinergym allows them to simulate various building and climate scenarios, providing a consistent environment to compare the performance of different algorithms.
The study examines the robustness, adaptability, and optimization trade-offs of several DRL algorithms, including Soft Actor-Critic (SAC) and Twin Delayed DDPG (TD3). The researchers assess the controllers' ability to maintain occupant comfort while also minimizing energy consumption.
The results confirm the potential of DRL algorithms in managing complex HVAC systems, but also reveal challenges related to generalization and incremental learning. The paper provides valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of these approaches, which can guide future research and development in this area.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thorough and rigorous evaluation of DRL-based HVAC controllers, which is a significant contribution to the field. The use of the Sinergym framework is a notable strength, as it allows for fair and reproducible comparisons between different algorithms.
However, the paper also acknowledges some limitations of the study. For example, the researchers note that the DRL algorithms may struggle with generalization, as their performance can be heavily influenced by the specific training data and scenarios used. Additionally, the paper suggests that incremental learning, where the controllers adapt to changes over time, is an area that requires further investigation.
While the paper demonstrates the potential of DRL for HVAC control, it also highlights the need for continued research to address these challenges. Future studies could explore ways to improve the generalization and adaptability of these algorithms, as well as investigate their performance in even more complex and realistic building environments.
Conclusion
This paper provides a comprehensive and standardized evaluation of several state-of-the-art DRL algorithms for HVAC control. The results confirm the potential of these approaches in improving the energy efficiency of buildings while maintaining occupant comfort. However, the study also reveals important challenges related to generalization and incremental learning that require further research.
The insights from this work can inform the development of more robust and adaptive DRL-based HVAC controllers, which could have significant implications for reducing the environmental impact of buildings and contributing to energy sustainability efforts.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏋️
Employing Federated Learning for Training Autonomous HVAC Systems
Fredrik Hagstrom, Vikas Garg, Fabricio Oliveira
0
0
Buildings account for 40 % of global energy consumption. A considerable portion of building energy consumption stems from heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC), and thus implementing smart, energy-efficient HVAC systems has the potential to significantly impact the course of climate change. In recent years, model-free reinforcement learning algorithms have been increasingly assessed for this purpose due to their ability to learn and adapt purely from experience. They have been shown to outperform classical controllers in terms of energy cost and consumption, as well as thermal comfort. However, their weakness lies in their relatively poor data efficiency, requiring long periods of training to reach acceptable policies, making them inapplicable to real-world controllers directly. Hence, common research goals are to improve the learning speed, as well as to improve their ability to generalize, in order to facilitate transfer learning to unseen building environments. In this paper, we take a federated learning approach to training the reinforcement learning controller of an HVAC system. A global control policy is learned by aggregating local policies trained on multiple data centers located in different climate zones. The goal of the policy is to simultaneously minimize energy consumption and maximize thermal comfort. The federated optimization strategy indirectly increases both the rate at which experience data is collected and the variation in the data. We demonstrate through experimental evaluation that these effects lead to a faster learning speed, as well as greater generalization capabilities in the federated policy compared to any individually trained policy.
5/2/2024
Adaptive Reinforcement Learning for Robot Control
Yu Tang Liu, Nilaksh Singh, Aamir Ahmad
0
0
Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) has shown remarkable success in simulation domains, yet its application in designing robot controllers remains limited, due to its single-task orientation and insufficient adaptability to environmental changes. To overcome these limitations, we present a novel adaptive agent that leverages transfer learning techniques to dynamically adapt policy in response to different tasks and environmental conditions. The approach is validated through the blimp control challenge, where multitasking capabilities and environmental adaptability are essential. The agent is trained using a custom, highly parallelized simulator built on IsaacGym. We perform zero-shot transfer to fly the blimp in the real world to solve various tasks. We share our code at url{https://github.com/robot-perception-group/adaptive_agent/}.
4/30/2024
New!Reinforcement Learning for Efficient Design and Control Co-optimisation of Energy Systems
Marine Cauz, Adrien Bolland, Nicolas Wyrsch, Christophe Ballif
0
0
The ongoing energy transition drives the development of decentralised renewable energy sources, which are heterogeneous and weather-dependent, complicating their integration into energy systems. This study tackles this issue by introducing a novel reinforcement learning (RL) framework tailored for the co-optimisation of design and control in energy systems. Traditionally, the integration of renewable sources in the energy sector has relied on complex mathematical modelling and sequential processes. By leveraging RL's model-free capabilities, the framework eliminates the need for explicit system modelling. By optimising both control and design policies jointly, the framework enhances the integration of renewable sources and improves system efficiency. This contribution paves the way for advanced RL applications in energy management, leading to more efficient and effective use of renewable energy sources.
7/1/2024
↗️
Integrating DeepRL with Robust Low-Level Control in Robotic Manipulators for Non-Repetitive Reaching Tasks
Mehdi Heydari Shahna, Seyed Adel Alizadeh Kolagar, Jouni Mattila
0
0
In robotics, contemporary strategies are learning-based, characterized by a complex black-box nature and a lack of interpretability, which may pose challenges in ensuring stability and safety. To address these issues, we propose integrating a collision-free trajectory planner based on deep reinforcement learning (DRL) with a novel auto-tuning low-level control strategy, all while actively engaging in the learning phase through interactions with the environment. This approach circumvents the control performance and complexities associated with computations while addressing nonrepetitive reaching tasks in the presence of obstacles. First, a model-free DRL agent is employed to plan velocity-bounded motion for a manipulator with 'n' degrees of freedom (DoF), ensuring collision avoidance for the end-effector through joint-level reasoning. The generated reference motion is then input into a robust subsystem-based adaptive controller, which produces the necessary torques, while the cuckoo search optimization (CSO) algorithm enhances control gains to minimize the stabilization and tracking error in the steady state. This approach guarantees robustness and uniform exponential convergence in an unfamiliar environment, despite the presence of uncertainties and disturbances. Theoretical assertions are validated through the presentation of simulation outcomes.
5/16/2024